New Church Book for Married couples

  • Thread starter Thread starter HagiaSophia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

HagiaSophia

Guest
Vatican sex guide
By Julian Coman
(Filed: 31/10/2004)

A Vatican-sanctioned sex guide is encouraging churchgoers to make love more often in an effort to offset “impotence and frigidity” and address papal concerns over declining birth-rates among Italian Roman Catholics.

The controversial book, It’s A Sin Not To Do It, written by two theologians, promises the reader answers to “everything you wanted to know about sex but the Church (almost) never dared to tell you”.

In their attempt to galvanise the faithful, Roberto Beretta and Elisabetta Broli, who write regularly for the Italian Bishops’ magazine, Avvenire, have written one of the raciest works ever to deal with the Church and sex.

Bullet points on the jacket cover underline the central message: “Sex? God invented it. Original sin? Sex has nothing to do with it. Without sex there is no real marriage.”

“When people think of the Church and sex, they think of prohibitions and taboos,” said Beretta. “But there is a very different and positive side to Church doctrine which needs to be emphasised.”

In both style and content, the guide - published earlier this month - marks a radical break with traditional Church pronouncements on physical intimacy. Forty years ago, the Vatican published a notorious set of guidelines for courting Catholics that outlawed even French kissing before marriage.

The pages of It’s A Sin Not To Do It, however, feature a frank interview with Cardinal Ersilio Tonini in which he emphasises that “the Church is not an enemy of the flesh”. He argues that Vatican doctrine has always defended the “nobility of sexuality”, which is regarded by the Church as a “treasure” of humanity…
The authors have included passages taken from previous papal statements on sexuality, and pronouncements from cardinals who advocate a “healthy Catholic materialism” about marital sex.

The Vatican has regularly expressed its concerns over Italy’s low birth rate, which stands at fewer than nine births per thousand inhabitants. Two years ago, in an address to the Italian parliament, Pope John Paul described the declining rate as “a serious threat that weighs on the future of the country”.

According to Beretta, the book is a comprehensive summary of Church doctrine on sexuality, couched in deliberately populist language.

He said: “We deliberately set out to discuss the Church’s attitude towards sex in frank, secular language. But everything in this book is taken from conventional doctrine. Because of the widespread assumption that the Church loathes sexuality, most people are not aware of the positive things it has to say about physical intimacy.”

He is now awaiting reader reaction. “The Vatican has not raised any concerns about the tone and style of the book,” he said. “Some people might find it a little direct. But at least after reading this book, they will have a balanced picture of what the Church actually thinks about sex.”

telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2004/10/31/wvat31.xml&sSheet=/news/2004/10/31/ixnewstop.html
 
40.png
HagiaSophia:
Vatican sex guide
By Julian Coman
(Filed: 31/10/2004)

In both style and content, the guide - published earlier this month - marks a radical break with traditional Church pronouncements on physical intimacy. Forty years ago, the Vatican published a notorious set of guidelines for courting Catholics that outlawed even French kissing before marriage.

telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2004/10/31/wvat31.xml&sSheet=/news/2004/10/31/ixnewstop.html
This article is misleading. There has been no “radical break” with Church teaching. This book, if the article is accurate about it’s contents, is in regard to MARITAL sexuality. There has been NO change in what the Church teaches regarding PREMARITAL sexual activity.

I would guess that this book has nothing new regarding church teaching, probably a lot like Christopher West’s materials based on the pope’s Theology of the Body.
 
40.png
1ke:
This article is misleading. There has been no “radical break” with Church teaching. This book, if the article is accurate about it’s contents, is in regard to MARITAL sexuality. There has been NO change in what the Church teaches regarding PREMARITAL sexual activity.

I would guess that this book has nothing new regarding church teaching, probably a lot like Christopher West’s materials based on the pope’s Theology of the Body.
I did not find the article misleading at all; if you will reread it, it does not infer that there is a radical departure from church teaching, the article simply indicates the book is radical departure from the style of other works preceding it.

If you will check the thread title, it clearly indicates the material is aimed at married couples - no one implied or inferred in the article or in the post that it was anything else.
 
I hope the authors understand the problem behind population decline is not so much married couples avoiding sex but couples avoiding conception by artificial means.
 
40.png
asquared:
I hope the authors understand the problem behind population decline is not so much married couples avoiding sex but couples avoiding conception by artificial means.
I gathered in reading the full article that it does indeed address the need for procreation and the church position.

From the full article:

"“In view of the trivialisation of sex and the rise of impotence and frigidity in consequence, as well as the increasing number of only children, it is better for the Church to promote sex in the right circumstances, instead of just focusing on prohibitions and perversions.”

The authors have included passages taken from previous papal statements on sexuality, and pronouncements from cardinals who advocate a “healthy Catholic materialism” about marital sex.

The Vatican has regularly expressed its concerns over Italy’s low birth rate, which stands at fewer than nine births per thousand inhabitants. Two years ago, in an address to the Italian parliament, Pope John Paul described the declining rate as “a serious threat that weighs on the future of the country”.
 
40.png
HagiaSophia:
I did not find the article misleading at all; if you will reread it, it does not infer that there is a radical departure from church teaching, the article simply indicates the book is radical departure from the style of other works preceding it.

If you will check the thread title, it clearly indicates the material is aimed at married couples - no one implied or inferred in the article or in the post that it was anything else.
Re-read the article. I quoted directly from it. It states that in style and CONTENT this new book is a “radical break” with previous Church teaching on physical intimacy. My beef isn’t with the book-- which is suspect is perfectly fine-- but with the article trying to imply the book contains something it does not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top