Please help with answers!

  • Thread starter Thread starter notsure13
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
thank you so much for this, you help me understand things so easy. can i ask where your faith came from? have you always been religious since childhood? is your heath stable?
I grew up in a family that was at first nominally Protestant, I was baptised and went to Sunday School for a few years, but when I was about 7, we stopped going. My family are all now atheist or agnostic. I had this strange longing to be Catholic throughout my teens, even though I didn’t know anything about the Catholic faith. When I went to university, I plucked up the courage to ask the student in the room next to mine in the hall of residence, to take me to Mass. I formally converted two years later.

As for my health, it is stable but I suffer from a few problems, mostly to do with bloodflow. It isn’t fatal though, so I’ll be around for a while, providing I don’t wander in front of a bus or something. There are people suffering far worse than me, so I can’t complain. Given a choice between this and living in the Third World without clean water or medical care, I’d choose this every time.
 
Thank you for your compliments!

Answer me this, would our salvation history be significantly different if we had blue skin, eight legs, six arms, twelve finger and communicated via little colored lights on the tops of our heads? The Bible is not a literal description of the formation of the universe and everything in it. The part of a human being that is made in the image of God is the soul. Where the physical body came from is not important.
Hi starsmurf,

No, I do not believe our salvation history would have been different if we did not look as we physically do. I am in total agreement with you that our being made in the image of God has nothing to do with the physical; rather it has to do with our immortal soul, free will and intelligence. God calls us to be holy as He is holy.
Your question on amoebas show that you don’t understand how multi-cellular life formed. It wasn’t lots of amoebas “joining together”, it a single amoeba that became two cells, not one. The amoeba we see today are very different from the ones that existed then, they have to be to survive, as the enviroment is so different…
I must apologize – I was not very eloquent when trying to put forth my thoughts. I am aware that amoebas did not join together. An individual lifeform cannot fuse with another. When I think I think in pictures envisioning what I am relaying, (probably the artist in me :)) and I see a cluster of “cells” all “joined together”. That is my reference to “joining together”. Mitosis would have occured creating “daughter” cells* identical *to its “parent” cell. This is how the amoeba “reproduces”. So these reproduced cells haven’t changed into a brain, eyes, sex organs, spine, etc…they continue to remain relatively unchanged even to this day, just as the horseshoe crab remains relatively unchanged. Note: I use the word relatively.
As the above makes the rest of your argument for intelligent design invalid, I won’t go on. Evolution didn’t think, it does not have a design plan. Evolution works because certain characteristics allow that creature to survive more often than another one does. Therefore the creatures with that characteristic are more likely to survive long enough to breed than those with the other characteristic. Eventually that means that there will only be those with that characteristic. There is plenty of evidence of this happening. We don’t see amoebas evolving into something else because it happens very slowly. .
Yes, and they still remain relatively the same. In order for mammals to have appeared on the earth, there would have had to have been a male and female created simultaneously in order to propagate, and not one scientist or biologist can explain how any one-celled organism had the “intelligence” to know to do this. Not only that, but all life forms would have had to have been created at the same time in order to sustain life on earth. You cannot rule out an intelligent designer (I say “God” - our Creator), who was in control of this whole process. Our bodies, brains, the way we function, (all complicated life forms), are too complex and intricate to have come about by “chance”. Impossible.
There is lots of proof that the fossils we have found are indeed related to us. I’m an astrophysicist, so it isn’t my area, but I do know that the evidence is there.

Intelligent design is based on a “God of gaps”, a very dangerous premise, as when that gap disappears, what happens to God?

I’m sorry but evolution **has **passed all the tests of the theory. It **has **been proved.
The fossils that have been found to have common human DNA are those that are “recent” per se, in the history of the world. Cro-Magnon is from about 120,000 to years ago, and Neandertals interbred with Cro-Magnon and “modern” humans, with modern humans carrying a percentage of Neandertal DNA to this day. Evolution has not passed all tests of theory. It is not de facto. Neandertals shared this timeline with the Cro-Magnons. Scientists today do not see any sufficient differences between modern humans and the Cro-Magnons. We share common DNA with “humans”, but we do not share human DNA with other life forms/genuses. What we do share are the chemical makeup of what this earth hold of which all life shares a part of. In that way we are “related”, for from dust we were created and to dust we shall return. (“Dust” of the earth per se).
 
I grew up in a family that was at first nominally Protestant, I was baptised and went to Sunday School for a few years, but when I was about 7, we stopped going. My family are all now atheist or agnostic. I had this strange longing to be Catholic throughout my teens, even though I didn’t know anything about the Catholic faith. When I went to university, I plucked up the courage to ask the student in the room next to mine in the hall of residence, to take me to Mass. I formally converted two years later.

As for my health, it is stable but I suffer from a few problems, mostly to do with bloodflow. It isn’t fatal though, so I’ll be around for a while, providing I don’t wander in front of a bus or something. There are people suffering far worse than me, so I can’t complain. Given a choice between this and living in the Third World without clean water or medical care, I’d choose this every time.
I am very glad to hear of your conversion and faith in God. May God continue to keep you close to Him and surround you with His Holy Angels to guard over you. 🙂
 
im sorry starsmurf please let me ask one more thing that i have been thinking about… jesus is the only man without sin… isnt it blasphemy when he says, “father why do you forsake me?”
Hi notsure13,

starsmurf wrote in response to your question:

Please feel free to ask questions, it is my pleasure to answer them.

The “My God, My God, why have you forsaken me?”, that Jesus said on the cross isn’t blasphemy, it is actually the first line of Psalm 21(22). That must have shocked those listening because of the correlation between the Psalm and what was happing in front of them. You can read it here: catholic.org/bible/book.p…ble_chapter=22

I would like to add the following:

In the era that Jesus and His Apostles lived, the Bible was not separated into chapters and verses and “books”. Not all could read either, and so the Psalms were memorized, being very important.

When Jesus was dying, He recited the first few opening words of this Psalm, which immediately brought to mind the rest of this integral Psalm to those Apostles and disciples nearby. It is just like when someone would say the first few words of a well-known nursery rhyme, it would immediately bring to mind the rest of the nursery rhyme. For example, most people know “Twinkle twinkle little star…” nursery rhyme, and just by those few opening words, those people know the rest of this rhyme.

So too with this Psalm that Jesus recited. It is about an innocent man, and predicts all that Jesus endured. However, the ending is triumphant, and it is this triumph that Jesus was reminding His loved ones with His dying breath.

blessings,
CEM
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top