Old Testament Sacrifice, Why?

  • Thread starter Thread starter bengeorge
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

bengeorge

Guest
A series of connected questions:
  1. What was the purpose of the Old Testament sacrifice of animals? Was it to cover the temporal punishment or eternal punishment of sins?
  2. If it was to cover the temporal punishment of sins, why do we not still do it, since we still experience temporal punishment?
  3. If it was to cover the eternal punishment, why did God demand it at all, seeing as how it would be totally ineffective?
I am leading a discussion of Sin and Grace next week, and I would like to trace the history of Sin and Grace, from the Garden and the Fall to the Flood to the Law to the Temple to the Cross to the Mass.

Any thoughts or analogies or anything would be appreciated.
 
The sacrifices didn’t really cover situations where the person had sinned with a “high hand”. That is, deliberately, knowingly, with malice, etc. It more covers unknowing failures, as I understand it.

How did Israel or God conceive these sacrifices? I have not the theological background to answer that question. Probably God knew they would teach Israel many lessons, say of being separate and holy. Also to trust/depend on God. Israel had connection to God through the sacrifice system, so for them perhaps it allowed them to worship.

These are the same folks who didn’t want to get too close to God, who were chicken. Deu 18:16 I think the whole cleanliness and sacrifice thing helps address this.
 
40.png
bengeorge:
A series of connected questions:
  1. What was the purpose of the Old Testament sacrifice of animals? Was it to cover the temporal punishment or eternal punishment of sins?
  2. If it was to cover the temporal punishment of sins, why do we not still do it, since we still experience temporal punishment?
  3. If it was to cover the eternal punishment, why did God demand it at all, seeing as how it would be totally ineffective?
    I am leading a discussion of Sin and Grace next week, and I would like to trace the history of Sin and Grace, from the Garden and the Fall to the Flood to the Law to the Temple to the Cross to the Mass.
    Any thoughts or analogies or anything would be appreciated.
Read Leviticus it explains it all. God gave them a list of animal sacrifices in order to atone for their sins and the “perfect animal sacrifice was an unblemished lamb”.

That all stopped when God sent his Son to die for us and that’s why we call Jesus the Lamb of God.
 
Isn’t the first reference to sacrifice the account of Cain and Abel?

Genesis, I believe, never says God commanded animal sacrifice; it was a spontaneous human act that seems to express the (imperfect) intuition that we are dependent on the Creator, and finite, and ultimately unable to overcome our guilt except by annihilating flesh.

Previous religious cults performed human sacrifices; but these accomplished nothing. Still in animal sacrifice, there remained an intuition that by some kind of sacrificial death, one could separate the Self from ones heavy experience of guilt.

Psalm 50 shows Yahweh saying He wants no temple animal sacrifices, but a contrite heart. This is radical and new.

Salvation history brought the ultimate sacrifice of Christ on the Cross, which was the only acceptable sacrifice to God because it was the gift of Himself in total obedience. This is why it is so important that Christ gathers us into Himself so that we share in His suffering and his mission. This is the solution that animal sacrifice was grasping for in the dark. By dying to Self, and coming alive in the new life of Christ, we are given as a gift what we tried to TAKE by means of ineffective animal sacrifice.

This is how I think about the issue, anyway.
 
40.png
bengeorge:
  1. If it was to cover the temporal punishment of sins, why do we not still do it, since we still experience temporal punishment?
    .
The only thing I know is that people gathered to make a sacrifice, such as clean lamb (its a sin to sacrifice a defected one), in order to make an offering to God in atonement for their sins. After offering it to God, they all shared in eating the sacrifice. Jesus predicted, the Temple will fall and be rebuilt in 3 days. The temple fell and afterwards Jews stopped making sacrifices and never started again. Jesus was the ultimate sacrifice, he already paid the price for all our sins. So now, the Liturgy of the Eucharist is like a time warp where we go back to the Last supper, where we in church are like his disciples and the priest is like Jesus telling us, “This is my Body which will be given up for you.” It is Jesus’ body that is layed on the altar like a Lamb. After his sacrifice through death on the cross in atonement for our sins, we share as a community eating his Body. Jesus has given us the gift of his Body, Blood, Soul and divinity. When we partake of the Eucharist, we receive his divine nature within us. My pastor said sometimes he trembles while holding the Eucharist because he feels he is holding Jesus in his hands.

I am sorry but this is just how and what I remember and cant guarantee its 100 percent accuracy. I also apologize if i wrote what you already know. I hope that helps in some way.
 
I’m sorry, but how do we experience temporal punishment?
 
I’ve heard it explained that the sacrifices were a way of rehabilitating the Israelites for their idolatry in Egypt and the wilderness.

After the Golden Calf incident, Moses instituted the sacrifices. Maybe not instituted, but increased them.

The way it was explained, think about a woman who wants to make her husband quit drinking. After an all night binge, she threatens to leave him, unless he breaks a bottle of whiskey and pout it down the drain. Then she makes him do it every day for the rest of their marriage.

Notworthy
 
The animals that were sacrificed were those that the pagans worshipped (calf, ox, goat, etc.). So each time these animals were sacrificed, it was a reminder that they are not gods, only animals, and there is only One True God.

The Passover was a special feast to commemorate when death “passed over” the Jews who spread the blood of the the lamb of the doorpost. They also had to roast the lamb and eat the lamb as part of the old covenant promise.

In the New Testament, Jesus is the Lamb of God Who takes away the sins of the world. He is the male lamb, unblemished, who sheds His blood to save us from sin and death and give us everlasting life. In the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, we receive this Lamb of God in Holy Communion as the New Covenant.

Jesus’ sacrifice perfects the Old Testament sacrifice, which is no longer needed.
 
Hi all!

I don’t care for the mistranslation “sacrifice” for the Hebrew word korban, which actually is a cognate of a root meaning “to approach” or “to draw near/close to”) Because there is no Temple (and for other reasons as well), the order of offerings (as well as other Torah precepts which are dependent on the Temple & a fully functioning Aaronic priesthood, such as accepting tithes, administering the bitter waters to a suspected adultress, 7th and Jubilee years, etc. etc.) are also temporarily suspended :crying: .

The order of offerings on a regular basis ceased in CE 70, when the Romans destroyed the Second Temple. It was briefly reinstituted during the Bar Kokhba revolt against Rome (in CE 132-135, see us-israel.org/jsource/biography/Kokhba.html ). There are vague hints that it may have been reinstituted for an even shorter period during the brief reign of the Roman Emperor Julian (“the Apostate”) in CE 361-363 (see jewishencyclopedia.com/v…J&search=Julian). It probably was reinstituted for a short time after CE 614, when the Sassanid Persians captured Jerusalem from the Byzantines & turned the city over to us. But this interlude came to an end when the Byzantines retook the city a few years later. Since then, nada. :crying:

Following is an article by Rabbi Shlomo Riskin here in Israel. I saved it from many years ago. It is his column on the weekly Torah portion of Vayikra, which is both what we call Leviticus & the name of the first weekly portion from that book. (His column still appears in Friday’s Jerusalem Post.)
“Sacrifices from the heart”

Much of the third book in the Torah, Leviticus, is devoted to the priestly character of Israel and the world of sacrifices. Although there is a vast difference between an animal sacrifice brought in Jerusalem and a human sacrifice to Moloch, all one has to do is mention animal sacrifices to a liberal Jew and one sees how quickly he winces.

As long as Judaism deals with universal concepts such as freedom, justice and the prophetic dream, then everything is sweet and light and palpable. However, from a public relations perspective, it might be best to leave those sacrifices buried in the closet. After all, there is no Temple today, and a culture of animal sacrifices smacks of primitive cults, a form of Judaism alien to the modern spirit.

It should not come as a surprise, therefore, that when any particular segment of the Jewish people decides to make a change, the first place they use their scalpel is on the Book of Leviticus, and the ancient world of sacrifice portrayed in this week’s Torah reading, Vayikra.

It’s the first thing to go, and anyone can find more modern and sophisticated prayer books with gaps or changes when the service ordinarily recalls the Temple sacrifices brought on festivals, Shabbat musaf and Rosh Hodesh; they make a quick, clean incision with nary a look backwards. There is just too much good material around in Genesis and Exodus to get stuck in the quagmire of Leviticus.

However, sometimes an incision can miss the mark completely, creating a new wound where there wasn’t one to begin with. I’m afraid that in dedicating their lives to the “cultural revolution” in judaism, certain Jews may have overlooked the ethical structurepresented in the text itself, which would be clearer if only one stood back a moment and read carefully.

(cont.)
 
(cont.)

Maimonedes (us-israel.org/jsource/biography/Maimonides.html), in his Guide to the Perplexed, suggests that the entire sacrificial cult was a carry-over from the Egyptian experience; the Jews had to be given a substitute sacrificial ritual which would direct their energies to God. Although Nachmanides (us-israel.org/jsource/biography/Nachmanides.html) in his biblical commentary strongly disagrees with the approach in the Guide, Maimonedes’ approach expresses a crucial educational principle. That is, the individual must be directed in accordance with his inherent predilection and historical context, ennobled and elevated naturally and spontaneously.

Nachmanides himself finds symbolic and mystical meaning underlying sacrificial ritual, imbuing each detail with transcendant and eternal significance. Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch (us-israel.org/jsource/biography/Hirsch.html) and Rabbi David Zeff Hoffman, in their respective biblical commentaries, develop the symbolic themes reflected in each category of sacrifice.

There are four – almost like archetypes. The first is the korban olah, or “the whole burnt offering,” in which everything is completely sent up to God, and neither priest nor penitent gets an opportunity to eat any of it. This expresses the truth that we owe the very fibre of our being to God, and must dedicate our lives entirely to His service. Although he survives the binding, Isaac is nevertheless called a “whole burnt offering,” a figure who personifies total commitment to God.

Morever, this sacrifice is brought when a person, struggling to overcome his “evil inclination,” finally empowers it to the extent that he even rids himself of evil thoughts. In an act of recognition top his new determined state of mind, he offers a complete and total sacrifice, in effect his own being.

It is for this reason that the korban olah is brought during the festivals, each one of which signifies a turning point in the year and in the individual’s life, a contain a message of renewed dedication and devotion.

The second kind of sacrifice is the mincha, the meal offering, something simple, easily accessible, as flour and oil. If the person is so poor that he cannot afford to bring either a bull or a goat, or even a turtle-dove, he need not feel shame because of his meager funds. The Torah calls his offering of meal, oil and frankincense a holy of holies.

With this we see that everybody can serve God on his own level. No matter how unfortunate one is, there is always someone less fortunate who would do anything to be in your position. And an offering of meal given by one individual may be more precious in God’s eyes than the most expensive cattle given by another. “The Compassionate One desires the heart most of all.” Furthermore, since so many of us tend to take the basics – the flour and the oil of life – for granted, as if owed to us, isn’t it important to thank God for these as well?

The third category is the hatat, the sin offering. When a person brings this sacrifice, he places his hands on the head of the animal and recites the confessional. In effect, this offering says that every person is given life and the correct way to live it. One wrong move could be your last move, and although the sin may have been committed by accident or temporary amnesia, it still must be expiated. Sin is serious. A person cannot ignore the ramifications of his actions and must be given a physical means to atone for them.

The fourth category is the exact opposite of a sin offering. A thanksgiving or peace-offering takes place when there is an overflow of feeling because of a special event, like a birth, or a large inheritance, or the accomplishment of a significant milestone. All you really want to say is: Thank God. Most important, these sacrifices are eaten by those who bring them, and by the priests, amid songs of thanksgiving and lessons of Torah, enabling every Jew to partake, as it were, at God’s table as His honored guests.

Sacrifices aren’t simply a tapestry of blood and guts, the fetishes of a primitive cult seeking to drown itself in the mystery of the blood and the ecstasy of the fire. They actually provide a broad overview of overcoming pitfalls, trials and tribulations.

Occasionally, they are even a way of celebrating.”
(cont.)
 
(cont.)

Please let me clarify something. The order of Temple offerings was merely one part of the process whereby a Jew could repent of his/her sins; by itself, isolated, bringing an offering was insufficient. Since the order of offerings is, as I’ve said, temporarily suspended, we must rely, for the time being, on the other steps of the process.

What are the other steps of the process? Hosea 14:2-3 (read in synagogue on the Sabbath between Rosh Hashannah jewfaq.org/holiday2.htm and Yom Kippur jewfaq.org/holiday4.htm) says:
Return, O Israel, unto the Lord your God; for you have stumbled in your iniquity. Take with you words, and return unto the Lord; say unto Him: 'Forgive all iniquity, and accept that which is good; so will we render for bullocks the offering of our lips.
From this & other verses, we learn that the repentant sinner must understand, confess & acknowledge his sin (before God), promise not to do it again & then actually not do it again. This is basically it. A korban that was unaccompanied by a contrite heart, sincere confession, etc. was less than useless. Rabbi Riskin cites Rabbi Avraham Yitzhak Hacohen Kook (us-israel.org/jsource/bi…y/Rav_Kook.html) as having taught that, “The most significant part of the sacrifice was never meant to be the savoury smell of the burning meat, but the trembling sincerity of the human heart.”

There were other kinds of offerings, other than those of a penitent/repentant sinner. See jewfaq.org/qorbanot.htm for a very good read on the whole issue of korbanot.

If you have any more questions, ask away & I’ll do my best.

Howzat?

Be well!

ssv 👋
 
Just wonderful.

Do need to look more into our jewish connections - it brings a lot more depth into The New …how the yoke and the burden have been made ‘easy and light’…

That this is The faith our Lord Himself observed .
.
Was at a Jewish -christian service once and noted how

hauntingly beautiful the music is -hoping to be able to locate some …

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top