Natural Law, Condoms & Blindfolds, Difference?

  • Thread starter Thread starter D0UBTFIRE
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Guys, we need to get bettter at explaining to people why we believe what we believe. I include myself in that ‘we’.
 
Dr Janet Smith has a really good talk on why contraception is no good for society. “Contraception, why not?” Here’s an excerpt from it.

youtube.com/watch?v=eAJexmBX5lI

In this, she basically says contraception is just the prelude to abortion, because if it fails, abortion is the next step.
It also has led to decreased respect for women, because with contraception they’re expected to be ready at any time to have sex, there’s no excuse not to any more.
I think this tape, if you can find the whole thing, will answer the OPs questions, it’s very clear.
 
The purpose of sex is to both create unity and to create life.
But they don’t have to go together. You can have sex just to unify with your partner. And you can do the same with the intention of conceiving a child. That’s optional.

I know that there is an argument that says even when using natural planning, the female could still get pregnant so there is the potential to conceive. And I’ve even heard it argued that if it was impossible for the woman to get pregnant there is still the opportunity for a miraculous intervention.

But let’s say it was beyond any doubt whatsoever that she couldn’t get pregnant. And the church had no argument against sex in that situation. Then that would mean that there could be no argument against contraception because sex in that situation could not be ordered toward procreation and could only be described as purely unitive with no chance of a resultant pregnancy.

That is…just for fun.
 
Well, this thread is over a year old so it’s not likely that the OP will see this.

But I’ve struggled with the same question! Here’s an essay that attempts to answer it

In short: There is a difference between preventing a natural function (blindfold) and directing it to a contrary end (contraception).

Seems very subtle. Hmm…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top