Moms with young kids are the angriest Americans

  • Thread starter Thread starter Serap
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I have to admit that I get angry a lot. I try not too, but after the 10th sibling fight or rude comment, I start to lose it.

Then I go to bed feeling guilty wishing I had more patience. 😦
 
I have to admit that I get angry a lot. I try not too, but after the 10th sibling fight or rude comment, I start to lose it.

Then I go to bed feeling guilty wishing I had more patience. 😦
And then me, being the well-meaning protector, steps in and makes it worse!

…and I go to bed feeling like a failure…
 
I have to admit that I get angry a lot. I try not too, but after the 10th sibling fight or rude comment, I start to lose it.

Then I go to bed feeling guilty wishing I had more patience. 😦
We all get angry at poor behavior. We all need to pray for more patience. That doesn’t make you an angry person. We are all works in progress. I really dislike the tendency of our culture to label everyone. If they can label you, then they can put you on on a shelf, dismiss you and leave you there. The only label I accept these days is CATHOLIC. Okay, I also claim Mother and Wife. 😛
But that just goes back to my point. If mothers of young children are such angry people, why on earth would they identify with that role which supposedly makes them so angry to begin with? They wouldn’t!
But we always want to renounce vice and cultivate virtue. And a “mea culpa” attitude is healthy to have. But that does not mean that society is right to label someone according to our spiritual struggle.
 
We all get angry at poor behavior. We all need to pray for more patience. That doesn’t make you an angry person. We are all works in progress. I really dislike the tendency of our culture to label everyone. If they can label you, then they can put you on on a shelf, dismiss you and leave you there. The only label I accept these days is CATHOLIC. Okay, I also claim Mother and Wife. 😛
But that just goes back to my point. If mothers of young children are such angry people, why on earth would they identify with that role which supposedly makes them so angry to begin with? They wouldn’t!
But we always want to renounce vice and cultivate virtue. And a “mea culpa” attitude is healthy to have. But that does not mean that society is right to label someone according to our spiritual struggle.
I once confessed to my priest friend that I told my then 2 year old daughter to “shut up” and you know what he said?

“You are being a mother. Stop being so hard on yourself.”
 
What do you think?
Well, if I was a single mom w/young kids, I’d be upset a lot of the time too. It’s really hard when kids are toddlers/preschoolers and you don’t have backup.

And like QuiteCatholic said, working moms have a lot on their plate too.

However, as the parent of a preschooler, every mom has bad days and sometimes the kids really do keep doing bad things over and over again just to test their parents. There are specific reasons for the anger/frustration.

Knowing that this survey was done by NBC just discredits it in my mind. There’s always an agenda when it comes to their reporting.
 
I can’t not jump in :). There are ways to parent that do not involve yelling. We do not need to yell to make our kids behave! Please don’t feel is inevitable; please don’t feel like irritation or anger while parenting young children is inevitable.

I do not hit my children. I do my best not to yell at all, and DS knows it - I apologize when I do and remind him and me that yelling is not how we speak to people or promote peace. He is three.

We are regularly complimented on their behavior, especially at Mass and in restaurants.
 
I can’t not jump in :). There are ways to parent that do not involve yelling. We do not need to yell to make our kids behave! Please don’t feel is inevitable; please don’t feel like irritation or anger while parenting young children is inevitable.

I do not hit my children. I do my best not to yell at all, and DS knows it - I apologize when I do and remind him and me that yelling is not how we speak to people or promote peace. He is three.

We are regularly complimented on their behavior, especially at Mass and in restaurants.
I think we all do our best not to yell at our kids 🤷
 
I can’t not jump in :). There are ways to parent that do not involve yelling. We do not need to yell to make our kids behave! Please don’t feel is inevitable; please don’t feel like irritation or anger while parenting young children is inevitable.

I do not hit my children. I do my best not to yell at all, and DS knows it - I apologize when I do and remind him and me that yelling is not how we speak to people or promote peace. He is three.

We are regularly complimented on their behavior, especially at Mass and in restaurants.
There are also all different kinds of children and all different kinds of families. What worked for me with my oldest when I had no other children has not worked with subsequent children or in a larger family setting. This is one of those areas of liberty in parenting. Sometimes, yelling is to stop a dangerous behavior. Sometimes it is because 3kids running around screaming are so loud the parent cannot otherwise be heard (“Oy you crazy kids, stop and listen!”). Sometimes yelling is necessary because you are nine months preggo and cannot hop up fast enough to avoid danger. So ya scream. Sometimes you gotta yell to RESTORE the peace that your kids are disrupting.

In necessary things, unity. In doubtful things, liberty. In all things, charity.
-St. Augustine
 
I think we all do our best not to yell at our kids 🤷
There are also all different kinds of children and all different kinds of families. What worked for me with my oldest when I had no other children has not worked with subsequent children or in a larger family setting. This is one of those areas of liberty in parenting. Sometimes, yelling is to stop a dangerous behavior. Sometimes it is because 3kids running around screaming are so loud the parent cannot otherwise be heard (“Oy you crazy kids, stop and listen!”). Sometimes yelling is necessary because you are nine months preggo and cannot hop up fast enough to avoid danger. So ya scream. Sometimes you gotta yell to RESTORE the peace that your kids are disrupting.

In necessary things, unity. In doubtful things, liberty. In all things, charity.
-St. Augustine
Yes, but most of the posts here have treated yelling as an inevitable function of parenting. It’s not.
 
I can’t not jump in :). There are ways to parent that do not involve yelling. We do not need to yell to make our kids behave! Please don’t feel is inevitable; please don’t feel like irritation or anger while parenting young children is inevitable.

I do not hit my children. I do my best not to yell at all, and DS knows it - I apologize when I do and remind him and me that yelling is not how we speak to people or promote peace. He is three.

We are regularly complimented on their behavior, especially at Mass and in restaurants.
That’s great that you have found what works for your kids. Personally, though, I think you might have missed the point of the original post. Furthermore, I tend to take with a grain of salt advice from people with so few years experience at parenting. 🤷
 
That’s great that you have found what works for your kids. Personally, though, I think you might have missed the point of the original post. Furthermore, I tend to take with a grain of salt advice from people with so few years experience at parenting. 🤷
We do not need to view our children as adversaries who must be tamed. That seems the general tenor of most threads now, and it’s a sad assumption. I am not a perfect parent. But I do my best to be a peaceful one, even when my children are anything but.
I was offering another viewpoint, and commenting on the general tenor of conversation about children on these forums.
 
I can’t not jump in :). There are ways to parent that do not involve yelling. We do not need to yell to make our kids behave! Please don’t feel is inevitable; please don’t feel like irritation or anger while parenting young children is inevitable.

I do not hit my children. I do my best not to yell at all, and DS knows it - I apologize when I do and remind him and me that yelling is not how we speak to people or promote peace. He is three.

We are regularly complimented on their behavior, especially at Mass and in restaurants.
Okay. But the term “yelling at” does not always mean the same thing. Many times kids will say that they got “yelled at” by an adult even when the adult never raised their voice. “Yelled at” is a term that has come to mean being scolded or told not to do something. This is not a bad thing, in and of itself, though parents should try to avoid losing their temper when they are correcting their kids and avoid raising their voices excessively. Being angry with a child doesn’t automatically assume losing control of your temper and raising your voice. By the same token, there are instances when a parent literally does yell at a child, like when they call them in for dinner, without a hint of anger whatsoever.
 
Yes, but most of the posts here have treated yelling as an inevitable function of parenting. It’s not.
I don’t think that yelling is an inevitable form of parenting, at least not in the sense of being out-of-control raising one’s voice excessively. I only argue that being angry is an inevitable aspect of raising a child.
 
There are also all different kinds of children and all different kinds of families. What worked for me with my oldest when I had no other children has not worked with subsequent children or in a larger family setting. This is one of those areas of liberty in parenting. Sometimes, yelling is to stop a dangerous behavior. Sometimes it is because 3kids running around screaming are so loud the parent cannot otherwise be heard (“Oy you crazy kids, stop and listen!”). Sometimes yelling is necessary because you are nine months preggo and cannot hop up fast enough to avoid danger. So ya scream. Sometimes you gotta yell to RESTORE the peace that your kids are disrupting.

In necessary things, unity. In doubtful things, liberty. In all things, charity.
-St. Augustine
Lol, yes, like if you are changing one baby’s diaper and see another child in the distance doing something they need to stop right that moment. You yell. Or you need the help of your spouse, who is far away, and you cannot walk away from the scene. You yell. Yelling doesn’t have to be the form of discipline, it might just be the only way you can get the person to hear the message at the moment you need them to hear it.

Honestly, I didn’t read the article, but I think the concept is baloney. Lots of times I might sound stern to my children, but I am not ‘angry’, I am just trying to convey a message. Other times, I might scold them etc, not angry, but just concerned. Other times, yes I get mad at my (older) kiddos for not doing what they should be doing. Actually, the younger they are, odds are I will never be mad at them because they are not past the age of reason and their behavior, although it may need to be corrected, is not purposefully malicious.
 
Honestly, I didn’t read the article, but I think the concept is baloney. Lots of times I might sound stern to my children, but I am not ‘angry’, I am just trying to convey a message.
My mother told me the same thing a long time ago… now she admits that she might be part of the reason why most people mistakenly assume I’m angry when I talk.

When my father more or less said, “Oh only NOW you tell him.” forgive me when that was the moment when I thought if many women were just as unaware of how people take their tone. :o
 
There’s a lot of generalizing going on here, and a lot of assumptions.

Earlier I said (I’ll repeat, and I mentioned it on another thread, too) that having young children is way too much fun to make one “angry.” It’s been the most peaceful time of my life. But given that I also interacted, and still interact, with a lot of other mothers of young children, and don’t perceive them to be “angry” either, it’s hard to take the premise of this thread with any objectivity.

One thing is people self-reporting that they’re “angry.”
Another thing is perception by others about what is and is not “anger.”

In any case, I and all my peers can’t all be outliers.
 
That’s great that you have found what works for your kids. Personally, though, I think you might have missed the point of the original post. Furthermore, I tend to take with a grain of salt advice from people with so few years experience at parenting. 🤷
I have less years parenting, but was given an extremely difficult baby and toddler, so I think that bumped me up in the experience dept lol.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top