Non-Catholics wearing the rosary

  • Thread starter Thread starter saribee
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

saribee

Guest
It is my understanding that one should not wear a rosary. However, it seems to be the newest fashion. Yesterday I encountered two people who were wearing them who weren’t Catholics, and I don’t know if one was even a Christian. It seems disrespectful to wear it as a pretty piece of jewelry.

If this person is a classmate or co-worker you know kind of well (not just some random person in a store), is it okay to gently explain that a rosary is not for fashion, but for prayer? What have you done in situations like these?
 
Sadly rosary beads are becoming a fashion accessory, people don’t understand their true meaning and significance to us. It’s the same with crosses, people wear them as fashion items without really knowing what they mean. If you don’t practice a faith, it’s very disrespectful to wear a symbol of that faith.

If it is someone you know fairly well, you could ask if they know what the rosary is and its significance to Catholics. They will most likely not, so then you explain what they are and that they are devotional and used for prayer and that they are not to be worn as fashion necklaces. Try to be kind and charitable, assuming that they are doing it out of ignorance rather than malice. By approaching it in this way, you avoid offending them by assuming they know the significance and are abusing it anyway.
 
They give them out in prisons (here in England) in the same way as the Bible but in prison it is usually drug dealers that wear them so the users know who to go to.

I guess that it is fashionable in the same way as saying you have been inside or speaking like a gangsta rapper.
 
Unless they are wearing them in a really disrespectful way, I would just let it go. It could be Our Lady’s way of calling them home.
 
I personally would not wear a rosary as a necklace. However, if you go to the rosary manufacturers’ catalogs and websites, you will notice that they manufacture and market items known as rosary necklaces, which have a clasp halfway through the circular section of the rosary necklace, making them designed to be worn around the neck. I’ve seen such products offered for sale in Catholic book and gift stores, including the one operated by my diocese. Because of the gang connotation, it’s a little on the questionable side.

However, if I saw someone who obviously didn’t know the purpose of a rosary wearing one about their neck, I might, if I knew the person, tell them something like, “If you ever want to know what it’s really used for, and how to do it, let me know,” in a friendly way, maybe even with a wink and a smile. That might pique their curiosity, and who knows where that may lead? Maybe even to a conversion?

I just want to comment about a trend I’ve noticed in society as a whole, especially over the last fifteen years or so: Every group has its vocal members who claim an offense quite loudly, where no offense probably was intended. I know I’ve been been guilty of being a little touchy about some things, and pray I haven’t needlessly alienated people out of such reactivity, particularly in matters of faith. I’ve been praying about this a lot lately, as it occurred to me that reacting in thinking the worst motives may have lost, through my failure to slow down and think before speaking, souls that could have been lead to Christ. I don’t want that on my conscience, and I don’t want to stand in front of my Maker having to explain such foolish shortsightedness. A rosary, after all, unless it has been blessed by a priest or a deacon, is merely a set of beads and medallions on a string, chain or wire. It is the blessing and prayers said with it that makes it a sacramental. Obviously, it shouldn’t be desecrated. But is that a reason to ascribe bad motives to people I know slightly, and perhaps turn them off from the faith forever? And furthermore, wearing one around one’s neck may look tacky, but it isn’t actually desecrating a rosary.

I don’t know where this thought is taking me, but I pray that considered, discreet, and charitable teaching might be one way that I can be blessed as a peacemaker instead of adding to the rage that is already in the world. Don’t ask me to reason this out further; as I said, this is something I’m discerning.

And just maybe that rosary necklace, initially used in a secular way, might be a piece of advertising for Our Lady!
 
It is my understanding that one should not wear a rosary. However, it seems to be the newest fashion. Yesterday I encountered two people who were wearing them who weren’t Catholics, and I don’t know if one was even a Christian. It seems disrespectful to wear it as a pretty piece of jewelry.

If this person is a classmate or co-worker you know kind of well (not just some random person in a store), is it okay to gently explain that a rosary is not for fashion, but for prayer? What have you done in situations like these?
What Jesus said: “Those who are not against us, are for us”
 
what kind of helps me deal with this whole “fashion statement” that people have (which I think ultimately began with Madonna and came back into fashion with the show Jersey Shore) is the fact that I am pretty sure most people that are wearing the Rosary are wearing a rosary that is most likely not Blessed by a Priest, therefore it is not a sacramental if it is not Blessed to my understanding. I do get upset when I see this too but try to remind myself it is not Blessed. Not to say that makes it okay to wear the rosary I know its wrong but what I mean is that it gives me some comfort in knowing it holds no weight if it isn’t a Blessed Rosary, I could be wrong but just my thoughts on it.
 
A generic rosary an be found in many high street stores such as Top Shop/Man or River Island, H & M. 2011 saw the rosary become a thing of fashion, most likely to give an impression of higher faith, culture and spirituality.
 
What Jesus said: “Those who are not against us, are for us”
You can’t use that quote out of context.

"For whoever is not against us is for us." (Mark 9 40)

"Whoever is not with me is against me" (Luke 11:23)


Context is everything in the Bible.

-Tim-
 
You can’t use that quote out of context.

"For whoever is not against us is for us." (Mark 9 40)

"Whoever is not with me is against me" (Luke 11:23)

Context is everything in the Bible.

-Tim-
Yes, I can.
You forgot that one thing is the meaning of Jesus another is my meaning.
Within “my” context, the quotation was perfect…
Jesus said (my english wont help) not to break what is plintered, not to put out the somke that indicates fire, be gentle…
And when someone was preaching and makeing miracles and did not belong to Christ’s followers the Apostles complained (beginning of Monopoly!), and Jesus said, Thoses who are not against me are for me.
Perfect for the situation.
 
I’d just approach them in ignorance and say, “Oh, you have a devotion to the Blessed Mother? Great, let’s prey the rosary together. Today is the X Mysteries.”

BTW, I wear my rosary under my work shirt. I figure it’s better than being stuffed in my pocket. Why is it disrespectful to wear the rosary? Wouldn’t it be a witness to God?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top