Modesty poll

  • Thread starter Thread starter 1inICXC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
imho, any attire that would show off undergarments is definitely immodest. As for length of skirt it is not so much the length that bothers me. If matched with tights or leggings of the same color one does not notice the length so much. Rather what bothers me is the tightness of clothes being wore. I teach part time, high school mostly and I see both boys and girls wearing clothes that are too tight. They may be fully covered but you can still see too much. I would much rather see somewhere wearing a tasteful skirt of a shorter length than one that is too tight.
 
I always start feeling guilty when people say that skirts should come at least to the top of the knee. I am 5’ 7 inches with very long legs. I buy cute skirts and pretty dresses but they always hit me about 3 to 4 inches above the knee because I wear an extra small size. I always wear tights or nylons with them in the winter but I am not going to wear them in the summer. I also wear my skinny jeans with a long thin sweater and boots. I just love to wear the fashions and I wonder if it is wrong to wear these if is not your intent to tempt men. Yes, my skirt might go up an inch or two when I sit down but I take care to pull it down when I sit.
 
your sarcasm is uncharitable. Why can’t you take the arguments put forth at face value and not mock them by suggesting that people who desire less revealing attire also desire to stone people who show more skin? Do you really think this is a reasonable response to something you disagree with?

Bolded are your ad hominem arguments – useless, but designed to sting and defame character, but not to actually improve the discourse by offering thoughtful objections.
I agree ChiRho, I hate sarcasm. I would be hurt if someone spoke to me that way.
 
I always start feeling guilty when people say that skirts should come at least to the top of the knee. I am 5’ 7 inches with very long legs. I buy cute skirts and pretty dresses but they always hit me about 3 to 4 inches above the knee because I wear an extra small size. I always wear tights or nylons with them in the winter but I am not going to wear them in the summer. I also wear my skinny jeans with a long thin sweater and boots. I just love to wear the fashions and I wonder if it is wrong to wear these if is not your intent to tempt men. Yes, my skirt might go up an inch or two when I sit down but I take care to pull it down when I sit.
I am wondering if it is less about the amount of leg/knee you are showing and the more about the amount you are covering up that decides if it is modest. It sounds like you do your best to be modest but at your height this becomes difficult.
 
Interesting…

Perhaps not everyone…

My wife’s wedding dress was strapless. I think her bridesmaids wore strapless dresses too, or perhaps spaghetti straps. I certainly don’t think the dresses were scandalous or immodest (although I presume you’ll disagree) and nothing was said by our priest or any family or friends.

I guess in any discussion of modesty there will be disagreements on where to draw the line.
I’m not sure whether it is because that’s how formal and ,wedding dresses especially, are made nowadays but it’s true that you see A LOT of strapless at weddings and ,ost priests do not complain. I got married in an Orthdox churxh so I wore a shawl but I know that in a Catholic church it would’ve been ok without.

Having said that, strapless on a regular Sunday would not to go well.

And yes, i agree that the other big issue is how fitting the clothing is. On Leah everything is tight, but like I said, when you have a petite figure it’s not scandalous, I would just think it’s inappropiate if younger, more “endowed” girls decided to wear what she does without realizing that it looks different on them.

Now that I’m breastfeeding and have gained more than just a few inches in certain areas I am realizing how hard it is to find clothing that doesn’t attract too much attention to those areas and am feeling much more self-conscious about everything. Thank God for loose tops with elastic waists,
 
Susanne, from the responses on here I think everyone would agree with you, I would consider those the obvious ones.

Knowing there are a lot of conservative Catholics on CAF I wanted their opinions on the knee showing or not because it’s less obvious, come to think of it, sleeveless would be another one, I’ve heard some complaints about that one but it’s not as scandalous as showing cleavage or mini-skirts or strapless tops. And then, there would be heels. Shoes can make a world of a difference.

Again, I prefer some sleeve over no sleeve and below the knee rather than above the knee but it’s good to know that either is acceptable.
Given that this is a conservative forum I kind of expected people to agree with me but I am (always) surprised about people’s views on wedding dresses.
 
This does seem to be the point of this thread. The claim seems to be that anyone attractive is automatically an evil sinner and is personally responsible if however nicely dressed, men think that woman is pretty.

Anyone ugly is off the hook and can show up to Mass naked because the OPs issue isn’t about dress but about female beauty and male attention that comes from it, assumed.

This thread is all about inappropriate boundary issues.

It’s not about women’s attire but about making women responsible for how men react to women around them. Since no one can control anyone else’s feelings, sinful or otherwise, the thread indicates a psychological issue ragarding rage at attractive people and a desire to make them somehow pay for being attractive, perhaps by hoping they will burn in hell because men think they are pretty.

We don’t habitually wear burkha’s in this country, it isn’t the norm and it shouldn’t be required at Church. Are we sure the OP isn’t an Irani Muslim, a 7th Day Adventist or maybe a Hasidic Jew?

Perhaps we could stone women who show their calves at Mass, in big circles of angry jealous women. Oh whoops! Jesus said “let he who is without sin cast the first stone” and in any event, dressing appropriately for church is not a sin, even if the appropriately dressed woman is attractive.

I think this is a personal issue for the OP, best addressed in therapy and it would probably help if she actually were Catholic, had actually ever been to a Mass to see what people really wear there, and actually knew any of the Church’s doctrine. Then perhaps her fantasies about sexuality in Mass would recede and her posted concepts about going to Mass would be less ignorant.
👍👍👍
 
Interesting…

Perhaps not everyone…

My wife’s wedding dress was strapless. I think her bridesmaids wore strapless dresses too, or perhaps spaghetti straps. I certainly don’t think the dresses were scandalous or immodest (although I presume you’ll disagree) and nothing was said by our priest or any family or friends.

I guess in any discussion of modesty there will be disagreements on where to draw the line.
Definitely not everyone, many do not bother any more posting in such threads. I am sure your wife and her bridesmaids were happy and beautiful.
 
I am wondering if it is less about the amount of leg/knee you are showing and the more about the amount you are covering up that decides if it is modest. It sounds like you do your best to be modest but at your height this becomes difficult.
Thank you Joanofarc! Your post was very helpful.🙂
 
I just want to say that, as a gay man, men are immodest when they wear shorts that are too short. I think immodesty can apply to men just as much as women, but it’s not talked about as much.

However, I think this poll is ok to focus on women. Because if you’re a man you should wear pants to Church.
 
I think the setting it is important. None of those would be acceptable for Church and** bra straps showing is never acceptable.**
On the other hand, a stapless gown that isn’t low cut might be perfectly acceptable and modest for a formal occassion.
I agree that it’s unacceptable. It’s one of the disturbing things about the recently published “YOUCAT”- there are quite a few pictures of ladies with their undergarments exposed in this manner.

Pax Christi
 
I think the setting it is important. None of those would be acceptable for Church and bra straps showing is never acceptable.

On the other hand, a stapless gown that isn’t low cut might be perfectly acceptable and modest for a formal occassion.
I used clear bra straps when I wore a strapless dress and I can see them in my photos what would you think about that?
 
On that note, I respect other posters who have values in terms of dress but Im still indecisive as to whats appropriate and what’s not. I do think knees exposed is absolutely not immodest!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top