More on RCIA

  • Thread starter Thread starter palmas85
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

palmas85

Guest
I’ve posted several things that my best friend, who is entering the Church through the RCIA Program, has told me about the process and what he is going through Several things he has told me recently bother me somewhat so I’ll lay them out here.

Several weeks ago, they were treated to what was described as the TRUE Mass, the Agape. There were several tables set up in the shape of a cross. It was covered with candles, and had a loaf of bread and a jug of grape juice in the center. The inquirers were sitting in a circle around the tables. They were told that what they were about to experience was the original form of the Mass. First they were told to clear their minds , meditate on the candles, and look within themselves, seeking their inner light, their own burning candle. Afterwards, the director read from an account of the Last Supper, passed the bread out and everyone took a piece and ate. Then the Director read again from an account of the Last Supper, and passed around the grape juice. Everyone took a sip. They were then told to meditate on the Candles silently for a while, looking inward for truth. It was stressed that they were to clear their minds and not to pray during this experience.

After this they had a spirited talk describing the curent Mass by, as my friend described him, a Deacon. The Deacon said that inquirers will be tested by many who want to pull the faith backwards and stop it’s progress and that they should watch for and be on guard against such things. He then explained that since the first Mass was said in Greek, no one should expect or push for a return to Latin usage and those that do are merely looking for something that is comfortable to them… He said the “Old Mass” celebrated until Vatican II was full of errors and almost never celebrated properly He shared that as a young man he hated the Mass because of this and almost left the Church… According to him, the Church was on it’s knees and then Vatican II swept in and saved it.

He ran through the Mass, giving most of his attention to the Consecration when he told them that it was the belief of the Congregation coupled with the prayers of the Priest that changed the Bread and Wine into the Body and Blood of Christ. While the Priest alone could not accomplish this, the congregation somehow could and without the congregation such a change is impossible.

He went on a while more telling them that the only proper way to receive Holy Communion was in the hand, although some “old timers” felt more comfortable receiving on the tongue. He said they should not be laughed at although it does look funny seeing grown people stick their togues out. Apparently the class thought that was funny as my friend reported a good chuckle at the joke.

He concluded his talk on the Mass by mentioning that since the word Eucharist means thanksgiving, Catholics should no longer feel that the Mass is the re presentation of a Sacrifice, but rather a celebration of all Christians, both Catholic and “Beloved Separated Brethern”, in the unity of Christ.

I don’t really know what to make of these statements :confused:
 
Tell your friend to get out of that RCIA group and do it now. And alert the Bishop to this horror.

Dxu
 
Your friend is being indoctrinated by the Neocatechumenal Way. The “Way” already has control of many parishes and is introducing their doctrine over Catholic teaching to unsuspecting people thru their form of RCIA. Can you just imagine what they are doing with the children in CCD.

Tell your friend to get out of there and to take as many people with her.

Tell her to write a letter to the Bishop and send a copy to the Vatican, concerning what is being taught in that class.
 
this deacon is teaching heresy and should be reported to the bishop at once.
 
See, this is the scary thing about RCIA. How does one know what is right and wrong, or perhaps proper and not proper.

I am a returning to the Church, and I have been doing my questioning through these forums and looking up things on my own (fortunately I love to do research). I also remember the Church growing up.

Attending various parishes (parish shopping), I know what I feel comfortable with and what I don’t from attending with my grandparents during childhood.

I have an advantage, I suppose, to see what RCIA should be teaching. But what of those who don’t have that information to fall back on? Who is teaching the RCIA instructors?
 
40.png
Walking_Home:
Your friend is being indoctrinated by the Neocatechumenal Way. The “Way” already has control of many parishes and is introducing their doctrine over Catholic teaching to unsuspecting people thru their form of RCIA. Can you just imagine what they are doing with the children in CCD.

Tell your friend to get out of there and to take as many people with her.

Tell her to write a letter to the Bishop and send a copy to the Vatican, concerning what is being taught in that class.
This sounds a bit like my RCIA. Can I have more info on this please? And how do I contact the Bishop for Hartford CT?

-D
 
Palmas,

I see you are in San Diego. Is this the ardiocese where your friend is taking these RCIA classes?

Please, contact Catholic Answers for a sound, orthodox RCIA program in that archdiocese if this is where they are located. If necessary, please-please have your friend take private instruction from a sound, totally orthodox priest.

May God have mercy on this deacon.

Prayers are with.

Kev
 
Morning Glory:
See, this is the scary thing about RCIA. How does one know what is right and wrong, or perhaps proper and not proper.

I am a returning to the Church, and I have been doing my questioning through these forums and looking up things on my own (fortunately I love to do research). I also remember the Church growing up.

Attending various parishes (parish shopping), I know what I feel comfortable with and what I don’t from attending with my grandparents during childhood.

I have an advantage, I suppose, to see what RCIA should be teaching. But what of those who don’t have that information to fall back on? Who is teaching the RCIA instructors?
There’s a lot of issues with RCIA. The best advice I have for you - some may have better - is to double check everything you’re taught. There’s tons of resources online, such as this one here on CA, and of course the catechism.

As for those that don’t know that what they’re being told is wrong, it’s not their fault - but they should really as part of the process do some learning on their own, and hopefully that will lead them in the right direction. But believe me- I understand your frustration.

I’m hoping someday there will be a set standard to the way RCIA is taught.

Palmas85 - don’t go back to that RCIA class. Find another at a good, orthodox parish. And as everyone else mentioned, I’ll just stress a good letter to your bishop describing this nonsense. Good luck.
 
Mr. Darrel,

Go to the Apologetics forum and do a search for Neocatechumenal, Mr. Sean O L and Matt 01, have some good information on the Neocatechumenal Way.

I checked and unfortunately Hartford is in a hot bed of neocatechumenal activity.

One thing to note, they pass themselves off as charismatics, but not all charismatics are neocatechumenals).

Also be very wary of any invitation by the catechists teaching the RCIA class, for you all to join a community to help you in your faith - this is where the hard core indoctrination occurs. (I must note here that not all groups or communities are neocatechumenal).

That is the difficulty, knowing which charismatics are neocatechumenal and which communities are neocatechumenal for they will not tell, until basicly you are under their control.

My advice to you and is to try and find an orthodox RCIA class, true to the faith. May our Lord Christ and our Lady in heaven guide you. Pass this information on to the other students in class.
Invite them to come here to Catholic Answers.

Your in the Archdiocese of Hartford - Archbishop Mansell.

The Most Reverend Henry J. Mansell, D.D.
134 Farmington Ave.
Hartford, Ct. 06105-3784

Please write also to the Vatican.
 
40.png
palmas85:
I’ve posted several things that my best friend, who is entering the Church through the RCIA Program, has told me about the process and what he is going through Several things he has told me recently bother me somewhat so I’ll lay them out here.

Several weeks ago, they were treated to what was described as the TRUE Mass, the Agape. There were several tables set up in the shape of a cross. It was covered with candles, and had a loaf of bread and a jug of grape juice in the center. The inquirers were sitting in a circle around the tables. They were told that what they were about to experience was the original form of the Mass. **First they were told to clear their minds , meditate on the candles, and look within themselves, seeking their inner light, their own burning candle. **Afterwards, the director read from an account of the Last Supper, passed the bread out and everyone took a piece and ate. Then the Director read again from an account of the Last Supper, and passed around the grape juice. Everyone took a sip. They were then told to meditate on the Candles silently for a while, looking inward for truth. It was stressed that they were to clear their minds and not to pray during this experience.

After this they had a spirited talk describing the curent Mass by, as my friend described him, a Deacon. The Deacon said that inquirers will be tested by many who want to pull the faith backwards and stop it’s progress and that they should watch for and be on guard against such things. He then explained that since the first Mass was said in Greek, no one should expect or push for a return to Latin usage and those that do are merely looking for something that is comfortable to them… He said the “Old Mass” celebrated until Vatican II was full of errors and almost never celebrated properly He shared that as a young man he hated the Mass because of this and almost left the Church… According to him, the Church was on it’s knees and then Vatican II swept in and saved it.

He ran through the Mass, giving most of his attention to the Consecration when he told them that it was the belief of the Congregation cou[pled with the prayers of the Priest that changed the Bread and Wine into the Body and Blood of Christ. While the Priest alone could not accomplish this, the congregation somehow could and without the congregation such a change is impossible.

He went on a while more telling them that the only proper way to receive Holy Communion was in the hand, although some “old timers” felt more comfortable receiving on the tongue. He said they should not be laughed at although it does look funny seeing grown people stick their togues out. Apparently the class thought that was funny as my friend reported a good chuckle at the joke.

**He concluded his talk on the Mass by mentioning that since the word Eucharist means thanksgiving, Catholics should no longer feel that the Mass is the re presentation of a Sacrifice, but rather a celebration of all Christians, both Catholic and “Beloved Separated Brethern”, in the unity of Christ.
I don’t really know what to make of these statements :confused:

Whole thing sounds bogus, the first highlighted area sounds like Gnosticism, and the last sounds mainline liberal Protestant. Hogwash.
 
Mr. Darrel,

For the Vatican:

The Most Reverend William Joseph Leveda
Congregation For The Doctrine Of The Faith
Vatican City
Rome, Italy

I am not sure if I am addressing Archbishop Leveda correctly in the first line. If I am incorrect, maybe someone can give the right form. You may also want to post in Ask an Apologist for the form of addressing Archbishop Leveda.

Also the invitation to join a community can also come during a regular mass.
 
40.png
Walking_Home:
Mr. Darrel,

For the Vatican:

The Most Reverend William Joseph Leveda
Congregation For The Doctrine Of The Faith
Vatican City
Rome, Italy

I am not sure if I am addressing Archbishop Leveda correctly in the first line. If I am incorrect, maybe someone can give the right form. You may also want to post in Ask an Apologist for the form of addressing Archbishop Leveda.

Also the invitation to join a community can also come during a regular mass.
Thank You Much

-D
 
:mad: I thought Gnostic but then I remembered the NeoCats. Yes, most definitely blow the whistle on this group, now.

Over here in England one particular Diocese, Clifton in the Bristol area had a terrible time with the Neo Catechumenical way. They nearly destroyed at least one Parish where they parachuted themselves into it. Took over nearly all the Ministries, the youth group, the FHC classes, RCIA, just everything. The attitude shown by the NeoCats seemed to be; if you aren’t with us, you are against us. Those who had a problem with the NeoCats left. Some not only left the parish but left the Church. A once healthy parish nearly closed through lack of a Congregation. Really destructive.
The Neo Cats are a very dangerous cult. That’s my opinion anyway and one not yet shared by the Curia. Indeed, HH John Paul II had a close relationship with the organisation. I don’t know why so many of our Bishops and Cardinals still think that the sun shines out of the you-know-where of the two founders and can’t see through them or the organisation they founded.

BTW: if you want fresh baked yeasted bread on the Altar for the Eucharist celebration then go find an Orthodox Church!
 
40.png
JKirkLVNV:
Whole thing sounds bogus, the first highlighted area sounds like Gnosticism, and the last sounds mainline liberal Protestant. Hogwash.
Yeah, I thought it was kind of wierd too, but with everything else the poor guy is telling me I’m really not surprised. I’m still not sure exactly what to make of this whole RCIA thing that he’s going through. When he talks to me, I’m in a bad position, because I don’t really want to discourage him, he seems to have adapted to the group he is with, and seems earnest in his search. My problem is that with all the wacky stuff going on in the Church, heck even on this forum, I’m not sure what is being taught by the Church these days. Somtimes it seems that we are accepting any and all beliefs to be considered, accepted and taught. There doesn’t really seem to be a center anymore. Anything and everything seems to be all right, except showing reverence, piety and humility. You know kind of like the old Chuck Berry verse

" Freedom baby, live the way you wanna live"

This whole thing has really got me confused. :confused:
 
They’ve had 40 yrs of working themselves thru the Church.

The majority of the problems that we have been experiencing and attributing to the liberals and modernists are actually the “fruits” of a totally new religion.

They don’t believe in our most Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, as we can see by the first post of this thread.

To do away with our faith, they do away with our traditions.
 
First of all, the Neocatechumenal Way has less than nothing to do with your friend’s RCIA program. The liturgy you have described bears no remote semblance to anything regarding the Neocatechumenal Way and you ought to speak to the pastor of your parish about it. I walk in the Neocatechumenal Way and think that what you have described is absolute, unadulterated heresy. That being said, I also think that everyone needs to have a better understanding of the issues at hand before leveling baseless accusations that are completely false. I fail to see any benefit in this. It appears to me that your friend ought to seek a more orthodox RCIA program at another parish, but as for the Neocatechumenal Way Way being having anything to do with this bizarre situation, that is completely bogus.

PEACE!!!
 
Speak to the Pastor.

Speak to the head of the Diaconate at the Diocese.
 
and in response to someone who posted on page 1 saying something along the lines of “if you want fresh baked yeasted bread, go find an Orthodox church,” the bread that we use is not leavened and is prepared according to the standards of the Church.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top