Positive views on Harry Potter

  • Thread starter Thread starter rocklobster
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Rocklobster,
Greetings. An author’s beliefs, intentions and even goals in writing a novel can be irrelevant. This is because what people get out of a work is largely dependent on what they bring into it. If your friend has a strong christian faith, they will undoubtedly find a lot in the novels which reaffirm that faith. If they’re not interested now in dabbling in the occult HP certainly isn’t going to get them interested.

Why do you or your friend need articles from other folks in order to determine whether it’s ok to read? If you have read the novels you should be able to explain to your friend without having to appeal to outside authority. Wouldn’t they be more inclined to trust you and your judgement than an unknown stranger?

I don’t know how old you/they are. Some younger children could certainly use some guidance to understand all of the symbology and themes, that is to consider HP from a christian perspective or lens. Do you not trust yourself to see them? Do you not trust your own judgement in this matter?

It could actually be a lot of fun for you and your friend to discuss them together. Things like Nearly Headless Nick’s conversation with Harry after Sirus death. Is Rowlings using Nick to represent atheists? His comment that he has chosen a ‘pale imitation of life’ by his refusal to ‘go on’ seemed similar to an atheist’s rejection of spirituality and limiting themselves to this world. Atheist’s limit themselves to a ‘pale imitation of life’ by not recognizing that life is much more than our current existence.

One of the most fascinating lines to me, which made me reconsider Rowlings intentions in her portrayal of spirits HP sees in times of stress; was Dumbledore’s comment (when HP/Voldemeort are both knocked out when HP tries to sacrfice his life) along the lines of - Of course this is occurring in your head- what makes you think that doesn’t mean it’s real?

Have spirits actually been coming to HP, or is he simply being affected by his memories of them or the good works they accomplished in critical times? Nick did say that the dead ‘go on’ and can’t be contacted by the living.

Do you see what I mean? While Rowlings may never have intended that the reader read these things into the novel, it is something to consider. You and your friend can certainly have those kinds of discussions if they read the books.
 
Rocklobster,

It could actually be a lot of fun for you and your friend to discuss them together. Things like Nearly Headless Nick’s conversation with Harry after Sirus death. Is Rowlings using Nick to represent atheists? His comment that he has chosen a ‘pale imitation of life’ by his refusal to ‘go on’ seemed similar to an atheist’s rejection of spirituality and limiting themselves to this world. Atheist’s limit themselves to a ‘pale imitation of life’ by not recognizing that life is much more than our current existence.
I’m not so sure. When nick says ‘go on’ I took it to mean go to heaven/hell. I think the ghosts
seem to be in a purgatory-like-state because of their attachment to this world.

An attachment a person like Sirius didn’t have.​

As for the Harry Potter is evil stuff; oh brother :rolleyes:
It’s a great book. When I read it, I never saw any evil in it. I don’t think most would have if
the “evil” accusation hadn’t spread through the media like crazy.
It is just a story. The magic is no different from X-men comics or anything else.
 
I’m not so sure. When nick says ‘go on’ I took it to mean go to heaven/hell. I think the ghosts
seem to be in a purgatory-like-state because of their attachment to this world.

An attachment a person like Sirius didn’t have.​

As for the Harry Potter is evil stuff; oh brother :rolleyes:
It’s a great book. When I read it, I never saw any evil in it. I don’t think most would have if
the “evil” accusation hadn’t spread through the media like crazy.
It is just a story. The magic is no different from X-men comics or anything else.
Exactly why it’s interesting to discuss- the christian themes kind of jump out. I tend to think atheist because of their rejection of the next life - i.e. choosing not to go on. Nick says the ghosts can choose to go on or stay, choosing a pale imitation of life. I think your interpretation is just as valid- a kind of purgatory based on our choices making us not ready to go on. Which is why for the OP the idea of reading and then discussing together will bring out how some things can be viewed as reinforcing christian beliefs.
 
There was a resurgence in interest in UFOs and paranormal stuff when I was a kid- telekinesis, ESP, supposed USSR experimentation in mind control, out of body experience, etc. It was at the time the book and movie ‘Chariots of the Gods’ came out- (BTW great counter book came out called ‘Crash go the Chariots’ disproving everything in Chariots of the Gods). Basically trying to claim God, angels, and supernatural events were actually attributable to natural phenomena and aliens. I think that kind of thing is more dangerous than the concept of the occult. Deluding oneself into thinking they’re dealing with natural phenomena leaving themselves open to being influenced by the devil without realizing it. I sometimes wonder if the quantum physics folks who talk about alternate universes and remote effects due to uncertainty are going along the same lines.
 
An unjustified bad reputation for Harry Potter?? Maybe because our faith tells us this…

Catechism of the Catholic Church

2116
All forms of divination are to be rejected: recourse to Satan or demons, conjuring up the dead or other practices falsely supposed to “unveil” the future.48 Consulting horoscopes, astrology, palm reading, interpretation of omens and lots, the phenomena of clairvoyance, and recourse to mediums all conceal a desire for power over time, history, and, in the last analysis, other human beings, as well as a wish to conciliate hidden powers. They contradict the honor, respect, and loving fear that we owe to God alone.

2117
All practices of magic or sorcery, by which one attempts to tame occult powers, so as to place them at one’s service and have a supernatural power over others—even if this were for the sake of restoring their health—are gravely contrary to the virtue of religion. These practices are even more to be condemned when accompanied by the intention of harming someone, or when they have recourse to the intervention of demons. Wearing charms is also reprehensible. Spiritism often implies divination or magical practices; the Church for her part warns the faithful against it. Recourse to so-called traditional cures does not justify either the invocation of evil powers or the exploitation of another’s credulity.

Deuteronomy 18:9-15

9 When you enter the land the LORD your God is giving you, do not learn to imitate the detestable ways of the nations there. 10 Let no one be found among you who sacrifices their son or daughter in the fire, who practices divination or sorcery, interprets omens, engages in witchcraft, 11 or casts spells, or who is a medium or spiritist or who consults the dead. 12 Anyone who does these things is detestable to the LORD; because of these same detestable practices the LORD your God will drive out those nations before you. 13 You must be blameless before the LORD your God.

14 The nations you will dispossess listen to those who practice sorcery or divination. But as for you, the LORD your God has not permitted you to do so. 15 The LORD your God will raise up for you a prophet like me from among you, from your fellow Israelites. You must listen to him.
 
Oh, please, let’s not start beating that poor dead horse again, mp7777777 (or whoever you might actually be–pardon my skepticism regarding the brand new membership and choice of first post). There is a distinction which seems to be universally ignored by those who want to give the HP novels that ‘bad reputation’ (which is undeserved) between fact and fiction. There is, in fact, nothing contained within the novels which has anything to do with those practices mentioned and condemned in the passages quoted from the catechism and Scripture.

Fictional witchcraft (which has absolutely nothing to do with the real-world variety) is neutral. In these novels, the best way to describe it is that witchcraft is an alternate science which can only be used by those who are born to it. If one is a Muggle, he lights his house by paying his bill to the utility company and flipping light switches as needed; if one is a wizard, he lights his house by uttering “lumos”. No one in the real world lights his house by waving a wand and saying “lumos”. No occult powers are used or tamed in the utterance of “lumos” turning on a light; no evil powers are invoked.

In other words, the witchcraft in the Harry Potter novels is nothing more than a multi-purpose tool (which one must learn to handle properly, just as all tools require some learning before use to avoid injury to persons and/or damage to property) not the point of the stories; the actual point of the novels could be summarized by Dumbledore’s speech to the school at the feast at the end of Harry’s fourth year: “It is my belief, however, that the truth is generally preferable to lies, …we are only as strong as we are united, as weak as we are divided. Lord Voldemort’s gift for spreading discord and enmity is very great. We can fight it only by showing an equally strong bond of friendship and trust. Differences of habit and language are nothing at all if our aims are identical and our hearts are open… Remember, if the time should come when you have to make a choice between what is right and what is easy, remember what happened to a boy who was good, and kind, and brave, because he strayed across the path of Lord Voldemort.” (GOF, p. 722-724)

The truth of what is taught by the novels (insofar as fiction teaches) is an undeniably Christian virtue. In the end, love and a willingness to sacrifice oneself for the good of another are virtues which evil can never comprehend and why, in the end, good will triumph over evil–because love and the willingness to sacrifice oneself for another are the “deeper magic” (to quote Lewis) which defeated Voldemort, the White Witch of Narnia, Emperor Palpatine, Emperor Jagang, and any other number of fictional villains whose defeat seemed impossible until it happened.
 
An unjustified bad reputation for Harry Potter?? Maybe because our faith tells us this…

Catechism of the Catholic Church

2116
All forms of divination are to be rejected: recourse to Satan or demons, conjuring up the dead or other practices falsely supposed to “unveil” the future.48 Consulting horoscopes, astrology, palm reading, interpretation of omens and lots, the phenomena of clairvoyance, and recourse to mediums all conceal a desire for power over time, history, and, in the last analysis, other human beings, as well as a wish to conciliate hidden powers. They contradict the honor, respect, and loving fear that we owe to God alone.

2117
All practices of magic or sorcery, by which one attempts to tame occult powers, so as to place them at one’s service and have a supernatural power over others—even if this were for the sake of restoring their health—are gravely contrary to the virtue of religion. These practices are even more to be condemned when accompanied by the intention of harming someone, or when they have recourse to the intervention of demons. Wearing charms is also reprehensible. Spiritism often implies divination or magical practices; the Church for her part warns the faithful against it. Recourse to so-called traditional cures does not justify either the invocation of evil powers or the exploitation of another’s credulity.
Interesting then, since HP lends itself to reinforcing both of these.
  1. Divination is the branch of magic which is portrayed as useless, with an incompetent teacher and the students never actually performing divination. In addition, the most respected and accomplished wizard, also the headmaster of the school, indicates at one point he was going to eliminate the subject completely. It is the bad guy’s misplaced faith in divination which is ultimately his undoing, if he had ignored a prophesy he would have won. Rowlings displays some of the typical tricks of the fortune teller/psychic fraudsters- changing their voice and appearance in a ‘trance’, vagueness allowing the prophesy to be applied to multiple people, no timeline, no actual indication of outcome etc.
  2. The magic is portrayed as an innate ability, not something obtained by " … tame occult powers." There are no demons, no rites which seek to gain power by association or deals with supernatural beings.
In addition, you can read the lengthy posts by many pointing out how Rowlings reinforces Christian teaching on dangers of attachment to things of this world, the ruining of one’s soul through evil and consequences for eternity, nobility of self-sacrficie and love for one’s friends, the redemption through true remorse and repentance and on and on…
 
An unjustified bad reputation for Harry Potter?? Maybe because our faith tells us this…
That real-world magic is evil? Of course it does. Now tell me, how does this apply to the erratically different phenomenon of fictional magic?
 
Fictional witchcraft (which has absolutely nothing to do with the real-world variety) is neutral.
Yes, and the oiuja board is also “fictional”. You go ahead and play it if you’d like since it’s also “fictional” but I’ll stick to trusting those in the Church who have a better understanding of what reality is.

lifesitenews.com/news/archive/ldn/2006/mar/06030104

goddiscussion.com/35996/demon-watch-catholic-exorcist-claims-that-harry-potter-desensitizes-children-to-the-dark-orld/
 
Yes, and the oiuja board is also “fictional”. You go ahead and play it if you’d like since it’s also “fictional” but I’ll stick to trusting those in the Church who have a better understanding of what reality is.
How is the ouija board fictional? It’s a real object with a real practice. Do you even know what “fictional” means?

Allow me to educate you. Here are four definitions from my dictionary.
fiction [noun]
  1. the class of literature comprising works of imaginative narration
  2. works of this class, as novels or short stories
  3. something feigned, invented, or imagined; a made-up story
  4. the act of feigning, inventing, or imagining.
The ouija board falls under none of these definitions.
It does however, fall under superstitious poppycock. Coincidentally, the same goes for the logic of people such as yourself who can’t tell fantasy from reality.
Am I the only one who finds it very telling that Euteneuers is the only priest that the anti-Potter’s source and act like he speaks for the whole Church?

And Amorth? Are you aware that he now also claims the devil is in the Vatican? As much as I respect his experience, I find that it’s also done something to the poor old man’s head.
 
Getting a late start I just finished the HP series last week. Someone in my office saw me with it and asked about it. I asked her if she’d read them and she replied “no, I don’t believe in witchcraft”… she had clearly passed judgment on the series without even knowing anything about them other than the fact that they contain words like magic, witch, wizard and spell.

It’s this kind of fantatical thought process that kept me away from Christianity in general for the longest time. I’m right there with LW in terms of my hobbies of choice… I play a card game called Magic: The Gathering from time to time. Play video games that put me in the roles of a “Black Mage” or “Warlock”. I read Spawn comics. Out of the people who I’ve chosen to keep as friends over the years (all of them Christian) none of them consider these things evil… geeky… but not evil.

It’s all make believe. Fiction. Not real. Satan is real… Harry Potter is hardly the devil. Older generations tend to want to blame popular media for the way their children missbehave rather than taking personal responsibility for it. When I was a kid I played a game called Mortal Kombat… ripping off heads and pulling out hearts… did it lead me to violence? No… because my mother did very well in explaining not only the difference between right and wrong but the difference between fantasy and reality.
 
How is the ouija board fictional? It’s a real object with a real practice. Do you even know what “fictional” means?

Allow me to educate you. Here are four definitions from my dictionary.
fiction [noun]
  1. the class of literature comprising works of imaginative narration
  2. works of this class, as novels or short stories
  3. something feigned, invented, or imagined; a made-up story
  4. the act of feigning, inventing, or imagining.
Thanks for getting that for me. There is a clear and distinct difference between fiction and non-fiction in libraries and bookstores. I’d read somewhere (can’t locate the quote though) that JK Rowling thought the appropriate age to read each of the novels is when the reader is minimum Harry’s age in the novel minus two years (so a 9 year old for the first volume, but 15 as a minimum ‘intended age of reader’ for the last volume). So even the youngest readers starting out are (or should be) well beyond the stage of not being able to distinguish fiction/non-fiction or fantasy/fact (I mean, seriously–my youngest children are the twins who are 9 and doing 4th grade work. For four years now in English, we have had lessons in library skills that include assigning a work to one of three categories: fiction, non-fiction, and reference.)
Am I the only one who finds it very telling that Euteneuers is the only priest that the anti-Potter’s source and act like he speaks for the whole Church?

And Amorth? Are you aware that he now also claims the devil is in the Vatican? As much as I respect his experience, I find that it’s also done something to the poor old man’s head.
No, not the only one. It seems that anti-Potter sources boil down to three: Mr. O’Brien, Fr. Euteneuer, and Fr. Amorth. Mr. O’Brien’s work has been dealt with (although some will refuse to acknowledge that his opinion has been disregarded due to the factual errors and logical fallacies that fill his work as opposed to ‘just not liking what he has to say’). Frs. Euteneuer and Amorth–again, the appeal to authority. I’ll repeat myself–here are the standards by which one can assess whether the authority:
  1. The person has sufficient expertise in the subject matter in question.
    Fr. Euteneuer and Fr. Amorth do not necessarily possess sufficient expertise in the analysis of children’s/young adult’s literature. FAIL
  2. The claim being made by the person is within her area(s) of expertise.
    Fr. Euteneuer and Fr. Amorth are talking about fiction when they talk about the Harry Potter novels, they are not talking about the area of their expertise. When a person makes a claim about a subject outside of his area of expertise, then the person is not an expert in that context. Hence, the claim in question is not backed by the required degree of expertise and is not reliable. FAIL
  3. There is an adequate degree of agreement among the other experts in the subject in question.
    FAIL (Do I really need to say more?)
  4. The person in question is not significantly biased. UNKNOWN
  5. The area of expertise is a legitimate area or discipline. PASS
  6. The authority in question must be identified. PASS
    Because of the failures in points 1-3, it is clear that the opinion of Frs. Euteneuer and Amorth on these particular works of fiction fail as a legitimate authority upon which to base an argument.
Not a chap (nor LW), and old school (1st & 2nd ed. AD&D, none of that 3e and beyond stuff), so the basic vorpal sword is a +3, but I could also offer you a +5 Holy Avenger (there is nothing above +5 in the old school world), but you have to be a paladin for it to work well (how about a +4 Defender?).

(aside to mp7777777 … fiction)
 
Because of the failures in points 1-3, it is clear that the opinion of Frs. Euteneuer and Amorth on these particular works of fiction fail as a legitimate authority upon which to base an argument.
I’ve said it a few times myself. One thing I could never stand from the ‘spiritual warriors’ and their champions is how they overstep their boundaries. In short, they think being an expert exorcist makes you an expert on everything. :rolleyes:
Not a chap (nor LW), and old school (1st & 2nd ed. AD&D, none of that 3e and beyond stuff), so the basic vorpal sword is a +3, but I could also offer you a +5 Holy Avenger (there is nothing above +5 in the old school world), but you have to be a paladin for it to work well (how about a +4 Defender?).
Okay gimme a sec… rummages through chest of Fantasy Weapons

Lesee…
pulls out giant sword Nope.
pulls out triple-barreled revolver Nope.
pulls out insanely long katana HECK NO!!! DX
pulls out large key Oh yeah, always wanted one 'o these… 😃
pulls out [/-]](http://i778.photobucket.com/albums/...tio Cards - Coloured Manga Version/Nodoka.jpg) WHOA!! AH! hides it Um… hehe, how’d that get in there? ^^;

Ah wait! Here it is! hands over vorpal sword

Now… turns to other fantasy weapons now lying down What am I gonna do with the rest of this…? :cool:

P.S.

You know, with all these fringe folks inciting moral panic over mere fiction, I’m surprised they haven’t crossed themselves and started sprinkling holy water on their computer screens whenever we fantasy junkies have conversations like this. XD
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top