Mortal sin and prayers for others

  • Thread starter Thread starter Blessedwithfive
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sigh.

Legalism, especially the sort practiced by the Pharisees, is the performing of religious rituals and other actions with precise external adhesion, but without any sort of internal conversion. The words of Our Lord to the Pharisees cannot be understood if not in this sense.

The doctrine that someone in a state of mortal sin cannot merit anything supernatural isn’t legalism. It’s simply a doctrine. The converse of this doctrine is called Pelagianism.

What you have said can be the precise line of reasoning someone could give as to why they avoid going to Confession altogether. And that’s a problem, my friend.
Avoiding confession is quite different than not making it to Confession before one dies…this is exactly what the particular judgement, and the 4th beatitudes is all about.

Have you not noticed the significance of the timing of the loving actions of the father of the prodigal son, while the son was still off in a distance and had not yet come home?

I never suggested Reconciliation should be avoided, but your argument is troubling in that it seems to indicate prayers for others while we ourselves are not in the state of grace is futile.

Nonsense, my friend. We are on the way to mending our relationship with God by merely offering prayers to the Father for others.

When we determine that prayer is ever not efficacious, we have committed that horrible sin against the Holy Spirit. Which is the only sin Christ said could not be forgiven.
 
Please don’t be offended. When I read Neo’s post, it reminded me of a writing Pope Pius X wrote of Le Sillon that is why I related it to communism.

SAINT PIUS X (1903-1914):
The dream of re-shaping society will bring socialism
“But stranger still, alarming and saddening at the same time, are the audacity and frivolity of men who call themselves Catholics and dream of re-shaping society under such conditions, and of establishing on earth, over and beyond the pale of the Catholic Church, ‘the reign of love and justice’ … What are they going to produce? … A mere verbal and chimerical construction in which we shall see, glowing in a jumble, and in seductive confusion, the words Liberty, Justice, Fraternity, Love, Equality, and human exultation, all resting upon an ill-understood human dignity. It will be a tumultuous agitation, sterile for the end proposed, but which will benefit the less Utopian exploiters of the people. Yes, we can truly say that the Sillon, its eyes fixed on a chimera, brings Socialism in its train.” (Apostolic Letter Notre Charge Apostolique “Our Apostolic Mandate”] to the French Bishops, August 25, 1910, condemning the movement Le Sillon)
Yeah, don’t be offended…I’m offended enough for the both of us Clare!
 
I can’t believe that if I am in mortal sin, I shouldn’t pray for anyone who is sick or in Purgatory…because God will not listen to my prayer. :eek:
 
I can’t believe that if I am in mortal sin, I shouldn’t pray for anyone who is sick or in Purgatory…because God will not listen to my prayer. :eek:
Sigh, such heavy weather it wears… JUST PRAY because you care and there is need and trust God… FAITH, OK? OK!
 
Hello.

From how I understand things about Catholicism, once a person repents, goes to confession and is cleansed of mortal sin, they will get “credit” for all their meritorious actions.

Please correct me if I’m wrong.

Jesus I trust in You.
From what I understand, when someone is in a “state of mortal sin” or not in a “state of grace” they are unable to earn merit or grace for their actions. What about their prayers for other people? Are their prayers for other people “heard” by God? Does He accept them? And if He would, can you earn grace for others if you are unable to earn it for yourself?
 
Sigh, such heavy weather it wears… JUST PRAY because you care and there is need and trust God… FAITH, OK? OK!
The set up of this thread is a bit alarming especially when someone hears for the first time that prayers of those in a state of mortal sin might in someway be “lesser”. A person might see that dark wall of storm clouds first before looking up and seeing the bright rainbow.
 
The set up of this thread is a bit alarming especially when someone hears for the first time that prayers of those in a state of mortal sin might in someway be “lesser”. A person might see that dark wall of storm clouds first before looking up and seeing the bright rainbow.
Actually, I had the opposite reason for starting the thread. I believe we need to realize just how serious the church believes mortal sin is. Knowing that my prayers for others maybe useless is mighty motivation to remain in a state of grace.
 
Then we have James 5:16
“Therefore confess your sins to each other and pray for each other so that you may be healed. The prayer of a righteous person us powerful and effective.”
 
Sigh, such heavy weather it wears… JUST PRAY because you care and there is need and trust God… FAITH, OK? OK!
I always did pray and believe that God hears & will accept my prayer even though I may be temporarily in mortal sin…but some of the previous posts here have made me confused & doubtful. :confused:
 
Hello.

From how I understand things about Catholicism, once a person repents, goes to confession and is cleansed of mortal sin, they will get “credit” for all their meritorious actions.

Please correct me if I’m wrong.

Jesus I trust in You.
It is wrong. All previous merits lost through mortal sin are restored. But good works done in the state of mortal sin merit nothing. There is no credit. No reward is waiting upon reconciliation.

Credit applies only to sacramental grace, especially is the Sacrament is relatively non-repeatable such as Confirmation, Holy Orders and Matrimony.
 
It is wrong. All previous merits lost through mortal sin are restored. But good works done in the state of mortal sin merit nothing. There is no credit. No reward is waiting upon reconciliation.

Credit applies only to sacramental grace, especially is the Sacrament is relatively non-repeatable such as Confirmation, Holy Orders and Matrimony.
That is what I was always taught but I was hopeful I was wrong.

Thanks
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top