Monatone asleep bored priests in confession?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lfsajourney
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

lfsajourney

Guest
I am a new Catholic but try to go to confession once a week. I have had a pretty much the same few priests at my old parish for confession. They were pretty good as far as listening and giving good solid spirtual advice and penence. But now I live in a new state with a priest that only does confession behind the screen confessions. He is very monatone and is in such a rush he tells me to say an act of contrition before I can even get to my (small) list of sins. He’s not the only one some are so monatone and give me the same penance every time. I guess I was spoiled in having an Opus Dei preist as a confessor. These priests just seem like its a drag and bore and wan’t it to just be over. They only heare 45 min of confessions a week. What do you think folks should I start searching for a parish? Don’t get me wrong I understand the sarcrament regardless of what priest forgives me I’m forgiven it’s just some are so…
 
You might schedule a meeting with your priest to let him know of your concerns. One thing I’m wondering about though, do you really need to go weekly? When I was going throught RCIA, and it came time to have our first confession, I happened to mention that I planned to go weekly. The priest overheard and said that, in his opinion, no one needs to go that often. I try to go monthly.
 
Monthly, or even biweekly, sounds good. But as to the priest–how long are the confession lines? If they are long, maybe he does need to keep the line moving. If not, just hang in there, or find a confessor more to your liking.

JimG
 
Oh MAN, don’t get me started about indifferent priests hearing confession!!! OH MY GOSH, this is my NUMBER ONE pet peeve!!! URGH! I actually had to WAKE A PRIEST UP when I was done telling my sins once. I was so mad, I couldn’t contain myself, and freaked out in the sanctuary, in tears. I mean, I know that they still posess the power to absolve no matter what, but confession is supposed to be a healing sacrament, and I left that confessional more wounded than I was when I went in. I went home and called the diocese office, they put a priest on, and he acted like I was some kind of nut. This of course made things worse. On top of the sleeping priest, this guy made me feel insulted as well. I’ve had so many bad experiences. One was in Manhattan, at St. Francis on 33rd street, on Holy Saturday. There must have been 8 priests hearing confessions in different languages, one in English. There was a sign that stated the end time for confessions on each confessional door. The one hearing in English came out 15 minutes before the end time and SCREAMED (these confessionals were in the basement chapel, so picture an altar, tabernacle, pews, a crowd of people scattered praying) in a nasty voice, “This confessional will close in 15 MINUTES, I WILL HEAR NO MORE CONFESSIONS AFTER THAT!” He gave a clear message that he was miserable and didn’t want to be there. THen there was the priest at my new parish (he’s gone now) who couldn’t be bothered to stay in the confessional for the entire 30 minutes on Saturday, and would only stay until the ‘line’ was gone…who knows how long that took…so when we arrived 15 minutes before confession was supposed to end, only to find no priest, we called the rectory. He said that if we wanted him to hear our confessions, we could walk down to the rectory and he’d hear them. What, over tea in his living room??? This was in late December, and he expected us to walk 100 yards down an un-shoveled, icy sidewalk (all downhill), and there was me, 9 months pregnant. I pitched a fit again, this time in the parking lot. This did not bode well with me, as we had only just joined the parish THE WEEK BEFORE! Well, God has His own plan, and the priest resigned about two weeks after he baptised our daughter, for personal reasons. I think he didn’t want to be a pastor anymore.

Anyway, I do empathize with them, surely it is quite taxing to hear such horrible things over and over again, day after day, year after year. It must be demoralizing to hear the same voices repeat the same sins. I can understand why they might go in to ‘autopilot’ just to cope. But come on, this is a SACRAMENT!!! A very very CRUCIAL sacrament, essential to our spiritual health, and it deserves a significant amount of respect and dignity, from both confessor and confessee. I wish I knew of a proper way to deal with this problem. I wish there were diocesan protocols for dealing with this, helping priests to deal with the stresses, helping confessees to have a viable route to a valid, non-stressful confession. I feel for all the people who finally make it to confession after being away for years, only to have a bad experience. It wouldn’t take much to scare them away again. THink of how serious the impact of a bad confessional experience is. Yes, we must pray for priests, but there needs to be more. Both priests and laypeople have become far too cavalier about the sanctity and seriousness of this crucial sacrament.

Phew, sorry to rant, but I needed that. Just my :twocents: :twocents:

OH, I want to add that I have had some WONDERFUL experiences with the confessors at our diocese cathedral. They listen, give feedback, practical advise, and well-though and profound penances. Thanks be to God for their wonderful work!!!
 
my preist always gives the same pennance (silently recite 2 psalms), however he is very good at recognizing you (but not letting on) and will work with you and give lots of advice when you need it and speedily absolve you if he knows it is more a “maintainence” confession.
 
40.png
lfsajourney:
I am a new Catholic but try to go to confession once a week.
I guess I was spoiled in having an Opus Dei preist as a confessor.
First, don’t let anyone talk you out of going to Confession as often as you want to. Weekly is not too much if you’re sincerely trying to grow in holiness.

Yes, the Opus Dei priests can really spoil you - confession is their special charism. Now you need to pray hard for God to lead you to a good confessor. Perhaps a novena to the Holy Spirit would be in order or prayers to some renowned confessors like St. John Vianney, the patron saint of parish priests, or the recently canonized St. Pio of Pietrelcina (Padre Pio). The right one is out there for you somewhere - keep looking!

Betsy
 
40.png
lfsajourney:
…What do you think folks should I start searching for a parish? Don’t get me wrong I understand the sarcrament regardless of what priest forgives me I’m forgiven it’s just some are so…
I pick a parish based on its respect for God in the Church. The priest doesn’t necessarily have to be exciting. We had a very good energetic priest at our parish for several years. It helps to have a great priest. However, we are not there for the priest, but we are there to worship God. I’ve appreciated this even more after our great parish priest left for another assignment.

In the confessional, we are there to confess our sins to Jesus through the priest. It doesn’t matter who the priest is, they are the vehicle to Jesus. If you need advice on how to handle certain sinful tendencies, you may need to look for a spiritual director (your parish might even have one: if not perhaps someone else can chime in as to where you can look).

I hope my comments have been helpful. Take care. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top