Mortal/venial sins

  • Thread starter Thread starter wkj_123
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
… Yes there are intrinsically evil acts. Meaning the object is always grave matter. Always grave evil. …
No, not really.
Yes, really.

See the Teachings of the Catholic Church and Catholic Moral Theology. …
Reading the teachings and reading the experts are always a good ideas.

Not all intrinsically evil acts as you claimed above are gravely disordered.

Lying is intrinsically evil. The gravity of the evil in lying is dependent on the other sources of morality, intent and circumstance.

“Lying can be either a venial or a mortal sin. It is mortal is the lie is serious.”
ewtn.com/v/experts/showmessage.asp?number=570287
 
Not all intrinsically evil acts as you claimed above are gravely disordered.

Lying is intrinsically evil. The gravity of the evil in lying is dependent on the other sources of morality, intent and circumstance.

“Lying can be either a venial or a mortal sin. It is mortal is the lie is serious.”
ewtn.com/v/experts/showmessage.asp?number=570287
You cut off your reading my answer at the first part. If you read the rest you will see that I said that there can venial matter involved too. I know that part was not the main text there - so I can understand a quick reading. Yes of course there can be grave matter and venial matter that are intrinsically disordered. We were discussing only grave matters up above. Hence the first answer.
Yes, really.

See the Teachings of the Catholic Church and Catholic Moral Theology.

Murder is always a gravely intrinsically evil object.

Again this is speaking of the nature of the thing. It is in itself -always a gravely sinful object.

(This is not referring to the persons culpability.)

(note we were discussing grave matters. Of course there are also matters that are intrinsically disordered but admit of parvity of matter - where there can be intrinsically disordered matters that include venial matter -were some sins of that kind are grave matter and some are venial matter - either being intrinsically disordered.).
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=13864768&postcount=39
 
The category of “invincibly ignorant” as a defense to avoid the culpability for the commission of intrinsically evil acts has I think a zero or near zero population. If so, the defense is merely a technical solution looking for a non-existent or extremely rare event.

From the Catechism:
1793 If - on the contrary - the ignorance is invincible, or the moral subject is not responsible for his erroneous judgment, the evil committed by the person cannot be imputed to him. It remains no less an evil, a privation, a disorder. One must therefore work to correct the errors of moral conscience.

1860 Unintentional ignorance can diminish or even remove the imputability of a grave offense. But no one is deemed to be ignorant of the principles of the moral law, which are written in the conscience of every man. …
" It is undeniable that a man cannot be invincibly ignorant of the natural law, so far as its first principles are concerned, and the inferences easily drawn therefrom. This, however, according to the teaching of St. Thomas, is not true of those remoter conclusions, which are deducible only by a process of laborious and sometimes intricate reasoning. "http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07648a.htm

1862 One commits venial sin when, in a less serious matter, he does not observe the standard prescribed by the moral law, or when he disobeys the moral law in a grave matter, but without full knowledge or without complete consent.

1955 …Its (natural law) principal precepts are expressed in the Decalogue.

• No one is deemed to be ignorant of the principles of the moral law, which are written in the conscience of every man (1860).
o The invincibly ignorant remain culpable in transgressing the principles of the moral law.
o Therefore, as I claimed, intrinsically evil acts that violate the standards prescribed by moral law are at least venially sinful acts.
o Intrinsically evil acts which do not violate the Decalogue or the inferences easily drawn therefrom are not culpable acts. But do such acts exist? I think not.​

Which of these intrinsically evil acts do not " violate the Decalogue or the inferences easily drawn therefrom"?
• Adultery
• Calumny
• Euthanasia
• Homosexual Acts
• Lying
• Masturbation
• Murder
• Pedophilia Acts
• Pornography Production
• Pornography Use
• Prostitution
• Rape
• Bestiality
• Sexual Abuse
• Sodomy

I think none of these acts pass the “Decalogue” test as an act for which one can claim invincible ignorance since by definition these acts are all prima facie, on the very face of it, evil.

Nevertheless, I agree that any intrinsically evil acts which require “remote conclusions, which are deducible only by a process of laborious and sometimes intricate reasoning” that such acts if, and only if, committed by a person who:

• has a real and sincere desire of knowing the truth
• is sincerely resolved to embrace the truth wherever he may find it, and whatever it may cost him
• sincerely uses his best endeavors to know his duty, and particularly, that he recommend the matter earnestly to Almighty God, and pray for light and direction from Him

may then assert the invincible ignorance defense.
 
Omlly - You are too zealous to disagree and are tending towards a straw man… Try finding a way to agree and the difficulty will be cleared for you.
 
Omlly - You are too zealous to disagree and are tending towards a straw man… Try finding a way to agree and the difficulty will be cleared for you.
Thank you. Zeal is a virtue, a human good. Excessive zeal may become a vice if predicated on obedience. But zeal is an unlimited virtue when predicated on the truth. The OP, a convert, is entitled to know the truth about Catholic morality.
 
Well, you are certainly zealous for what you think is the truth… Despite an announcement that you were ditching the thread, you immediately returned to offer what you think are corrections but are actually obfuscations. The OP has had his question more than adequately answered, now we’re arguing about minutiae.
 
Well, you are certainly zealous for what you think is the truth… Despite an announcement that you were ditching the thread, you immediately returned to offer what you think are corrections but are actually obfuscations. The OP has had his question more than adequately answered, now we’re arguing about minutiae.
Well, your last post seems a bit cranky. If my post seems too complicated for you, suggest you take your meds/nap. I am on topic w/o obfuscations. Sin is never a “minituae” although there are some who would like us to think so.
 
Code:
Therefore, as I claimed, intrinsically evil acts that  violate the standards prescribed by moral law are at least venially sinful acts..
Those that are of venial matter - are venially sinful - “in themselves”. In their object.

Those that are of grave matter - are gravely sinful (mortal, serious) - “in themselves”. In their object.

That is referring to the nature of the act itself. Not to the persons “committing” sin (culpability). It can be that a person commits not even a venial sin (though it was a grave matter).

Is it possible that person might have a mitigated guilt for various reasons and while the act remains itself gravely sinful - the person does not “commit” a grave sin but a venial sin?

Yes.

Is it possible that a person might happen to do either of the above and due to say invincible ignorance - not commit (be guilty of) any sin at all? (it is null) (Though of course the nature of the act itself remains what it is.)

Yes.

Catechism: 1746 The imputability or responsibility for an action can be diminished or nullified by ignorance, duress, fear, and other psychological or social factors.

scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s1c1a3.htm#I

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=13860707&postcount=29​

Is it possible that a person does not know even the term “grave sin” but yet commit a grave sin - knowing it via natural moral law and reason?

Yes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top