My family is dependent on me - Need advice

  • Thread starter Thread starter Vincent187
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
V

Vincent187

Guest
Thank you for reading my post, and any advice given. (This is in two parts: see first comment for part 2)

God bless you!

As an introduction, I am male, twenty-one years of age, currently living in my parents’ house in Australia, after travelling and working overseas for a year.

I feel as though I cannot speak of this to any one in my immediate social circles (even priests!) due to the interconnectivity of persons involved.

I came back to my home-country in May of this year, mainly in response to what I saw as a dire financial and social situation at home. I felt obliged to return and aid in whatever way possible, so that my immediate family (parents and 3 siblings at home) weren’t forced into poverty again, which we’ve already experienced throughout much of my childhood prior (first-world poverty, that is).

As a disclaimer, I love my family dearly, and wish the best for them in all things temporal and eternal. It is precisely because I love them that I find such internal agony over this.

The social situation at home is complex and dysfunctional.
My father works over 1400km away from home, as he could not find stable work in our city. My mother has severe anxiety issues, does not drive, and seems to make excuses every time I offer to help in learning road-rules. Two of my adult-siblings at home do not work or study, and one of them does little more than spend countless hours playing computer-games. As far as I can tell, they both suffer from depression in some way. Apart from one sibling, I am the only driver at home. Additionally, I am the only driver with an income (I work part-time while studying part-time at university). My youngest sibling is still school-aged, and is not able to self-provide.

There are multiple social and environmental issues at home.
My parents have issues with hoarding, which has had a negative effect on the functionality of the home itself. Moreover, both my parents have health-issues (not entirely their fault) which have affected their ability to provide for their children. My father’s work is contingent on opportunities which are scarce, and as far as I am aware, my mother is not mentally well enough to work in a full-time or part-time capacity.
Perhaps the most critical issue, however, is the psycho-social illness evidenced in their behaviour.

My mother holds deep resentment for my father’s immediate family, and this has negatively affected my own ability to have a relationship with extended family. She has threatened (colloquially phrased) to ‘kick out’ those who endeavour to attend meetings of extended family, such as weddings, funerals, etc. Sadly, she refuses to get professional therapy for her mental health.
My paternal grandfather passed away six years ago - I have not visited his grave since his funeral. My paternal grandmother suffers from a very painful disease (my mother disdains her and calls her a ‘witch’). When I saw her before leaving for overseas, my mother was furious about it. She is frequently uttering vehement vitriol to all members of the house-hold, and it is becoming too much to bear for me. Despite her vitriol, she randomly turns around with phrases such as ‘I don’t know what I would do without you’. To informally phrase it, it’s like living with Jekyll and Hyde. Accordingly, my mother’s mental illness, and refusal to get professional help has had a severely negative effect on my own social and mental well-being.

I have a sense of responsibility for the situation at home.
My mother’s inability to transport herself leaves two immediate options for transportation: My unemployed adult sibling and myself.
I am shouldering a disproportionate amount of this responsibility, as my adult sibling is currently dealing with mental health issues also, and evidences ‘unreliability’, as termed by my mother. Furthermore, I not only have the responsibility of transporting my mother, but also my youngest sibling, to whatever extra-curricular activities require attendance.
It should also be noted that my Mother does not evidence effective self-management in simple planning such as buying groceries. I often must spend in excess of 6 hours a week, just in driving her to a supermarket and helping her get groceries.
I also must drive her to whatever social meetings (unless she can organise otherwise) she attends, which also takes up time. I don’t mind doing this, but it just is not sustainable for balancing work and university.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Cont. over
 
cont. >

I am independent, but my family is not.
I keep giving money to my parents and my siblings, because they either do not have an income, or they do not effectively manage finances. I paid for the transport so my father could get to the destination where he is now, for work. Accordingly, I am financially independent, but my family is not.
Moreover, I could easily leave home and move elsewhere. I am not living at home because I am dependent - it is quite the opposite. I have worked as a volunteer-tenancy mediator for a rental company overseas - I would have no trouble living elsewhere.
However, I am cursed by this question: ‘what will happen to my family if I leave?’.
I have had conversations with my eldest sibling (he is a professional now), who moved away, and he has recommended leaving also. He knows exactly what I am dealing with, and advises me that it is not my battle to fight.
I understand his reasoning and agree with him, but I am still uneasy about the idea.

I feel I am enabling their dependency by shouldering so much of the responsibility.
As I have illustrated previously, my family is mostly dependent, and I feel like caring for them is my responsibility. However, I know that allowing myself to be walked over is enabling their dependency.
I cannot seem to find any possibility other than to leave.
I need to focus on my study and my own spiritual life. I can fix things for people - but I cannot fix people. 😦

I am afraid to speak to any one about this, due to possible repercussions to my family’s relationship with those who are confidants.

I am seriously considering leaving (i.e living away from home) and helping in a satellite capacity (where I am not always physically present, but can still aid financially, etc). I just can’t go on like this.
I feel like I am dying because of it.

Please, if any experienced person can offer wisdom and insight for dealing with what I know is a complex situation, I would highly appreciate it. Also, please pray for me and my family.

God bless you all.

Yours in Christ,
  • Vincent
 
You say your family lives in Australia. If you did not provide for them in the way you do now, what safety nets exist?

Also, I may have missed this - are any of your siblings minors?
 
There’s a difference between helping people in crisis and those who refuse to help themselves. This sounds incredibly toxic and my advice is to move out. If you choose to send money, be aware that it will most likely be mismanaged.

Also, how many times a week do you go grocery shopping??? Six hours?? I have a smaller family, but it takes us one hour max per week.
 
There’s a difference between helping people in crisis and those who refuse to help themselves. This sounds incredibly toxic and my advice is to move out. If you choose to send money, be aware that it will most likely be mismanaged.

Also, how many times a week do you go grocery shopping??? Six hours?? I have a smaller family, but it takes us one hour max per week.
Depends on the distance they need to travel. Here for example I am over an hour away from town

So at least three hours given that i am alone.
 
There’s a difference between helping people in crisis and those who refuse to help themselves. This sounds incredibly toxic and my advice is to move out. If you choose to send money, be aware that it will most likely be mismanaged.

Also, how many times a week do you go grocery shopping??? Six hours?? I have a smaller family, but it takes us one hour max per week.
Yeah. I have a family of five people to feed and I do spend a lot of time at the grocery store (2-3 times a week), but even including transportation and unloading and doing it with a 4-year-old with me, I doubt it’s ever more than 3 hours a week.

Six hours a week is mental illness and/or her being controlling.
 
It’s time to cut the cord and move away… If your adult siblings worked and paid thier own way in the house, finances will be better.

Your adult siblings that are home need to step it up instead of playing video games. They need to become solid citizens. By funding them, you are a crutch with all of this. If you remove yourself perhaps they will be motivated to work Internet and gaming is not free. They are too comfortabe, kwim?

If you stop funding them, perhaps food will not be as plentiful. This is also a motivator.

As for your mother, she is ill…she should not be in charge of household finances, or shopping… i personally would offer to set up a budget within thier means, from afar. I would not give any financial help, just offer to help manage thier money for them within the earnings that are there. If you need to you can assist her with shopping, but don’t put any of your money toward this. This is to prevent overspending only.

I think the first thing to address though is your adult siblings that do nothing…if words don’t work, a lack of money that affects thier comfort will.
 
IMO you are not capable of caring for 2 mentally ill adults. It is one thing to send a little money and another to spend your life trying to be your family caregivers. I would suggest that you contact whatever state agencies there are in Australia that deal with children (for your youngest sibling) and mentally ill adults. It sounds to me like things are going to get worse not better.
 
Have a talk with your local government social services agency about help for adults who are mentally and physically disabled. Ask for guidance on what income assistance, living assistance, or other programs are available for them.

Make a plan with your other sibling who is out of the house and working for a way that their bills can be paid and necessities provided without direct access to money-- for example in the united states we have something called a representative or organizational payee for those deemed incompetent to handle their own money.

This is not something to handle yourself. This is a situation that requires knowledgeable people who know government assistance programs and which ones apply, what the various institutional and in-home care options are, etc.

You cannot support your entire family for the rest of your life. You cannot be responsible for adult siblings who refuse to work.

This is an extremely unhealthy environment for you to be in.
 
Yeah. I have a family of five people to feed and I do spend a lot of time at the grocery store (2-3 times a week), but even including transportation and unloading and doing it with a 4-year-old with me, I doubt it’s ever more than 3 hours a week.

Six hours a week is mental illness and/or her being controlling.
Agreed.
 
Hello Vincent,

This is difficult. Some people either can’t or won’t help themselves. Simply moving away is not the answer, but may be an option. I suggest talking to a mental health therapist and outlining your individual family’s issues. I know how easy it is for younger people to rely on others as opposed to relying on themselves. It is also possible that some people with certain life issues feel they are doing their best or may not recognize that they have a problem of any kind. They may even believe that all is as it should be. Or, in the case of depression, need treatment of some kind.

Speaking to a person - one on one - will help you sort things out. You, of course, need to consider your own future as best you can right now. Plan things out, even tentatively. Have some extra money to act as a cushion should you need it. Perhaps there is a service at your University where you could get some guidance. I know the ‘what will they do without me’ feeling. And some people can continue helping for many years.

Yes, some people cannot recognize their own issues for what they are. Some may even know others who are able to work but getting money from a “kind” relative means more time for fun, or what I call ‘just getting by.’

Get a qualified person to talk to and guide you through this. If money is an issue, and you have a low income, a reduced rate or payment plan may be possible.

Yes, we can’t fix others but we need to understand the situation by sometimes going outside of our families. There are people who are willing to help.

Hope this helps,

Ed
 
Hi Vincent,

Sorry about your situation and I want to affirm you for reaching out. Family dysfunction, and particularly generational family dysfunction is extremely difficult.

Since you mentioned this is taking an emotional toll on you, I would think the first thing to do is to begin taking care of yourself. That would probably entail finding your own place to live.

Second, assisting your mother is an admirable thing, yet children aren’t supposed to take care of their parents who have a spouse. The spouse is. It is really your dad’s responsibility to take care of his wife. Even acknowledging the mental illness, they are adults and should figure out how to take care of themselves as a couple.

Third, it would be a good idea to stop giving money to your adult siblings. Allow them to experience the consequences of their action / inaction.

Fourth, as you move on in life, getting some counseling or joining a support group for people from dysfunctional families would be beneficial to work through some of your experiences to this point in your life.

Good luck in your journey.
 
…As an introduction, I am male, twenty-one years of age, currently living in my parents’ house in Australia, after travelling and working overseas for a year
…However, I am cursed by this question: ‘what will happen to my family if I leave?’
How did they manage the year you were away?

Did you move back home because they were dysfunctional OR did you return home to discover they were more dysfunctional than you realized?
 
Vincent, you are a kind and loving soul.

I suggest a book by Dr. Henry Cloud titled “Boundaries”. You need them, boundaries that is, and your family are going to push, fuss, and possibly cuss when you put some in place.

You are young and putting forth the effort to build your life. I have some experience with toxic and hoarding/perfectionistic family members. Moving away was one of the most healthy things I ever did. 🙂

Don’t worry about your family of origin. They will probably continue as they are, this is their choice. Your father is working and sending money home (and btw there is never enough money, you could potentially send half of your earnings when one day you are successful. It sounds like you could give them a fortune and it will be mismanaged.)

You might, might have to contact children’s and family services if your mother continues in her illness. You might be able to help your youngest sibling if need be. But at the very least you will be helping them by living a good and healthy example.

Pray for them, go live a healthy life, and maybe you can mentor your siblings who want it.
 
OP, live your own life. It is unfortunate that your family may have emotional/medical issues, but you should not live your life as full time enabler.

Do check out the social services available in your area. Encourage your family members to seek professional help.
 
Hi Vincent,

Sorry about your situation and I want to affirm you for reaching out. Family dysfunction, and particularly generational family dysfunction is extremely difficult.

Since you mentioned this is taking an emotional toll on you, I would think the first thing to do is to begin taking care of yourself. That would probably entail finding your own place to live.

Second, assisting your mother is an admirable thing, yet children aren’t supposed to take care of their parents who have a spouse. The spouse is. It is really your dad’s responsibility to take care of his wife. Even acknowledging the mental illness, they are adults and should figure out how to take care of themselves as a couple.

Third, it would be a good idea to stop giving money to your adult siblings. Allow them to experience the consequences of their action / inaction.

Fourth, as you move on in life, getting some counseling or joining a support group for people from dysfunctional families would be beneficial to work through some of your experiences to this point in your life.

Good luck in your journey.
Completely agree with this post.
 
Hi, I am going to respond before reading the other posts. So if I repeat what’s been said, that’s why.

I feel terrible for you, and I will pray for you because you will be on my heart. You are just a year older than my own son and the thought of him being saddled with such problems makes me feel the grief of a mother. I am sure Blessed Mother feels grief for you! Since you will not get this from your earthly mother.

This family is broken and stressed and yes, you can’t fix it. Its a toxic environment. For their sake, if you are going to be any help to them, you need to* not be living there. *Yes, its true, for the immediate time you can give them more material goods and more practical help by living there (though they will be irresponsible with what you give them and it will aid their dependency) but over time you will have less to give, and burn yourself out and so choosing this in the long run, you will give them less. I am sure you see that no matter what you give, its not enough for them, and their sense of desperate dependency only increases when they see you as their only hope.

But if you use your youth and energy now to study and work and support yourself and to take the time to develop your own Catholic faith, your family will take a hit now, but in the long run, you will be able to give them more materially. In the meantime years, between now and when you can make more and aren’t spending on education/training, you can seek when you are able the professional/expert/spiritual advice you need for handling such a situation, which is a very complicated one. I would give any extra personal time you have to your younger siblings, though. Those are my thoughts. Especially that you have to get out of there. Its not good to live there.

P.S. Okay I read the thread now and see its full of good advice! I am sure you will have everyone’s prayers. God is extra close to you in this trial, with His heart of mercy and compassion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top