Murderous Thief threatening spouse & children

  • Thread starter Thread starter IwishIknew
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Odd thought as I digest this. Would a peace-loving Abbot in war-torn Europe during the last century be morally obligated to arm his Monks in his Monastery? So many Monasteries with peaceful monks were utterly ruined. Of course, the Catechism hadn’t been drafted at that time, so maybe the rules were different… hmmm…
 
Then said Jesus unto him, Put up again thy sword into his place: for all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword (Matthew 26:52, King James Version)

is it possible that this is not a teaching meant for universal application? In the context of events, is it possible that Jesus meant that all who take the sword in his defense will be slain? I note that Jesus did not tell him to discard his sword entirely but rather to sheath it. If Jesus’s intent were to teach Peter (and all the world) that the sword was never to be used, why not tell him to discard it entirely rather than to simply sheath it? It may be that Jesus simply desired that Peter and the other disciples to comply with the will of God. Jesus had already demonstrated to Peter that he was going against the will of God when Peter told Jesus that he would not be crucified. Jesus said “get behind me Satan.” Now that was simply Peter denying what would happen. In the garden Peter again goes against the will of God, and through the sword, he intends to stop the crucifixion. That is not God’s will, clearly. So again, it seems, that this is Satan at work. Jesus knows that he must be crucified for that is his Father’s will. It seems to me that it may be possible to interpret this line as fitting the moment.

Also of note is that the Jewish people who carried the 10 commandments from God were also able to make war.

It would seem to make little sense that God would require a man to stand idle while someone abused, molested, and then killed his children.
 
Agreed - I don’t think “all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword” applies 100% of the time. Where I was getting tripped up was that Peter was defending and Jesus told this to him in a very general sense - so it wasn’t just explicit to that moment either. Peter was not the superior at the time so it wasn’t Peter’s authoritative call to defend Jesus.

So maybe it applies 98% of the time. The 2% of that it doesn’t is when defending those that you are responsible for/superior of. I’m leveraging the Catechism here because the NT doesn’t seem to address this. So would an Abbot in WWII who did not take up arms when his monastery is attacked in grave trouble spiritually? Since the Catechism wasn’t written then, and I’m not sure it was explicit anywhere prior, he may be off the hook. But currently, it seems to me that an Abbot and his Monks in a war-torn area such as the Middle East may have to carry arms. Thoughts?
 
I don’t think they must carry arms. A person of priestly devotion can go unarmed if it is God’s will and he can defend those in his care to the best of his ability within the limits that are imposed upon him by God. It may be that that this particular Abbot may not be permitted to use the sword. Do you think that it is possible that God may forbid an Abbot to carry a sword but may permit a parent to defend his children with deadly force?
 
I don’t think they must carry arms. A person of priestly devotion can go unarmed if it is God’s will and he can defend those in his care to the best of his ability within the limits that are imposed upon him by God. It may be that that this particular Abbot may not be permitted to use the sword. Do you think that it is possible that God may forbid an Abbot to carry a sword but may permit a parent to defend his children with deadly force.
Good question. I’ve heard of the vows of poverty, chastity and obedience as well as extra vows that allow cloistering. I’ve never heard of the “vow of non-violence” though - that might be one.

Maybe there are different rules for Abbots that would provide a non-violent exception to them that would not apply to a Parent, Governor or Leader of a country.

In some ways, I am thankful for this explicit instruction from the Catechism because, I often wondered how I could live with myself if I - by force of sheer will - chose not to defend my kids to the point of violence. I truly would have had to live with utter heartbreak for the rest of my days to see them abused, tortured and killed in front of me if I had the ability to kill that psychopath but didn’t use it in the name of Jesus.

I think of the mother in the Maccabees and could only imagine what she would have gone through had she been allowed to live. It would have been sheer torment to live from that point forward. Note, she was probably bound by the soldiers - so she was by no means guilty.

If I had to choose what the rest of my life would look like, I would much rather live with the guilt of killing a murderer than have not employed violence to stop one.
 
In such a case I don’t think you would not be guilty of “murder” but only of defending your children with deadly force when you deemed it necessary. If it were myself in that situation and the intruder in my house gave me opportunity to be merciful I would do it. I suppose many people who undertake criminal activity such as burglary are not psycho’s and would learn their lesson in the justice system. If I could spare them and turn them over to the police I would do it.
 
Agreed.

It gets trickier with the psychopaths. Like the ones in Germany and Russia who lured families into townships, then work camps then ultimately death.

In hindsight, I’m thinking that the guardians of the families should have revolted at the first sign of “herding”. But how were they to know what was about to happen to them?.. God willing this will never, ever happen again… what an utter atrocity to innocent families in a “civilized” world.
 
That’s a good question that I might pose in a new thread… at what point would the parents be allowed to use arms against a tyrannical regime based on this Catechism? I’ll post it!
 
The “Turn the other cheek”, “Give your cloak”, “lay down your life”, “be child-like”, teachings as well as Jesus’ stern rebuke of Peter when Peter lopped off the ear of the guard and even Mary’s silent acceptance of Jesus’ crucifixion** all lead me to think as parents we should NOT defend our little children should a murderous thief threaten them cornered in our home.
**
I believe that Christ is teaching that if we need defending, He will send his legions of Angels. Otherwise, we should let the murderer do what he does. Note - I know we can defend with cunning dialogue - which Christ promised the Spirit would help us with… but that is it - no violence - not even to lop of his ear.

The instincts in me would be tear out the heart of the murderer of my children and burn it in the fire. And if a child abuser touched my children inappropriately, it would take tremendous inner strength not to take swift & furious justice into my own hands.

However, the Christian in me says - “Lay your sword down and let what happens happen. God allows what He allows in His divine and eternal Wisdom.”

I seek the answer to this difficult question because, I don’t want to have to think through it should someone threaten my family one dark and terrible evening.

Does anyone have any wisdom to offer? I am seeking the most saintly approach to such a scenario.
Your thinking is completely wrong.

If an intruder breaks into your home and threatens you and your family you are entitled to use whatever force necessary for self defence and defence of your family, even if that entails deadly force.
 
Your thinking is completely wrong.

If an intruder breaks into your home and threatens you and your family you are entitled to use whatever force necessary for self defence and defence of your family, even if that entails deadly force.
Agreed. Per the comments earlier above, I now see the light. Thank you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top