Movies online - stealing?

  • Thread starter Thread starter OnFireForChrist
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

OnFireForChrist

Guest
As many of you know, there are hundreds of movies available online at just the click of a button for free.
Do you think this is wrong to watch them, or is it stealing as you are not paying for, well, anything?

At the library you get it free, as well as on tv, so why is this any different?
The people who uploaded the video payed for it as well.
 
It is stealing because 1 copy is being used by potentially thousands at one time. Not the “one at a time” of the DVD.
 
According to copyright owners, it is stealing, since they are the owners of it, you must respect their wishes, no matter how greedy they are or otherwise. Currently many of these movie websites are legal, and present the user uploading the material of agreeing or disagreeing with the licence agreement that the material that they upload belongs to them, usually it doesn’t belong to them.
 
I’ve got loads. I don’t consider it stealing. They shouldn’t charge so much for DVD’s in the first place. I don’t know about you but I’n not paying full price when I can download it for free.
 
I’ve got loads. I don’t consider it stealing. They shouldn’t charge so much for DVD’s in the first place. I don’t know about you but I’n not paying full price when I can download it for free.
Yeah. Cars cost too much so I just take the closest one that is available–and it’s free.
 
Give to Cesear what is Cesear’s and to God what is God’s… even Christ paid the temple tax although unfair.
 
This is a topic of MUCH discussion in my household. A family member of mine checks out movies from the library or a rental store and copies them. It IS stealing! And those who do it know it’s stealing. “Everybody does it” or the ease of doing it or some other rationalization is just that, a rationalization. People who make movies or video games do so to make a living. If they make a popular movie, they make a lot of money. But regardless of how much money they make (are you envious?) they are entitled to receive the rewards of their labors. By pirating a DVD, you are denying them their wages. You. Not some company out there. Not some “other.” You. If $20 or $30 is too much for a movie in your opinion, go without it. Don’t take it without paying for it. That is stealing.
 
As many of you know, there are hundreds of movies available online at just the click of a button for free.
Do you think this is wrong to watch them, or is it stealing as you are not paying for, well, anything?

At the library you get it free, as well as on tv, so why is this any different?
The people who uploaded the video payed for it as well.
Taking what you aren’t entitled to or doesn’t belong to you is stealing. This is very easy to determine. Check with the owner of said movie and ask whether they allow you to download that movie without compensating him for it. It is different with a library, because, either the copyright expired, or the owner has allowed permission to public libraries for this type of activity. Usually they don’t allow you to check it out at the library and then make copies available.
 
I think stealing is a harsh word in this context. I think Piracy is more appropriate.

I don’t think Piracy is stealing. I think it is disrespectful (which is probably a sin in itself)… but it is not stealing.

:twocents:
 
I think stealing is a harsh word in this context. I think Piracy is more appropriate.

I don’t think Piracy is stealing. I think it is disrespectful (which is probably a sin in itself)… but it is not stealing.

:twocents:
It is taking something you have no right to take. Close enough to stealing for me…

Recording it off TV for your own rewatching, that is one thing… sharing it with friends in your home, fine. Lending your copy, iffy.

Putting it up on the net, or d/ling it off the net, or making copies from the library or DVD store’s copy, it’s a crime, it’s immoral, and it’s theft.
 
I’ll download something either if its not available where I live or I wouldn’t of bought it anyway. For instance I downloaded “Another gay movie” because it was unavailable for rent/purchase because retailers in my small city unfortunately do not carry the movie and the one video store that is supposed to have it has been “rented out” for about a year now. But on the flip side I’m purchasing Spider-Man 3 when it comes out because I loved that movie.
 
This is a topic of MUCH discussion in my household. A family member of mine checks out movies from the library or a rental store and copies them. It IS stealing! And those who do it know it’s stealing. “Everybody does it” or the ease of doing it or some other rationalization is just that, a rationalization. People who make movies or video games do so to make a living. If they make a popular movie, they make a lot of money. But regardless of how much money they make (are you envious?) they are entitled to receive the rewards of their labors. By pirating a DVD, you are denying them their wages. You. Not some company out there. Not some “other.” You. If $20 or $30 is too much for a movie in your opinion, go without it. Don’t take it without paying for it. That is stealing.
Agreed, and in the end it comes back to bite you on the *** this practise, not at the end, but now.

At least with Music which doesn’t have a permanent audience unlike the cinema which always has a large audience(DVD is diffrent though). But I don’t download MP3s unless I’ve already got the CD, in which case I just put it in the drive and ripp it for my portable player, which is what you should do morally.

I don’t download MP3 because I know you’ll get charged for the music somehow and may as well just pay. If you don’t pay for the music, they just go “fine, we’ll find another way of charging you for it”, and then decided, “Low and behold, we are going to force nightclubs to pay thirteen times the original amount for music for them to play, if you want the nightlife to survive, better pay for your music, otherwise we’ll just keep on putting the pressure on the innocent third party until it dies and you have no place to go to drink!”

I’m not kidding, the price per person to listen to music for a night at a nightclub was 7cents in Australia… that’s now gone up to $1.10 as the industry looks for ways of charging people for music as the MP3 culture takes over.

That’s why, I refuse to download mp3s now.
 
the way I see it, may as well pay for it, because they’re going to make you pay for it anyway, some way or another.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top