ERose (and others):
I think there are some more basic questions to be asked about the big bang- such as is it real?
It is clear that if one accepts a string of
assumptions about the universe, then the observations we have would support the possibilty of a big bang (especially if we throw in a bunch of unobservable stuff like dark matter and dark energy).
The question is why accept those assumptions and not consider others? Other assumptions would lead to totally different conclusions about what our observations mean.
This thread is very interesting in that respect.
The assumptions chosen exclude the possibility that we are in the center of the universe. They do so nearly explicitly. The thread I linked contains the following quote from Stephen Hawkings:
“…all this evidence that the universe looks the
same whichever direction we look in **might
seem to suggest **there is something special
about our place in the universe. In particular,
it might seem that if we observe all other
galaxies to be moving away from us,
then
we must be at the center of the universe.”
He does provide and alternative view, though:
“There is, however, an alternate
explanation: the universe
might look the
same in every direction as seen from any
other galaxy, too. This, as we have seen,
was Friedmann’s second
assumption. **We
have no scientific evidence for, or against,
this assumption. **We believe it only on
grounds of
modesty: it would be most
remarkable if the universe looked the same
in every direction around us, but not
around other points in the universe.”
Interesting that secular modesty sounds a bit like disobedience to the Church. The other important assumption is what redshift means. It is interpreted as expansion, but it could also be interepreted as a gravitaitonal field. If the second assumption were accepted, then we would interepret the presence of redshifts all around us as us being in the center.
And, it is clear that if there was proof of us in the center, science would reject it, not even consider it. For instance Hubble (same thread- I am trying to reproduce some of the emphasis from the original thread):
*What did Edwin Hubble write when he first discovered redshifts moving away from the earth everywhere he looked? Wow, look, we may be in the center? No. Hey we appear to have a central position, but maybe there are alternate explanations? No.
He Said (The Observational Approach to Cosmology):
“…Such a condition would imply that
we occupy a unique position in the
universe, analogous, in a sense, to the
ancient conception of a
central
Earth*…
This hypothesis cannot be
disproved, but it is
unwelcome and
would only be accepted as a **last
resort **in order to save the phenomena.
Therefore
we disregard this
possibility…
the unwelcome position
of a favored location must be avoided
at all costs… such a favored position
is
intolerable…Therefore, in order to
restore homogeneity, and to escape
the
horror of a unique position…must
be compensated by spatial curvature.
There seems to be no other escape.”
In any case, suggest you read the thread I linked- especially the exchange between psteichen and thrth_skr. The big bang is the result of a choice of one set of many possible unprovable assumptions.