meat on fridays

  • Thread starter Thread starter spirocatania
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
God bless you and your son and wife. God doesn’t punish us with children; they are always a blessing. However, I’m sure that you would (all things considered) not feel, on sober consideration, that the end (your son and his mother) justify the means (sex out of wedlock). Rather, you’re grateful that despite your own ‘misstep’ you have the blessing of a family. It’s a case of getting more than you deserve, in a good way. May you and your family live long and happy lives and then be forever happy together with Almighty God.
 
Right now I am 23 and I have a 1 year old son. He was conceived out of wedlock but I am not happily married to his mother. If it wasn’t for pre marital sex he wouldn’t be playing right next to me right now, and that would sadden me. He is a great little guy and I am happy with the decisions I have made. If pre marital sex was such a bad thing, I don’t think God would reward me so generously for it.
Premarital sex is not a good idea, like many things we humans do when we let our conscience take a walk. But God tends to make good from our waywardness.

I’m in the same situation and have a brilliant son. The gift of my son does not eradicate my transgression of his coming into being. Humans cannot use sin as a means to an end, however positive we view it. But at the same time, God has granted me some joy in my son’s being in teaching him now what I did not learn in bringing him to the world. A joyous paradox, if you will. 🙂
 
I see that the meat thing is a discipline and sin offereing, however Hebrews 10 says that Christ is not only our atonement for sin, but there is no longer any sacrifice for sin. Christ paid our fine on the cross.
He did indeed; however, it is beneificial to us to participate in His sacrafice. Someone once explained to me that if you were handed a cancelled note for a debt of $1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000, you would be pretty thrilled. You will be thankful to your debtor for that gift. Just because the offering is not required does not mean you shouldn’t make it. God loves it when we are sorry for our sins and He loves it when we try to make good. When I see my children trying to please me, it makes me happy. When I see them doing wrong, it hurts me.

You are absolutely correct that the sacrifice has been made, the debt cancelled, and there is nothing we can do to earn the grace that came with that, but personal sacrifice helps bring us closer to Christ. That is what this is all about.
 
Is there any scripture that says anything about eating meat on Friday? Did Jesus ever say you shouldn’t do it? Do you guys know where the tradition came from? Because I don’t, but I am fairly certain it is not from the Bible.
Well, fasting is certainly Biblical.

There is Christ’s own example of fasting in the desert.

and He also told the faithful - “When you fast, do not look somber as the hypocrites do”

Note He didn’t say “IF you fast”, He said “WHEN” you fast.

Why, because fasting is a type of prayer. And prayer is done well both individually AND in groups. Penetintial Fridays are group fasting. Like any type of group prayer, it could be done at any time, any day of the week.

It is not fitting to fast on Sundays, as it is a celebration of Easter, a reminder that Christ is with us ( and Christ’s disciples did not fast in Christ’s presence.)

So we fast on Friday, as that is the day of the Cross, when we take up our own crosses and suffer with Christ.

In recap, Christ told us to fast, if not Friday, on what day to you propose that the faithful should fast together?
 
I see that the meat thing is a discipline and sin offereing, however Hebrews 10 says that Christ is not only our atonement for sin, but there is no longer any sacrifice for sin. Christ paid our fine on the cross.
Ah, but don’t forget St. Paul’s letter to the Colossians
Now I rejoice in what was suffered for you, and I fill up in my flesh what is still lacking in regard to Christ’s afflictions, for the sake of his body, which is the church.
1 Col 1:24

Christ’s atonement if complete, but yet St. Paul says that it lacks, and our personal suffering fills up that lack.

What is lacking in Christ’s Redemeption. Simply put, are participation in His sufferings. We are called, like St. Paul, to suffer with Him and to offer those sufferings to Christ through His Body, the Church.

Fasting and abstaination are ways of doing that. They also serve to temper the will to the intellect.
 
Is there any scripture that says anything about eating meat on Friday? Did Jesus ever say you shouldn’t do it? Do you guys know where the tradition came from? Because I don’t, but I am fairly certain it is not from the Bible.
Maybe not, but Holy Mother Church pre-dates the Bible by at least a hundred years, so it might be Tradition.
 
Right now I am 23 and I have a 1 year old son. He was conceived out of wedlock but I am now happily married to his mother. ** If it wasn’t for pre marital sex he wouldn’t be playing right next to me right now, and that would sadden me.** He is a great little guy and I am happy with the decisions I have made. If pre marital sex was such a bad thing, I don’t think God would reward me so generously for it.

EDIT: NOW happily married, not “not happily married”
In my opinion, God did not reward you for your sin. This is a very dangerous way to think. Also using this logic, what do you have to say to people that have premarital sex but things do not work out? Now they are single with a baby? The baby is still a gift, but now has to grow up with only one parent? Did God punish them?

You should give thanks to God that He has blessed you with a child, but you should also repent for the premarital sex. I think that children are Gods greatest gift. Through our experiences with our own children, I think we are better able to fathom Gods love for us.

Edit. If you really want to know how Catholics view sex and marriage please read “The Good News About Sex and Marriage” by David West.
 
Oops, the book is by Christopher West. Talk about messing up an Edit :o
 
so is eating meat on fridays a grave mortal sin. i never really thought about it that much until now. my mum cooks and i eat what ever she cooks.

i am feeling stress because i went to confession on friday and went home and ate pizza with meat in it and went mass about 3 times during the weekend. i live in australia.

is it just during lent or is it every friday for the whole year.
AS of 2005 here is the law in Australia:

sydney.catholic.org.au/people/archbishop/addresses/2005/2005221_737.shtml
 
I’m a Wednesday and Friday abstainer–now that’s old school! 🙂

I would tell friends who would ask me the same question (what happened to all the Catholics who ate meat prior to the US indult) that if they were cavalier in one requirement of their faith there was a high degree of probability they were cavalier in others:eek:
 
I’m a Wednesday and Friday abstainer–now that’s old school! 🙂

I would tell friends who would ask me the same question (what happened to all the Catholics who ate meat prior to the US indult) that if they were cavalier in one requirement of their faith there was a high degree of probability they were cavalier in others:eek:
As in, every Wed and Fri the whole year, or just during Lent?

If you say whole year, why Wednesday?
 
so is eating meat on fridays a grave mortal sin. i never really thought about it that much until now. my mum cooks and i eat what ever she cooks.

i .
I don’t know what the discipline is in Australia, look on your diocesan website or ask your pastor. there are several current threads asking the same questions about Friday penitential obligation, or just search on the AAA forum, because the links there will answer your question
 
Since it is no longer a grave sin, what happened to all of the people who went to Hell because they died with that one unconfessed mortal sin on their soul? Are they still in Hell even though the meat restriction was later relaxed?
:confused:
yes they are still in hell because they only way they could have gotten there was by completely rejecting God, and for them the refusal to do penance on the day Christ died was one form of that rejection. They did not get there because they forgot and had a pepperoni pizza one Friday

If my town has a law against jay-walking because they want to prevent people from being killed, even if they rescind the law, somebody who legally runs across the middle of the street and gets hits by a car is going to be just as dead as someone who broke the law when they ran out in the street.

the disciplinary laws of the Church are or have been in place to remind people of what they already know is an obligation. at times the bishops may relax the disciplines removing the “mandatory under pain of sin” obligation, but the objective fact remains that we must do penance. and the objective fact remains that we must obey, the foundation of all true spirituality.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top