Palm Sunday, or is it Palm Monday?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Charlie_Zeaiter
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Charlie_Zeaiter

Guest
We know that the crucifixion took place on a Friday (Jn 19:42). And it was the day before Passover (Jn 19:14).

Jesus arrived at Bethany six (6) days proir to Passover (Jn 12:1), hence Sunday. His triumphant entry into Jerusalem was next day (Jn 12:12), hence Monday.

So, why do we celebrate Palm Sunday, and not Palm Monday?
 
We know that the crucifixion took place on a Friday (Jn 19:42). And it was the day before Passover (Jn 19:14).

Jesus arrived at Bethany six (6) days proir to Passover (Jn 12:1), hence Sunday. His triumphant entry into Jerusalem was next day (Jn 12:12), hence Monday.

So, why do we celebrate Palm Sunday, and not Palm Monday?
Huh?

Saturday (Passover)
  1. Friday
  2. Thursday
  3. Wednesday
  4. Tuesday
  5. Monday
  6. Sunday
What’s the problem?
 
Huh? … What’s the problem?
Jesus arrived at Bethany on Sunday. The next day, Monday, he made His triumphant entry into Jerusalem…

I have been speaking to non-Catholic friends who are adamant that the Catholic Church is a pagan daugter of an ancient Sun Worshipping religion. One of their arguments is that we celebrated Jesus’ triumphant entry into Jerusalem on Palm Sunday… and not Monday.

I’m guessing the Catholic Church has a good reason for celebrating this occasion on a Sunday. I was just wondering when it was formalised.
 
Jesus arrived at Bethany on Sunday. The next day, Monday, he made His triumphant entry into Jerusalem…

I have been speaking to non-Catholic friends who are adamant that the Catholic Church is a pagan daugter of an ancient Sun Worshipping religion. One of their arguments is that we celebrated Jesus’ triumphant entry into Jerusalem on Palm Sunday… and not Monday.

I’m guessing the Catholic Church has a good reason for celebrating this occasion on a Sunday. I was just wondering when it was formalised.
You said in your original post that Jesus arrived 6 days prior to Passover. Passover that year was Sabbath. 6 days prior is Sunday.

What’s the problem?
 
it was probably orignally celebrated on a Monday, but the bishops gave up on making it a holy day of obligation so they moved it to Sunday so more Catholics would celebrate it.

seriously, folks, this is a non-issue, just like the date for Christmas. do you always have your birthday party exactly on your birthdate? don’t we move Federal holidays around like checkers on a board to have more long weekends? the NT is not dateline NBC or a minute by minute account of the events of the Life of Christ, still less is it intended as a literal timeline of the events immediately preceding and surrounding the Passion, Death and Resurrection. Read it as it was intended, a narrative, a synthesis, and in John, an epic poem, written by and for people in another culture and time sense, not as a Time mag cover story written to modern journalistic standards, still less as police evidence compiled by detectives reconstructing a crime.

Bible literalists, who persist in their fundamental error of ignoring the spiritual sense of Scripture in their slavish insistence on such details, deny themselves the fullness of God’s revelation. What a pity. If literal adherence to the actual date and sequence of events was so important the Church would have reconstructed painstakingly the actual dates of the events and Easter would be the same date every year. The importance of the timing of events in the Gospel narratives is making the link with Passover and the new Pasch, not in journalistic details. The Gospel abounds in such details, but they are always the details critical for illuminating the meaning of events, not peripherals.
 
But isn’t the Jewish method of reckoning time starts at sunset?

The Passover did not necessarily happen on Saturday.

Here’s a piece Jimmy Akin wrote about the Passover being on Thursday/Friday:
cin.org/users/james/questions/q060.htm

Perhaps Jesus went to Bethany on Saturday, which would make sense if the Passover is in Thursday evening to Friday evening (or a week-long event, so in a sense the Passover is within a week of festivals).

Sorry is this reply is too unclear.
 
In my NAB, the footnote for John 13:1 says, “Before the feast of passover: this would be Thursday evening, before the day of preparation; in the synoptics, the Last Supper is a Passover meal taking place, in John’s chronology, on Friday evening.”
 
We know that the crucifixion took place on a Friday (Jn 19:42). And it was the day before Passover (Jn 19:14).

Jesus arrived at Bethany six (6) days proir to Passover (Jn 12:1), hence Sunday. His triumphant entry into Jerusalem was next day (Jn 12:12), hence Monday.

So, why do we celebrate Palm Sunday, and not Palm Monday?
Let’s not forget that in the Jewish custom a day started at sundown on the previous day. Part of a day was considered the whole day. He might have arrived in Bethany on Saturday evening and Jerusalem on Sunday morning.
This is the same way to explain the “3 days” in the tomb. Jesus was buried on Friday evening and rose from the dead on Sunday morning. Friday, Saturday, Sunday - 3 days.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top