No More "Liberal" or "Conservative", please!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cominghome89
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Who wants to hide? Not me.

But the danger comes when one does not embrace every tenet of an ideology and it is misleading to label them as such.

For instance, Ron Paul is labeled a conservative, yet, I believe he is pro gay marriage.

Many people call Blessed John Paul and Pope Beenedict liberal, but it is evident that they are not liberal in every tenet of the faith.

Some children are labeled ADD, ADHD, etc. when what they need is time to mature and learn some self control.

Labels are generalities and many times do a disservice to the one labeled.
Ron Paul labels himself as a conservative, so as to hide what his true affiliation is. He’s a Libertarian but he knows enough to hide that in order to be re-elected. He’s down the line, a Libertarian first, last and always. His supporters try to echo what he calls himself, but being that many of them are college students who are anxious for pot to be legalized, they can’t do much convincing of others.
 
Labels are generalities and many times do a disservice to the one labeled.
More often, however, they provide a great service in helping to communicate information without having to go down an infinitely long checklist to fully describe a person.
 
More often, however, they provide a great service in helping to communicate information without having to go down an infinitely long checklist to fully describe a person.
Exactly my point. I don’t know many pro-abortion people that are traditional in everything else, or many pro-gay-“marriage” supporters that attend a latin Mass. Just sayin’
 
Please move this if it is posted improperly, but since a lot of these labels often have to do with liturgical ideas, this was the best I could find.

Our Moral Theology professor at the seminary, who is at a parish notoriously labeled as extremely “conservative,” brought up the problem of the use of these words, and he’s absolutely right. For those of us who are very informed about Church teaching and belief, trust me, I know that we understand the connotations “liberal” or “conservative” have when speaking about certain Catholics, clergy, or just positions in general. But the results of using these words can be very damaging.

The truth is, these words have such a politicized meaning, which constantly changes with the state of politics. And, these meanings have nothing to do with the Church, and can greatly confuse the Catholics who do not have a firm grasp on Church teaching. Please, if somebody believes something that is contrary to the defined dogma of the Church, simply state that the Church teaches otherwise. Do not label the person a liberal. Likewise, if somebody has a preference for a tradition that has fallen out of common practice, do not label them an “ultra-conservative”.

This serves two very important purposes, I think. First, it’s so important that we avoid these terms for the sake of Church unity. If you have a problem with someone’s belief that you consider to be against Church teaching, outdated, whatever it is, address it quietly and truthfully. This division in the Church between liberal and conservative, traditional and progressive, is tearing out unity apart, especially among the clergy. Address people, tell them your issue, but please do not throw these words around. Also, I think avoiding these terms will help us to actually find out what the Church teaches. Is a person a “liberal” because their view is truly heretical? Or is their view on a teaching that the Church has never defined, and you just disagree? Big difference! In the same way, does the person prefer the Extraordinary Form of the Mass, or does he claim that it is the only valid form? Again, biggg difference.

I would like to hear people’s take on this, because I am often labeled “conservative” when I am no such thing. I love Latin, I am 100 percent faithful to the teaching of the Church, and I have a deep appreciation for liturgy. But I am also aware that there are brother seminarians and clergy who do not share my tastes, and often that is just fine! Point: do your homework, find out what is essential for orthodox belief and worship, and stop throwing around these misleading labels! Thank you for listening 🙂

In caritate Christi et Mariae,
Frank
I couldn’t agree more! THANK YOU for posting this. People need to understand far better what you have explained. Well done, Frank. 🙂
I see no problem with these labels, as they are quite accurate.
On the contrary - they can’t be accurate or inaccurate, because most of the time they’re so vague, generic, and vapid that they’re utterly useless and intellectually irresponsible.

The problem is precisely this vagueness. What “liberal” or “conservative” means depends greatly on the context.

Does “liberal” mean socially liberal? Economically liberal? And what even is economically liberal? Does that mean mildly socialist, or classical neo-liberalism? And the confusion goes on…

Even on the relatively narrow level of American politics, what does “conservative” mean? Pre-2002 and post-2002 the term has quite different and even incompatible foreign policy connotations.

There are far more precise terms we could be using. “Liberal” and “conservative” are useless and vague terms that most often serve no other purpose except as sticks to beat one’s ideological opponents with.
What do you mean by the following
I am 100 percent faithful to the teaching of the Church, and I have a deep appreciation for liturgy. vs there are brother seminarians and clergy who do not share my tastes, and often that is just fine

Does that mean it’s okay with you for clergy and teachers NOT to be 100% faithful to Church teaching in the seminary, nor appreciative for liturgy? :confused:
No, it means it’s perfectly okay for clergy and teachers not to share his liturgical tastes.
 
Woops. I didn’t realize it’s against forum rules to mention any political candidate by name. Please ignore my previous post. And if the mods happen by, could you remove it?

😊
 
No, no, no. Thank you for having me clarify, was not worded well. What I meant was, that there are brother seminarians and clergy who are also very faithful to the teachings of the Church, and appreciate the liturgy, who have different tastes. Some are terrible with Latin, or just don’t care for it. Some prefer clerical shirts, and prefer not to wear the cassock. There are a million other examples of details that do not define one’s orthodoxy and faithfulness to the Church. And that’s what I meant to address: that someone who prefers not to celebrate the EF or to wear the cassock, is not a less orthodox or less faithful Catholic. That’s all.

It’s interesting to note the many responses to this post, many disagreeing. You think that the labels “liberal” and “conservative” are both appropriate and straightforward, yet the various examples given in these posts suggest that people have many different ideas. Some liken the terms to their political connotations, liberal democrats and conservative republicans. Others understand them in the sense of traditional or modern liturgical tastes. Some use the more basic definition: conservatives wish to maintain the status quo, liberals wish to move forward with new ideas. All these definitions certainly have overlap, yet the words can be taken to mean different things by different people. All I wish is to make that clear, that we be very careful to clarify the terms when they are used when referring to Catholics.

Somebody asked above “Should we just use the harsher terms ‘orthodox’ and ‘heretical’.” And I would almost say yes, with an explanation. Because these terms are clear: an orthodox Catholic believes in and follows all the doctrines of the Holy Church, anyone who does not holds a heretical belief.

I didn’t write this with any strong agenda, I just wanted to see the various responses. Thank you.

In caritate Christi et Mariae,
Frank
:thankyou:thanks for the clarification
 
I think when we use labels we have a higher chance of the political usages getting caught in our heads and they retain for the rest of the talk. When I go to sites like Catholic.org and see people describing themselves as “Progressive” Catholics, I get a chill because I see the political Progressives in my head and I don’t want that thinking at all in the Church. The Truth is not Progressive or anything else, it’s just the Truth. We should have our eyes towards God, and the Church. Even though more than likely the labels will remain.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top