Papal Power

  • Thread starter Thread starter James_Trevor
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

James_Trevor

Guest
I’ve discovered through a conversation with a Protestant this quote
The Pope is of great authority and power that he can modify, explain, or interpret even divine laws… The Pope can modify divine law, since his power is not of man, but of God, and he acts as vicegerent of God upon earth." -Lucius Ferraris, Prompta Ribliotheca, “Papa,” art. 2, translated
The emphasized is wrong, right? What is the correct quote? If anyone knows…
 
The Pope along with the Magisterium decide if some teaching is declared infallible.The Pope is Christ’s vicar on earth but he doesn’t act alone.The Church is guided by the HS.We believe that the Church wouldn’t allow error on certain matters.(the HS wouldn’t allow error)I think non Catholic christians are wrong if they believe that the Pope alone guides the Church.
 
I’ve discovered through a conversation with a Protestant this quote

The emphasized is wrong, right? What is the correct quote? If anyone knows…
The actual quote is:
Papa tantae est auctoritatis et potestatis, ut possit quoque leges divinas modificare, declarare, vel interpretari . . . .
Which I would translate approximately as
The Pope is of such great authority and power, that he can also modify, declare, or interpret divine laws.
The remaining portion (“since his power is not from man but from God,” etc.) seems to be a quotation from Petrus de Ancharano which Ferraris cites.

You can read the original here. It does indeed seem to be full of more or less the statements that you see attributed to it, though with some caveats. I see references which claim that Ferraris says that whatever the Pope may do “seems to proceed from the mouth of God,” whereas he actually uses the subjunctive, which I would render more or less, “let it be seen as proceeding from the mouth of God” – in other words, calling for obedience and unquestioned respect, but not actually claiming that he speaks with the literal voice of God.

Yes, Ferraris is a bit over the top, not least when he calls the Pope “quasi Deus in terra” (“like God on earth”). Even so, it seems that he is speaking in terms of the Pope’s authority – that, on earth, he reigns supreme and unquestionable – and not saying, as some Protestant sources take it, that the Pope himself is a living God like one of the deified Caesars.
 
I’m no expert, but a quick google search revealed that this is considered a forgery in the canonical sense of the word. In other words, totally NOT TRUE. There is plenty of garbage out there to support positions that an anti-Catholic can glom onto and espouse to show that the one true Church is in error. My advice to the OP is to check these things out online as I did and be able to defend our faith to a person who attacks with falsehoods such as this one. The best way to defend the faith is to study and know the faith. A protestant “friend” who attacks your faith is no friend.
 
Thank you all very much, I am much less confused. 😃

The claim was that the RCC thinks that Papal/Ecclesiastical laws are divine in nature, and the quote was used to back that claim up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top