Possible Family Rift

  • Thread starter Thread starter ralvarado08
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

ralvarado08

Guest
Forgive me if this is long. We always have Thanksgiving at my Mom and Dad’s. This year, my 19 yr. old step daughter asked my Mom if she could bring her boyfriend. Granted the step daughter has not been the best Catholic, but my wife and I are trying to guide her back to the Catholic Church. She also has a 10 month old, who we adore. Dad said no and my Mom, following my Dad’s wishes, cited room being an issue. We told them we would host Thanksgiving at our house then and invited them and my sister;s family to our house for the holiday. My sister accepted and asked if my niece, who is gay, could bring her girlfriend and another friend of hers from work. While my sister knows that I don’t approve of my niece’s gay lifestlye, I told her of course they were all welcome as the more people giving thanks to God, the better. My sister now tells me that my Mom and Dad are not coming to my house (though they have not told me anything), and so they have decided to go to my Mom and Dad’s for Thanksgiving and that my Mom and Dad are allowing my niece to bring her girlfriend and friend from work. To say the least, my wife and I are really hurt by all this. We are sad that the family will not be all together as we were closely knit before this. I don’t want this to pemanently be a rift in our family, but I don’t know how to take my father’s decision to allow my niece to bring her girlfriend, but not my stepdaughter. Help.::confused:
 
So, ask your dad. He’s the one making these decisions that impact others. I’d ask him why he is making such hurtful decisions.

You aren’t going to find answers here to why your dad did what he did or what you should do.

I am sorry that you are hurt by this. I can only suggest that you try not to let “we’ve always done it this way…” to dominate your life. You can have Thanksgiving with your own immediate family and create your own traditions.

You can visit your parents on a different day, invite them over, etc. If they choose not to accept invitations you give, then that is their loss.

You need to set up your own boundaries and then act accordingly. You can’t control other people and you don’t have to let them control you either.
 
You did not cause the rift. They caused the rift by doing things contrary to God and then expecting you to be okay with it. As hurtful and depressing as things may seem, remember where the blame rests. If they should wise up, it will be your duty to swallow your pride, forgive them, and help them where possible. Until that time, there’s not a lot you can do, and you certainly shouldn’t stress over the poor moral decisions of family members who you cannot and should not control.
 
My sister accepted and asked if my niece, who is gay, could bring her girlfriend and another friend of hers from work. While my sister knows that I don’t approve of my niece’s gay lifestlye, I told her of course they were all welcome as the more people giving thanks to God, the better. My sister now tells me that my Mom and Dad are not coming to my house (though they have not told me anything), and so they have decided to go to my Mom and Dad’s for Thanksgiving and that my Mom and Dad are allowing my niece to bring her girlfriend and friend from work. QUOTE]

This is the part I would ask my father about directly. Do your parents really know the niece’s lifestyle and that the one woman she is bringing is her partner or do your parents think its just two people from work? Does your sister know the full story about why you decided to have Thanksgiving at your house instead of your parents? All the details need to come out with all involved and you can ask for an explanation, not sure you’ll get one though.

If there actually is a preferentional treatment for the niece over your daughter’s situation, then I’d be planning a nice family dinner at home with my daughter, her boyfriend and baby and make plans to get together with the extended family at another time.
 
Thank you all for your words of advice. I do plan to talk to my parents about the situation and yes they are aware of my niece’s lifestyle. They are sort of in denial about it and think that it is just a phase that she will grow out of. I do agree that we should start developing our own family traditions, especially as our immediate family continues to grow. I only pray it doesn’t affect the rest of the holiday season and end up losing the true meaning of what this season is truly about.

God Bless,

RA
 
I feel for you. I don’t have any wisdom, but I’ll keep you in prayers. :hug1:
 
When they cited room as an issue, were you planning on having the boyfriend over just to eat at their home, or spend the night? Is the niece et al going to be spending the night?
Either way, I agree with the rest, speak with your father. Let him know how you are feeling about this, let him talk. If you are still hurt by his explanation, forgive him, and do whatever is best for your family (your wife etc).
 
UPDATE; Talked to my dad, and mom, and they have decided to come to my house for Thanksgiving dinner. Thank you all for your prayers. 🙂

To life is beautiful – it was just for dinner. No one was spending the night.
 
UPDATE; Talked to my dad, and mom, and they have decided to come to my house for Thanksgiving dinner. Thank you all for your prayers. 🙂

To life is beautiful – it was just for dinner. No one was spending the night.
Yeah, then I couldn’t understand what reasoning they would have had, but I’m glad it all worked out!!!
Awesome!!! Have a wonderful Thanksgiving!!!
 
UPDATE; Talked to my dad, and mom, and they have decided to come to my house for Thanksgiving dinner. Thank you all for your prayers. 🙂

To life is beautiful – it was just for dinner. No one was spending the night.
I’m glad it worked out. I’m thinking that no one gets out of Purgatory who cannot show they can share a meal with anyone willing to break bread in peace. You never know who the Good Lord will send to your table. There are times for making distinctions, but Thanksgiving is not one of them. It is not a day of mutual approval, but a day for concerted gratitude.

Let everyone come who needs a table to join. If there has to be disagreement that just cannot be put aside for that one day…well, it would not kill anyone to make some of the gravy with cornstarch, and some with flour. Let there be peace.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top