S
styrgwillidar
Guest
Rocklobster,
Greetings. An author’s beliefs, intentions and even goals in writing a novel can be irrelevant. This is because what people get out of a work is largely dependent on what they bring into it. If your friend has a strong christian faith, they will undoubtedly find a lot in the novels which reaffirm that faith. If they’re not interested now in dabbling in the occult HP certainly isn’t going to get them interested.
Why do you or your friend need articles from other folks in order to determine whether it’s ok to read? If you have read the novels you should be able to explain to your friend without having to appeal to outside authority. Wouldn’t they be more inclined to trust you and your judgement than an unknown stranger?
I don’t know how old you/they are. Some younger children could certainly use some guidance to understand all of the symbology and themes, that is to consider HP from a christian perspective or lens. Do you not trust yourself to see them? Do you not trust your own judgement in this matter?
It could actually be a lot of fun for you and your friend to discuss them together. Things like Nearly Headless Nick’s conversation with Harry after Sirus death. Is Rowlings using Nick to represent atheists? His comment that he has chosen a ‘pale imitation of life’ by his refusal to ‘go on’ seemed similar to an atheist’s rejection of spirituality and limiting themselves to this world. Atheist’s limit themselves to a ‘pale imitation of life’ by not recognizing that life is much more than our current existence.
One of the most fascinating lines to me, which made me reconsider Rowlings intentions in her portrayal of spirits HP sees in times of stress; was Dumbledore’s comment (when HP/Voldemeort are both knocked out when HP tries to sacrfice his life) along the lines of - Of course this is occurring in your head- what makes you think that doesn’t mean it’s real?
Have spirits actually been coming to HP, or is he simply being affected by his memories of them or the good works they accomplished in critical times? Nick did say that the dead ‘go on’ and can’t be contacted by the living.
Do you see what I mean? While Rowlings may never have intended that the reader read these things into the novel, it is something to consider. You and your friend can certainly have those kinds of discussions if they read the books.
Greetings. An author’s beliefs, intentions and even goals in writing a novel can be irrelevant. This is because what people get out of a work is largely dependent on what they bring into it. If your friend has a strong christian faith, they will undoubtedly find a lot in the novels which reaffirm that faith. If they’re not interested now in dabbling in the occult HP certainly isn’t going to get them interested.
Why do you or your friend need articles from other folks in order to determine whether it’s ok to read? If you have read the novels you should be able to explain to your friend without having to appeal to outside authority. Wouldn’t they be more inclined to trust you and your judgement than an unknown stranger?
I don’t know how old you/they are. Some younger children could certainly use some guidance to understand all of the symbology and themes, that is to consider HP from a christian perspective or lens. Do you not trust yourself to see them? Do you not trust your own judgement in this matter?
It could actually be a lot of fun for you and your friend to discuss them together. Things like Nearly Headless Nick’s conversation with Harry after Sirus death. Is Rowlings using Nick to represent atheists? His comment that he has chosen a ‘pale imitation of life’ by his refusal to ‘go on’ seemed similar to an atheist’s rejection of spirituality and limiting themselves to this world. Atheist’s limit themselves to a ‘pale imitation of life’ by not recognizing that life is much more than our current existence.
One of the most fascinating lines to me, which made me reconsider Rowlings intentions in her portrayal of spirits HP sees in times of stress; was Dumbledore’s comment (when HP/Voldemeort are both knocked out when HP tries to sacrfice his life) along the lines of - Of course this is occurring in your head- what makes you think that doesn’t mean it’s real?
Have spirits actually been coming to HP, or is he simply being affected by his memories of them or the good works they accomplished in critical times? Nick did say that the dead ‘go on’ and can’t be contacted by the living.
Do you see what I mean? While Rowlings may never have intended that the reader read these things into the novel, it is something to consider. You and your friend can certainly have those kinds of discussions if they read the books.