Pius IX and Italy

  • Thread starter Thread starter HabemusFrancis
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why couldn’t you have said the First Crusade? I mean, after all it was “just”, wasn’t it? I wonder how just it felt to the Jews, Muslims and ,yes, even Christians who were butchered to death? At least the streets were good and clean after all the blood was washed away.
I go for the overly dramatic. I can live with a little saracen smite-down as a cost of western adventuring, par for the course. but sacking – and I mean a sack on an epic scale – an ancient center of your own faith, that’s way over the top. really can’t justify that.
 
All this is just your particular/peculiar ‘spin’ and, yes, Italy in 1870 wasn’t run by slave-owners (we can all play the ‘spin’ game).
You seem unable to make a comment that isn’t a complete non sequitur or a red herring.
 
I know exactly why the First Crusade was fought and it wasn’t for the glory of Christ or the Church.
I’m glad to debate the reasons for the First Crusade with you, but perhaps another thread would be apropos. This thread is focused on the unjust capture of Rome in 1870.
 
Unfortunately, that may well have an awful lot more to do with you than it has to do with me. 🙂
Your inability to make an *argumentum ad rem *has more to do with me than you? Really? Need I point out that is yet another Non Sequitur?

NEW POLICY… As fun as this is, I am not responding to any other of your comments on this thread that are non sequiturs. It was nice chatting though. God bless.
 
sometimes God has to chastise His servants to make them upright. its a shame that He had to force the Vatican out of european politics by stripping it of the papal states when voluntarily surrendering them would have been more righteous; its even more shameful that the Vatican had to acknowledge the *fait accompli *by treaty with that filthy thug mussolini. but its all worked out for the best.
 
sometimes God has to chastise His servants to make them upright. its a shame that He had to force the Vatican out of european politics by stripping it of the papal states when voluntarily surrendering them would have been more righteous; its even more shameful that the Vatican had to acknowledge the *fait accompli *by treaty with that filthy thug mussolini. but its all worked out for the best.
You do realize Mussolini wouldn’t have had an Italy to control if the Risorgimento hadn’t happened. Had the Papal States not been seized and had Italy remained a patchwork of smaller, culturally united but politically distinct States, there would have been no Fascist Italy, no Berlin-Rome Axis, no deportation of Italian Jews, etc, etc. It seems odd to bemoan Mussolini’s rule (an Italian nationalist) while praising Vittorio Emmanule II (another Italian nationalist) as the Righteous Fist of God.
 
You do realize Mussolini wouldn’t have had an Italy to control if the Risorgimento hadn’t happened. Had the Papal States not been seized and had Italy remained a patchwork of smaller, culturally united but politically distinct States, there would have been no Fascist Italy, no Berlin-Rome Axis, no deportation of Italian Jews, etc, etc. It seems odd to bemoan Mussolini’s rule (an Italian nationalist) while praising Vittorio Emmanule II (another Italian nationalist) as the Righteous Fist of God.
agree. the vatican should have gotten out of the political business long ago.
 
agree. the vatican should have gotten out of the political business long ago.
Because Early Modern and Medieval Europe was soooo respectful of Church authority there was never any need to keep potentates from interfering with the Church, right?
 
Getting in kind of late on this but anyways…
Because Early Modern and Medieval Europe was soooo respectful of Church authority there was never any need to keep potentates from interfering with the Church, right?
So therefore this gave the Popes the authority to use trickery (myth of the donation of Constantine to give legitimacy to the claim to Rome), excommunication when the Church didn’t win, and violence to maintain their territory and occasionally expand it?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top