New Catholic supports abortion

  • Thread starter Thread starter DKIN
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Keep in mind that full revelation and illumination does not occur suddenly for everyone, nor at the same rate for everyone. Just last night I was reading the commented Rule of St. Benedict that I read every day, on how this is true in a monastery and how it is the duty of each brother to patiently support those who are not yet at the same point on their faith journey that we’d like them to be.

I would suggest that this person’s view is not yet fully formed; she is in a sense a “novice” to the faith. I would be more inclined to support her with charity and discretion; in being her friend I would make it my duty to gently steer her towards things that will deepen her faith: bible study, adoration, etc., and let the Holy Spirit go to work. If she’s serious about studying her faith, she’ll come around eventually, and if she’s in RCIA she must have more than just a passing interest in Catholicism. Trying to force-feed her risks a great big backfire.

When someone in a group (not always believers) gets going on abortion and a “woman’s right to choose”, I typically say “you know, I was adopted as an infant (which is true). As such I tend to be quite biased on this issue, so I think I’ll just keep my mouth shut on this topic”. Oh boy does that stop them dead in their tracks. But I digress.

The important thing I think is to pray that she sustains and grows in her faith, and do things with her that help her sustain and grow in her faith, without getting in her face over this issue. If I look at what I believed when I first came back to the Church 15 years ago and what I believe now, there’s been quite an evolution.
Thank you for your thoughts. I understand your point and will continue to reflect on it. That said, keep in mind she is not in RCIA as you mentioned. She completed the class as did I and entered the Church. My understanding has always been that you must accept fully what the Church believes before making the decision to become Catholic. Not necessarily fully understanding the teachings, but accepting them…I think that is an important distinction, but I do understand that everyone’s journey moves at a different pace. But again as I have mentioned now a number of times, my bigger concern is the message it sends to non-believers or those of other faiths or even other Catholics when a new Catholic who has just received training in the faith pronounces their support for the pro-abortion movement as well as previous statements indicating that she believes homosexual marriage is okay…I think this could be very confusing to those folks I mentioned.

Again, thank you for your comments as they have been thought provoking.
 
I hope I am posting this in the correct forum. If not, please feel free to move to more appropriate place.

I’m not sure what I should do if anything and could use some advice. I am a former Southern Baptist who completed RCIA class earlier this year and am currently awaiting an annulment before I can fully enter the church with my wife. Our daughter was baptized Catholic during Easter Vigil.

One of my fellow RCIA classmates made it known during our class that she struggled with the Catholic position on gay marriage and abortion. None of my business, but I do feel that the class leadership (who by the way were terrific overall) should have taken her aside privately and maybe suggested that she pray about her conflicts with these Catholic teachings and study more on it to come to a place of acceptance if not full understanding before entering the church. Nevertheless, my issue is this. I am “friends” with her on Facebook and last night while the posts related to the election were flying…I see a post from her that follows…

“Ok that is it… I really need to find the Facebook setting that stops me from having to see posts of friends of friends. First it’s Romney’s, now it is pro life jargon… I feel like everytime I get on Facebook I am entering into republican/conservative land… I’m out until after the election. GO OBAMA!!! Oh and one last thing… **A woman has the right to choose…, ****signing off until later.”

Now, I found this a bit offensive on a couple of levels as a conservative Republican, but more over as someone who is trying his best to follow the teachings of the church and who believes them deeply. I pray every day that God bring me to his Son in the Eucharist while I await an annulment and meanwhile watch as she receives communion every Sunday at Mass. Furthermore I find the statement to be scandalous especially to those who know her and know that she just recently entered the church.

My question is this…do I do anything or do I just let it go and pray for her that she will somehow be enlightened as to Christ’s teachings on these matters? I thought of going to my parish priest, but don’t know if it is my place to “call her out” so to speak. Or if I should go to her directly, which I suspect would not be well received.

Any thoughts on this would be very much appreciated.

God Bless,

Dave-

If you feel prepared and have prayed then you need to visit privately with her but do so with Christian charity. In the household of faith we owe it to those in the family of faith to discuss issues of a moral nature at all times and always be prepared to do so in love, this is very hard to do and the easy way out would be to ignore these things as I’m afraid I and so many others have done for too long. We need to be bold but with a strong sense of His love for others foremost in our mind and hearts.

Prayers for you and WELCOME, I’m a recent convert (this past year) and am so grateful to be Catholic!

mlz,
mlz
 
Keep in mind that full revelation and illumination does not occur suddenly for everyone, nor at the same rate for everyone. Just last night I was reading the commented Rule of St. Benedict that I read every day, on how this is true in a monastery and how it is the duty of each brother to patiently support those who are not yet at the same point on their faith journey that we’d like them to be.

I would suggest that this person’s view is not yet fully formed; she is in a sense a “novice” to the faith. I would be more inclined to support her with charity and discretion; in being her friend I would make it my duty to gently steer her towards things that will deepen her faith: bible study, adoration, etc., and let the Holy Spirit go to work. If she’s serious about studying her faith, she’ll come around eventually, and if she’s in RCIA she must have more than just a passing interest in Catholicism. Trying to force-feed her risks a great big backfire.

When someone in a group (not always believers) gets going on abortion and a “woman’s right to choose”, I typically say “you know, I was adopted as an infant (which is true). As such I tend to be quite biased on this issue, so I think I’ll just keep my mouth shut on this topic”. Oh boy does that stop them dead in their tracks. But I digress.

The important thing I think is to pray that she sustains and grows in her faith, and do things with her that help her sustain and grow in her faith, without getting in her face over this issue. If I look at what I believed when I first came back to the Church 15 years ago and what I believe now, there’s been quite an evolution.
I understand your point and what you are trying to say but someone who is joining the Catholic Church but doesn’t accept key moral teachings and then goes on a public forum such as facebook to mouth off about abortion is not someone trying to accept or understand the Churches moral teaching and just is not there yet. It is one thing to become Catholic and needs to grow in understanding of Church teaching but it is another thing to knowingly join and publically take issue with the Church in areas such as abortion and flaunt it on facebook. We already have enough problems with too many Catholic that want to pick and choose what they want to believe and practice in their faith. Following Christ is following the Church. Yes it is a growth journey but Op has a right to be concern for public scandal as well as for this person’s soul.
 
I understand your point and what you are trying to say but someone who is joining the Catholic Church but doesn’t accept key moral teachings and then goes on a public forum such as facebook to mouth off about abortion is not someone trying to accept or understand the Churches moral teaching and just is not there yet. It is one thing to become Catholic and needs to grow in understanding of Church teaching but it is another thing to knowingly join and publically take issue with the Church in areas such as abortion and flaunt it on facebook. We already have enough problems with too many Catholic that want to pick and choose what they want to believe and practice in their faith. Following Christ is following the Church. Yes it is a growth journey but Op has a right to be concern for public scandal as well as for this person’s soul.
👍 Thank you for telling it as it is!
 
Above all pray for her. Conversion from being pro-choice is something that starts in the heart. You may or may not be able to talk to her and convince her of the other side, but you have to pray for her that she’ll be open to it in the first place. And such discussions can be deeply emotional–she might have had an abortion in the past and is not ready to deal with the guilt. Whether you talk to her or not, prayer is a must.
 
I am praying for her and I have not made any suggestion that she should not receive communion and have made it quite clear my intent is not to tattle. Additionally, I have not claimed to be without sin…quite the contrary I’m a wreck and in need of salvation! My worry is that what she has done in proclaiming her support for the pro-choice movement could be scandalizing to those who read her post. I think I’ve been as clear as possible on my concerns and intentions. It seems that some are not reading my post and are instead reading into it and making assumptions as to what is in my heart.
You are not alone, I understand what you are saying. I know you must be torn and want to do the right thing. And that is admirable.

If it were me, if she said something to me, then I would have to quote her the CCC 2270:
“Human life must be respected and protected absolutely from the moment of conception. From the first moment of his existence, a human being must be recognized as having the rights of a person - among which is the inviolable right of every innocent being to life.”

If she didn’t say something to me, then I would not say it to her. Saying it to you means you have the obligation to answer and she has the right to a correct answer.

Otherwise, say a short prayer for her as often as you want.

Another answer you might consider is that Jesus in the womb of Mary was complete at the first moment of his conception when she said to the angel, “be it done to me according to your word.”
“And the Word was made flesh.”
If Jesus was complete at the first moment, then we too are complete at the first moment.

Be at peace.
 
Above all pray for her. Conversion from being pro-choice is something that starts in the heart. You may or may not be able to talk to her and convince her of the other side, but you have to pray for her that she’ll be open to it in the first place. And such discussions can be deeply emotional–she might have had an abortion in the past and is not ready to deal with the guilt. Whether you talk to her or not, prayer is a must.
I think the OP is doing that already and your suggestion about a past abortion could be true but coming into the Church in RCIA, one does have to go to confession before receiving the Eucharist. If there had been a past abortion, it should be confessed there and then. If this were true, she should go a seek help and healing for it which is very much available for post-abortion women. It is curious why someone would want to become Catholic and still be very militant about being pro-abortion and openly so.
 
What is the outcome you hope to achieve? Conversion? Keeping a liberal out of the Church? Punishing her for her views? You need to sort that out first
. Also, ‘right to choose’ is not far from Catholic teaching. nonsense
asthenosphere |asˈθenəˌsfi(ə)r|
noun Geology
the upper layer of the earth’s mantle, below the lithosphere, in which there is relatively low resistance to plastic flow and convection is thought to occur.
 
What is the outcome you hope to achieve? Conversion? Keeping a liberal out of the Church? Punishing her for her views? You need to sort that out first. Also, ‘right to choose’ is not far from Catholic teaching. While the Church upholds the need for laws to protect life, this is not the same issue asthenosphere choices made by women whether or not there are laws against abortion. You have a view on what women should choose, or be supported to choose. Maybe your friend does also. Try asking.
nonsense
 
What is the outcome you hope to achieve? Conversion? Keeping a liberal out of the Church? Punishing her for her views? You need to sort that out first. Also, ‘right to choose’ is not far from Catholic teaching. While the Church upholds the need for laws to protect life, this is not the same issue asthenosphere choices made by women whether or not there are laws against abortion. You have a view on what women should choose, or be supported to choose. Maybe your friend does also. Try asking.
asthenosphere |asˈθenəˌsfi(ə)r|
noun Geology
the upper layer of the earth’s mantle, below the lithosphere, in which there is relatively low resistance to plastic flow and convection is thought to occur.
 
I hope I am posting this in the correct forum. If not, please feel free to move to more appropriate place.

I’m not sure what I should do if anything and could use some advice. I am a former Southern Baptist who completed RCIA class earlier this year and am currently awaiting an annulment before I can fully enter the church with my wife. Our daughter was baptized Catholic during Easter Vigil.

One of my fellow RCIA classmates made it known during our class that she struggled with the Catholic position on gay marriage and abortion. None of my business, but I do feel that the class leadership (who by the way were terrific overall) should have taken her aside privately and maybe suggested that she pray about her conflicts with these Catholic teachings and study more on it to come to a place of acceptance if not full understanding before entering the church. Nevertheless, my issue is this. I am “friends” with her on Facebook and last night while the posts related to the election were flying…I see a post from her that follows…

“Ok that is it… I really need to find the Facebook setting that stops me from having to see posts of friends of friends. First it’s Romney’s, now it is pro life jargon… I feel like everytime I get on Facebook I am entering into republican/conservative land… I’m out until after the election. GO OBAMA!!! Oh and one last thing… **A woman has the right to choose…, ****signing off until later.”

Now, I found this a bit offensive on a couple of levels as a conservative Republican, but more over as someone who is trying his best to follow the teachings of the church and who believes them deeply. I pray every day that God bring me to his Son in the Eucharist while I await an annulment and meanwhile watch as she receives communion every Sunday at Mass. Furthermore I find the statement to be scandalous especially to those who know her and know that she just recently entered the church.

My question is this…do I do anything or do I just let it go and pray for her that she will somehow be enlightened as to Christ’s teachings on these matters? I thought of going to my parish priest, but don’t know if it is my place to “call her out” so to speak. Or if I should go to her directly, which I suspect would not be well received.

Any thoughts on this would be very much appreciated.

God Bless,

Dave-

Well, the only reason I see you having an obligation to do something was if you had some kind of reasonable expectation that she would change. That could be necessary under pain of mortal sin.
newadvent.org/cathen/04394a.htm

But when talking about public posts on facebook, I don’t see that, certainly not in this case.

I have previously told Catholics who are vocal about being pro-choice or in favor of so-called “gay marriage” that they should refrain from Communion.

I want to encourage you to do this, but I also want you to realize that especially on the internet the chance of getting through with one message is small. 😦

If something is publicly stated like that, I usually respond directly to the post as it is in public.
 
=DKIN;9989188]I hope I am posting this in the correct forum. If not, please feel free to move to more appropriate place.
I’m not sure what I should do if anything and could use some advice. I am a former Southern Baptist who completed RCIA class earlier this year and am currently awaiting an annulment before I can fully enter the church with my wife. Our daughter was baptized Catholic during Easter Vigil.
One of my fellow RCIA classmates made it known during our class that she struggled with the Catholic position on gay marriage and abortion. None of my business, but I do feel that the class leadership (who by the way were terrific overall) should have taken her aside privately and maybe suggested that she pray about her conflicts with these Catholic teachings and study more on it to come to a place of acceptance if not full understanding before entering the church. Nevertheless, my issue is this. I am “friends” with her on Facebook and last night while the posts related to the election were flying…I see a post from her that follows…
“Ok that is it… I really need to find the Facebook setting that stops me from having to see posts of friends of friends. First it’s Romney’s, now it is pro life jargon… I feel like everytime I get on Facebook I am entering into republican/conservative land… I’m out until after the election. GO OBAMA!!! Oh and one last thing… **A woman has the right to choose…, ****signing off until later.”
Now, I found this a bit offensive on a couple of levels as a conservative Republican, but more over as someone who is trying his best to follow the teachings of the church and who believes them deeply. I pray every day that God bring me to his Son in the Eucharist while I await an annulment and meanwhile watch as she receives communion every Sunday at Mass. Furthermore I find the statement to be scandalous especially to those who know her and know that she just recently entered the church.
My question is this…do I do anything or do I just let it go and pray for her that she will somehow be enlightened as to Christ’s teachings on these matters? I thought of going to my parish priest, but don’t know if it is my place to “call her out” so to speak. Or if I should go to her directly, which I suspect would not be well received.
Any thoughts on this would be very much appreciated.
God Bless,
NO, None, Zip, Zerro “Catholic” can hold these views and participate in any of the Sacramnts.
Take your very just concerns in private to the RCIA teachers and let them knwo how you feel. IF they do not do it; take it to your DRE or pastor. Serious stuff here. And the Instructors MAY??? Have missed an obligation. On the other hand thy may have alrealy done it in private???
FYI: I taught RCIA for 3v years…
God Bless,
pat /PM
 
What is the outcome you hope to achieve? Conversion? Keeping a liberal out of the Church? Punishing her for her views? You need to sort that out first. Also, ‘right to choose’ is not far from Catholic teaching. While the Church upholds the need for laws to protect life, this is not the same issue asthenosphere choices made by women whether or not there are laws against abortion. You have a view on what women should choose, or be supported to choose. Maybe your friend does also. Try asking.
nonsense
 
NO, None, Zip, Zerro “Catholic” can hold these views and participate in any of the Sacramnts.

Take your very just concerns in private to the RCIA teachers and let them knwo how you feel. IF they do not do it; take it to your DRE or pastor. Serious stuff here. And the Instructors MAY??? Have missed an obligation. On the other hand thy may have alrealy done it in private???

FYI: I taught RCIA for 3v years…

Pray,

God Bless,
pat /PM
not true , one would have to act on these beliefs.
 
It sounds to me like she isn’t open to the teachings based on her facebook postings. I have no idea how you should approach this, I just felt like I should chime in because I was in her position when I went through RCIA. Maybe you could even send her a link to the woman I’m about to talk about.

I am ambivalent about some teachings of the Church but I am completely open to them, and I’m working on coming to an understanding of the ones I take issue with. I do have faith that the Church is correct based on my experience with birth control. Even on a secular level birth control does not make sense. When you compare it to NFP on efficacy (which is close, I’ll give them that), financial cost, and physical risk and complications - NFP wins by a long shot; people are simply uneducated about it. I wouldn’t call that faith on my part, but it bolstered my confidence on Church teachings. After reading what Pope Paul VI had to say about it and how prophetic it was, I’m now sold in faith to the Church. I take it on good faith that the connections the church makes between a sin here and how it effects the future in multiple ways later is correct. I have faith that God has a plan that works and when we don’t follow it bad things happen.

Abortion I was on the fence about. I always felt abortion had been abused and the morning after pill I just envisioned pure debauchery and women taking one every morning with their aspirin as though everything they did to their body was just a hangover from the night before to be rid of. By the grace of God I stumbled upon this: catholicnewsagency.com/news/abby-johnson-reveals-details-of-pro-life-turnaround-and-catholic-conversion/
I don’t believe I was even looking for something of this specific nature. And I cried when I read the part about the ultrasound. I am now adamantly pro life.

Like birth control, people are pro choice for the same reason they are anti NFP - they simply are not fully informed.

Now, we cannot know the state of someone’s soul. Perhaps you could simply ask her WHY she believes what she does and see what she says, just genuinely listen to her. Until you know why she feels that way it will be very difficult to share your point of view (and the Church’s) without possibly pushing her further away. Maybe that article will change her the way it changed me?

Maybe another approach would be to show her how the media hides the truth of abortion and skews information on it? A big pro choice argument is rape. I found a page (that was very hard to find and I wish I had bookmarked it) that was sadly outdated - 2008 - saying 1% of women who requested abortions cited rape. I did find this which had similar information:
citizenlink.com/2011/12/08/abortion-statistics/

I would like to add that my personal approach at the moment is to download audio from the EWTN library - particularly on topics that I am uninformed on or am not so passionately behind - to educate myself. I’ve already found that after listening to a good program on it I’m converted to varying degrees. Right now I’m listening to a really good one on euthanasia on The Good Fight radio show.

I think understanding is key to any issue.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top