More on the Big Bang

  • Thread starter Thread starter DanteAlighieri
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Things can exist without time, they simply have no motion. By steady-state I’m not referring to the idea that the universe was moving in a steady constant pattern, but that the material of the Big Bang was just “there” without any motion at all. We can’t actually measure such an existence so it’s pure hypothesis, but it wouldn’t interfere with the idea of God. 🙂

Peace and God bless!
According to the big bang theory, nothing identifiable existed prior to the big bang, not matter, not a steady state. If God created everything from nothing (ex nihilo), then the idea that all the matter pre-existed does interfere with at least the Catholic and more generally the Christian (if not also Judaic and Islamic) view of God.
 
ERose (and others):

I think there are some more basic questions to be asked about the big bang- such as is it real?

It is clear that if one accepts a string of assumptions about the universe, then the observations we have would support the possibilty of a big bang (especially if we throw in a bunch of unobservable stuff like dark matter and dark energy).

The question is why accept those assumptions and not consider others? Other assumptions would lead to totally different conclusions about what our observations mean. This thread is very interesting in that respect.

The assumptions chosen exclude the possibility that we are in the center of the universe. They do so nearly explicitly. The thread I linked contains the following quote from Stephen Hawkings:

“…all this evidence that the universe looks the
same whichever direction we look in **might
seem to suggest **there is something special
about our place in the universe. In particular,
it might seem that if we observe all other
galaxies to be moving away from us, then
we must be at the center of the universe
.”

He does provide and alternative view, though:

“There is, however, an alternate
explanation: the universe might look the
same in every direction as seen from any
other galaxy, too. This, as we have seen,
was Friedmann’s second assumption. **We
have no scientific evidence for, or against,
this assumption. **We believe it only on
grounds of modesty: it would be most
remarkable if the universe looked the same
in every direction around us, but not
around other points in the universe.”

Interesting that secular modesty sounds a bit like disobedience to the Church. The other important assumption is what redshift means. It is interpreted as expansion, but it could also be interepreted as a gravitaitonal field. If the second assumption were accepted, then we would interepret the presence of redshifts all around us as us being in the center.

And, it is clear that if there was proof of us in the center, science would reject it, not even consider it. For instance Hubble (same thread- I am trying to reproduce some of the emphasis from the original thread):

*What did Edwin Hubble write when he first discovered redshifts moving away from the earth everywhere he looked? Wow, look, we may be in the center? No. Hey we appear to have a central position, but maybe there are alternate explanations? No.

He Said (The Observational Approach to Cosmology):

“…Such a condition would imply that
we occupy a unique position in the
universe, analogous, in a sense, to the
ancient conception of a central
Earth
*…This hypothesis cannot be
disproved
, but it is unwelcome and
would only be accepted as a **last
resort **in order to save the phenomena.
Therefore we disregard this
possibility
… the unwelcome position
of a favored location must be avoided
at all costs
… such a favored position
is intolerable…Therefore, in order to
restore homogeneity, and to escape
the horror of a unique position…must
be compensated by spatial curvature.
There seems to be no other escape.”

In any case, suggest you read the thread I linked- especially the exchange between psteichen and thrth_skr. The big bang is the result of a choice of one set of many possible unprovable assumptions.
Good points my friend.

From what I understand is that the reason why everything looks like it is moving away from us is because the universe is expanding uniformally which would mean that anywhere you are in the universe the rest of the universe would look like it is moving away from you.

Concerning us being the center of the universe or close to it I don’t know. I do understand that our planet revolves around the Sun and our solarsystem is positioned on the outskirts of the milkyway galaxy and thus rotating around the center of the galaxy. And our galaxy is part of a cluster of galaxies. If these are true statements then that would eliminate us being at the center of the universe. But it would not eliminate us being close to it.

Of course one can always go back and say the center of the universe is relative.🙂
 
There are some interesting consequences of accepting that there is a creator of the universe.

Could he have created a steady state universe? Yes, and a “big bang” open or closed universe, too. The point is that no matter what kind it was, it says nothing about whether or not there is a creator of it.

There’s another interesting possibility for creation. It all happened two seconds ago. It happened in a manner that everything in it – things, animals, people, their memories and knowledge, etc. – was created in a manner consistent with it having been made much, much earlier. Science can’t prove that hypothesis either true or false.

Blessings,

Gerry
Anything with God is possible but if we evaluate the concept of the old earth theory (which is not what you are proposing per sae but many protestants have proposed) where God created the earth and the universe 6000+ years ago but just made it look like it was billions of years old, we would find problems that do not gel with what we know of God.

The big issue in my opinion with this concept is that if God created the universe not that long ago but made it look much older than it is wouldn’t that be a form of a deception? The universe is really 6000 years old but I made it look like it was 60 billion years old. (Throwing numbers out there not really sure what they should be at this time for I am at work and do not have the info in front of me) Why would He do that? What benefit to us or Him would be gained? And wouldn’t any rational being classify that as a deception which is counter to the nature of God as we understand it.
 
The result was that Fred Hoyle’s “Steady State” theory became the vogue until cosmic background radiation – which Le Maitre had predicted but was unable to detect – was discovered in the 1960s.
Hoyle’s objection to the Big Band theory was primarily philosophical inasmuch as one has to have space and time for the universe to be created in, whereas with the BB, supposedly, space and time begin with it. After the discovery of the microwave background radiation, Hoyle still had some doubts about the big bang, as new concepts such as dark energy and dark matter came to the fore, and he replaced it with a theory involving many small bangs occurring in space and time.
 
According to the big bang theory, nothing identifiable existed prior to the big bang, not matter, not a steady state. If God created everything from nothing (ex nihilo), then the idea that all the matter pre-existed does interfere with at least the Catholic and more generally the Christian (if not also Judaic and Islamic) view of God.
The Big Bang theory doesn’t say that nothing existed prior to the Big Bang, only that we can’t measure anything before the Big Bang. What existed prior to the Big Bang remains an utter mystery that can’t be probed due to the lack of time existing prior to it.

That being said, there is nothing about matter/energy existing prior to the Big Bang which flies in the face of Catholic teaching. All it would mean is that God created the “primordial atom” before exploding it. In fact, speaking in terms of logical priority this necessarily occured, since the atom had to exist logically (not temporally) before being exploded. The universe would still be made ex nihilo, and there would be no measurement of “how long” it existed prior to the Bang because without movement there is no time.

Peace and God bless!
 
Anything with God is possible but if we evaluate the concept of the old earth theory (which is not what you are proposing per sae but many protestants have proposed) where God created the earth and the universe 6000+ years ago but just made it look like it was billions of years old, we would find problems that do not gel with what we know of God.
…
My main point is that nothing in science is going to shed light on the nature of God. It has its hands full trying to sort out the work he did in creation.

Ad there’s a flaw in the reasoning about the so-called old earth and what we know of God argument. Implicitly, it sets aside what is given in the premise, without disproving the premise.

In any event, the purpose of the illustration was to show how futile logic and science are, especially in comparison to divine revelation (never forget: we didn’t figure God out; he revealed his existence and (aspects of) himself to us), when it comes to understanding God. Even though what he did does not offend our sensibilities, it sure can boggle our minds in a hurry, and as for fully understanding him, well, good luck.

Blessings,

Gerry
 
Kallam Principle.
(gee i think i spelled that right)
  1. Anything which begins to exist has a cause
  2. The universe began to exist
  3. The universe had a cause
Any state in which the universe existed, be it the primordal atom the singularity or whatever, demands that, unless the thing existed eternally which very few to none in the scientific community accept, it had to begin to exist.

Just because time had not begun to exist does not mean that the singularity could not exist because ontological reality does not necessarily depend upon spacetime.

Therefore, one can assert that the singularity began to exist before time although not in a context of which we can hope to grasp. Since this singularity began to exist it too has a cause.
 
Kallam Principle.
(gee i think i spelled that right)
  1. Anything which begins to exist has a cause
  2. The universe began to exist
  3. The universe had a cause
Any state in which the universe existed, be it the primordal atom the singularity or whatever, demands that, unless the thing existed eternally which very few to none in the scientific community accept, it had to begin to exist.

Just because time had not begun to exist does not mean that the singularity could not exist because ontological reality does not necessarily depend upon spacetime.

Therefore, one can assert that the singularity began to exist before time although not in a context of which we can hope to grasp. Since this singularity began to exist it too has a cause.
Bingo. 👍

God bless!
 
Just because time had not begun to exist does not mean that the singularity could not exist because ontological reality does not necessarily depend upon spacetime…
How does one distinguish between ontological reality and physical reality?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top