Mortal Sin and Habituation

  • Thread starter Thread starter MrSnaith
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
2352 By* masturbation *is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure. "Both the Magisterium of the Church, in the course of a constant tradition, and the moral sense of the faithful have been in no doubt and have firmly maintained that masturbation is an intrinsically and gravely disordered action."138 “The deliberate use of the sexual faculty, for whatever reason, outside of marriage is essentially contrary to its purpose.” For here sexual pleasure is sought outside of "the sexual relationship which is demanded by the moral order and in which the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love is achieved."139

To form an equitable judgment about the subjects’ moral responsibility and to guide pastoral action, one must take into account the affective immaturity, force of acquired habit, conditions of anxiety or other psychological or social factors that *lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability. *

scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s2c2a6.htm#II

Note well - the Catechism does not then say – oh if there are these other factors --well then the act is not masturbation. No – it is under that category of sin there called “masturbation”.

It is not a question of it not being the act of masturbation – but a question of at times there can be a reduction of culpability *of that act. It is not a question of the act *ceasing *to be masturbation.
  • (and I note for readers that such is *not to be presumed *as the CDF noted in the detailed document reference there in the CCC --see quote in posts above)
What are you responding to here exactly?
 
As you noted as well as I – a sin of weakness can be a mortal sin. In a moment of weakness one can give complete consent with the needed knowledge -and yes commit a mortal sin.

But as we both noted – one can also not commit a mortal sin-- in a “sin of weakness” – due to say lack of full advertance…
BookCat you may know the ins and outs of (your tradition) of pure moral theology well but applying it to the “real world” and to languages outside of Latin I think may be more of a challenge.

I put it to you that 99% of people would have no idea what you are saying by the phrase **" In a moment of weakness one can give complete consent." **
To most ordinary English speaking lay people that is an internal contradiction.

Try and apply it to real english language for us rather than use the technical moral theology english that perhaps only a couple of hundred people (ie moral theologians) in the world can make sense of :eek:.

Come on, throw us a bone in this regard 👍
Otherwise what is the point of contributing on this Forum other than to massage one’s own intellectual ego 😊.
 
BookCat you may know the ins and outs of (your tradition) of pure moral theology well but applying it to the “real world” and to languages outside of Latin I think may be more of a challenge.

I put it to you that 99% of people would have no idea what you are saying by the phrase **" In a moment of weakness one can give complete consent." **
To most ordinary English speaking lay people that is an internal contradiction.

Try and apply it to real english language for us rather than use the technical moral theology english that perhaps only a couple of hundred people (ie moral theologians) in the world can make sense of :eek:.

Come on, throw us a bone in this regard 👍
Otherwise what is the point of contributing on this Forum other than to massage one’s own intellectual ego 😊.
I forgot to add…
English “weakness” is used to translate Aquinas’s term “in infirmite”. Acts done “in infirmite” may well be done with consent according to Aquinas and usually are.

However he does, rarely, speak of another sort of weakness “in fragilitate”. Acts done “in fragilite” may well be done without consent according to Aquinas and usually are.

Clearly MrSnail is concerned about real-world situations of “in infirmite” which is the more usual meaning of the english word “weakness”.

An ideal-ist, single track approach to the application of a pure moral theology ultimately based on Latin with a 1:1 mapping to english words is terribly unhelpful.

If we step back and see moral theology as an art just as much as a science I think
these “lost in translation” disconnects would be more easily discoverable.

In which case your statement “In a moment of weakness one can give complete consent” is something of a ripping of the english language.

All this really means is “one can give consent to passion, and mortally so.”
Yes, this is obvious, we all know that. That is not what is really meant by the english expression “a moment of weakness”, esp wrt masturbation.
 
BookCat you may know the ins and outs of (your tradition) of pure moral theology well but applying it to the “real world” and to languages outside of Latin I think may be more of a challenge.

I put it to you that 99% of people would have no idea what you are saying by the phrase **" In a moment of weakness one can give complete consent." **
To most ordinary English speaking lay people that is an internal contradiction.

Try and apply it to real english language for us rather than use the technical moral theology english that perhaps only a couple of hundred people (ie moral theologians) in the world can make sense of :eek:.

Come on, throw us a bone in this regard 👍
Otherwise what is the point of contributing on this Forum other than to massage one’s own intellectual ego 😊.
I forgot to add…
English “weakness” is used to translate Aquinas’s term “in infirmite”. Acts done “in infirmite” may well be done with consent according to Aquinas and usually are.

However he does, rarely, speak of another sort of weakness “in fragilitate”. Acts done “in fragilite” may well be done without consent according to Aquinas and usually are.

Clearly MrSnail is concerned about real-world situations of “in infirmite” which is the more usual meaning of the english word “weakness”.

An ideal-ist, single track approach to the application of a pure moral theology ultimately based on Latin with a 1:1 mapping to english words is terribly unhelpful.

If we step back and see moral theology as an art just as much as a science I think
these “lost in translation” disconnects would be more easily discoverable.

In which case your statement “In a moment of weakness one can give complete consent” is something of a ripping of the english language.

All this really means is “one can give consent to passion, and mortally so.”
Yes, this is obvious, we all know that. That is not what is really meant by the english expression “a moment of weakness”, esp wrt masturbation.
 
Clearly MrSnail is concerned about real-world situations of “in infirmite” which is the more usual meaning of the english word “weakness”.
Typo, I of course meant:
“Clearly MrSnail is concerned about real-world situations of “in fragilitate” which is the more usual meaning of the english word “weakness”.”

i.e. frailty.

If the rest of the below post seems a bit disconnected it is.
Catholic.com minced up an attempted correction then crashed my PC.
 
What I noted is the case.

A person can commit a mortal sin “in a moment of weakness”. Most certainly.

(including masturbation) And such is yes a fine way of saying it in English.
 
if there is any hint at all that it was not fully deliberate then, by CCC definition, it was not even “masturbation.”
2352 By* masturbation *is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure. "Both the Magisterium of the Church, in the course of a constant tradition, and the moral sense of the faithful have been in no doubt and have firmly maintained that masturbation is an intrinsically and gravely disordered action."138 “The deliberate use of the sexual faculty, for whatever reason, outside of marriage is essentially contrary to its purpose.” For here sexual pleasure is sought outside of "the sexual relationship which is demanded by the moral order and in which the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love is achieved."139

To form an equitable judgment about the subjects’ moral responsibility and to guide pastoral action, one must take into account the affective immaturity, force of acquired habit, conditions of anxiety or other psychological or social factors that *lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability. *

scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s2c2a6.htm#II

Note well - the Catechism does not then say – oh if there are these other factors --well then the act is not masturbation. No – it is under that category of sin there called “masturbation”.

It is not a question of it not being the act of masturbation – but a question of at times there can be a reduction of culpability *of that act. It is not a question of the act *ceasing *to be masturbation.

Also of course since then it has been pointed out that the word “deliberate” there is referring to the on purpose human act -as opposed to say a person being asleep etc.

That the act of masturbation where one lacks say the full knowledge needful for mortal sin -is still “deliberate” - -it is still masturbation.

  • (and I note for readers that such is *not to be presumed *as the CDF noted in the detailed document reference there in the CCC --see quote in posts above)
 
Alright, I think this discussion has run its course. To sum up:

Any grave sin may or may not be mortal dependent upon both the knowledge of the sinner, and the level of consent involved in the action, which may be affected by things like, heredity, fear, pathological states, etc.

Thus, any grave sexual sin, including masturbation, may or may not be mortal depending on the two factors of knowledge and consent involved, but we must not generally presume veniality of the sin, but rather ought to expect confession prior to reception of the Sacred Species. Only in the exceptional circumstance, determined by a properly trained spiritual counselor, may one determine veniality of a normally mortal matter, and thereby continue to received Communion without necessarily needing to confess.

As regards masturbation in particular, factors such as age, or the level of habituation may reduce culpability, but that is to be prayerfully and carefully determined through spiritual counseling, and ought not to be determined by the sinner alone.

Moments of weakness may or may not be mortal, again dependent upon the factors of knowledge and full consent. As regards consent in particular, the CCC does not define absolutely full and free consent, but rather a “sufficiently” full consent. So again, it really comes down to a case-by-case examination, as each person, and each act, is under a unique set of circumstances. And again, this is to be understood against the backdrop of “don’t assume veniality.” In grave matters, veniality ought to be understood as the exception, not the rule.

As such, while mortal sins do not always represent an explicitly fundamental option, every mortal sin is an implicitly fundamental option, and we ought to strive ardently to make people aware of this, and the real nature of their actions.
 
Alright, I think this discussion has run its course. To sum up:
Yes
Any grave sin may or may not be mortal dependent upon both the knowledge of the sinner, and the level of consent involved in the action, which may be affected by things like, heredity, fear, pathological states, etc.
It is not that a grave sin becomes a mortal sin. The terms “grave sin”, “mortal sin”, “serious sin” are synonyms. But “mortal sin” is better used in terms of when one has “committed” such. (if it is not a mortal sin (grave sin) it is a venial sin -or no sin at all - so far as culpability -so far as one has committed a sin – but in terms of matter yes it remains grave).

But I understand what you mean.

So yes - just because three is *grave matter * present - does not mean that the person has committed a mortal (grave) sin. One needs also full knowledge and deliberate consent. \

Compendium from Pope Benedict XVI:
  1. When does one commit a mortal sin?
One commits a mortal sin when there are simultaneously present: grave matter, full knowledge, and deliberate consent.
Thus, any grave sexual sin, including masturbation, may or may not be mortal depending on the two factors of knowledge and consent involved, but we must not generally presume veniality of the sin, but rather ought to expect confession prior to reception of the Sacred Species. Only in the exceptional circumstance, determined by a properly trained spiritual counselor, may one determine veniality of a normally mortal matter, and thereby continue to received Communion without necessarily needing to confess.
Basically - a confessor can assist in judging that one does not have the needed consent etc. And yes one ought not (including the confessor -for that CDF document was directed basically to them–and such was discussing there Masturbation -not other sins. ) one ought not presume that it was not grave sin (mortal).
As regards masturbation in particular, factors such as age, or the level of habituation may reduce culpability, but that is to be prayerfully and carefully determined through spiritual counseling, and ought not to be determined by the sinner alone.
Such would be yes rather prudent to have a regular confessor who knows one and thinks with the Church -to assist one.

One is often not the best judge in ones own case. As the saying goes.
Moments of weakness may or may not be mortal, again dependent upon the factors of knowledge and full consent. As regards consent in particular, the CCC does not define absolutely full and free consent, but rather a “sufficiently” full consent. So again, it really comes down to a case-by-case examination, as each person, and each act, is under a unique set of circumstances. And again, this is to be understood against the backdrop of “don’t assume veniality.” In grave matters, veniality ought to be understood as the exception, not the rule.
The Catechism does define full knowledge and complete consent -deliberate consent. But it is a Catechism not a work of moral theology -so it does not get into a long discussion.

Normally with the sin of masturbation - a person is going to simply know and judge -that was a mortal sin and I need to confess it.

As to grave matters in general - in terms of say temptation to such – one still needs to always ask -was there full knowledge and complete consent.

One does not need to say go to ones confessor every time an impure though flew through ones mind -for one can judge -no I did not give consent to that. Or yes I consented. It can be quite plane.
As such, while mortal sins do not always represent an explicitly fundamental option, every mortal sin is an implicitly fundamental option, and we ought to strive ardently to make people aware of this, and the real nature of their actions.
I would tend away from that term for it gets misused. But yes every mortal sin changes ones “fundamental option” de facto. It turns one away from God. And yes let us all propose the Gospel - and live it --which yes involves “repenting” and turning to the Lord.

Yes - Let us all seek more and more the “renewal of the mind” as St. Paul and Pope Benedict XVI discuss vatican.va/holy_father/benedict_xvi/homilies/2009/documents/hf_ben-xvi_hom_20090628_chius-anno-paolino_en.html (keep reading past the first par).
 
A person can commit a mortal sin “in a moment of weakness”.
(including masturbation) And such is yes a fine way of saying it in English.
For english speakers the better translation of this moral theology is:
“A person can commit a mortal sin “in a moment of passion” (“weakness”)” when the medieval Latin phrase “in infirmite” is used.

We can also say:
"A person can commit only a venial sin or even no sin at all “in a moment of frailty (weakness)” when the medieval Latin phrase “in fragilite” is used.

As Aquinas himself used to say,
“Seldom affirm, never deny, but always distinguish.” 👍

I leave it to the wisdom of readers here to determine for themselves which meaning of the word “weakness” properly applies to any given real-world ethical issue.

Of course in areas of grave matter (which anything defined as “masturbation” always is) it is salutory to bring this before a Confessor from time to time if one is at all doubtful as to culpability.
 
Note well - the Catechism does not then say – oh if there are these other factors --well then the act is not masturbation. No – it is under that category of sin there called “masturbation”.
Unfortunately you have missed the point.
I won’t be endlessly debating this further with you as the following principles are well established:

Before deciding the culpability of an external act we must first make sure we understand what the external act (from which we mainly judge the “object”) actually is in a given moral context.

Thus the same death at my hands may be an act of murder, an act of homicide, an act of self-defence, an act of Capital Punishment by an executioner, or an “accident”.

In the context of this discussion… we must first correctly identifying what sort of “moral act” this stimulation of the genitals is. Is it masturbation, preparation for marital sex, or an “accident.” And then we proceed to judge culpability if that applies.

As above, in matters of possible “grave matter” we should always seek wise counsel from a Confessor if we are in any doubt/confusion in the matter.
 
In the context of this discussion… we must first correctly identifying what sort of “moral act” this stimulation of the genitals is. Is it masturbation, preparation for marital sex, or an “accident.” And then we proceed to judge culpability if that applies.
Yes indeed.

-------------------\

Getting back to what I noted above.

An act of the sin of masturbation which is not mortal in a particular case -due to say lack of knowledge - and is venial. Is still “masturbation”… it does not cease to be masturbation.

That is what I was noting there.
 
After reading all of this I am incredibly comforted that God will be judging my soul, not through rhetoric and verbiage,but rather with infinite mercy and love. WOW!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top