P
phil19034
Guest
Here is how it could happen in a 3rd world country:ChristMyLife:![]()
I don’t understand how any of the bolded happens on a case by case basis. The whole premise of what you are asking doesn’t make any sense to me.Would it be better for the rapist to be convicted and sent to prison if it meant the innocent person was also convicted although falsely accused?
Or would it be better for the innocent person to not have any charges brought up against them, but that also means the guilty person gets away with no charges?
To recapitulate: is it preferable for the innocent to suffer punishment together with the guilty? Or is it preferable for both the innocent and the guilty to go free of punishment?
This has to do with MeToo because it has implications for that movement.
If option 1 is preferable, then it is preferable to side with accusers at the risk of innocent men being condemned.
If option 2 is preferable, then it is better to side with those accused who maintain their innocence, even if they are proven guilty by our legal system.
Woman is drudged at a party and raped. But she doesn’t know who the rapist is, but knows it happened at the house because she wakes up there. She calls the police and there is forensic evidence of a rape, but no conclusive DNA evidence to identify the rapist. The members at the party say no one else was there, so the rapist had to be one of the party members. But no one knows who it is (other than rapist himself).
Therefore, in order to make sure the rapist is punished, the third world police imprisons every one at the party until the the criminal confesses or the friends “rat” on him. But since rape is a death sentence in some parts of the world, the criminal doesn’t confess so everyone rots in jail.
Granted - this is a made up scenario, but a very plausible one in some parts of the world.
God bless
Last edited: