new rules on sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter traillius
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

traillius

Guest
Hello,
Can someone tell where I can find info on what constitutes a mortal sin, I think the ‘rules’ may have changed. I know 10 commandments are the basic guidelines. I am just not sure what exactly is included.
 
** I think the ‘rules’ may have changed.**

Where did you get that idea?
 
Two things:
  1. a reasonable examination of conscience
I found this guide to an Examination of Conscience, which seems to be pretty effective:

scborromeo.org/confess.htm
  1. knowing that three conditions need to be met for a sinful action to be a mortal sin:

    a) it must be seriously sinful matter;

    b) the person must know that it is a seriously sinful matter;

    c) the sin must be committed deliberately.
There is also the issue of scrupulosity, which acts on item 2c.

As a guide, there are Websites, newsletters and books on scrupulosity. Just do a search on CAF for “scrupulosity”.

There is really nothing new in any of this.
 
Hello,
Can someone tell where I can find info on what constitutes a mortal sin, I think the ‘rules’ may have changed. I know 10 commandments are the basic guidelines. I am just not sure what exactly is included.
Yes, there are some new rules regarding what a mortal sin is. I think they were first introduced by some Guy over in the middle, but people did not like Him so they crucified Him. But He got the drop on them, He rose from the dead three days later. The rules have not changed since then.

And the “rules” for a sin to be mortal are:

If must be a grave or serious matter. For example, adultery, significant theft, unjustly taking a person’s life, pride, arrogance, lust, gluttony refusing to give honor to God by skipping Sunday Mass, etc.

The person must know it is a sin. This knowledge can come either from the natural law written on all our hearts, like adultery arrogance, lust gluttony, or it can come learning what the Church teaches on matter of faith and morals, like missing Mass or abusing the matter of Holy Communion.

The person must have time, even if briefly, to consider this and chooses to sin anyway. Thus a person cannot accidently commit a mortal sin. And some sins, by their very nature are practically always mortal, such as sexual sins, as they require some consideration and the person has time to stop.

A person’s culpability may be lessened if they are either in ignorance or under duress. In most cases, only God can know how much culpability is reduced.

In Section II of the catechism, each Commandment is examined in detail. The sins, as well as our responsibilities, relating to it, are described. It is very interesting reading.

vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/_INDEX.HTM
 
The rules which make any thought, word or action sinful remain the same. There has been in recent time emphasis put that we also have an obligation towards our environment and should act responsibly within our means to do so, and not to do so could be sinful. This, I think the media has picked up on as “a new sin”. It is not really new at all. Most thinking Catholics realizing in these days of realizing the danger to our environemt, and that our environment is created by God and that we have been placed as stewards over it, do understand that we have a God given obligation within our means towards it…in recent days, however, this has been stated and I think by a Bishop or Cardinal and the media has made a big fuss about it. Something like that I think.

Blessings - Barb:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top