...Praying Rosary Under Mortal Sin

  • Thread starter Thread starter Th0t
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Is it acceptable to be able to pray the Rosary under mortal sin? Will God still hear our prayer through the Holy Rosary if we are under mortal sin?

:confused::confused::confused:

:blessyou:
It is a grace from God that you still feel propelled to pray the Rosary.

Mortal sin erodes the grace of the soul…, unchecked it strips the soul of all grace to the point that repentance is impossible.

Go to confession - confession is the inexhaustible source of renewable grace. Go to confession as often as possible, to overcome this mortal sin and the near occasions that bring you to converse with temptation.
 
Jesus said I have come to seek the lost, not the righteous. Most of us are familiar with the image of the Good Shepard removing the Lamb from the thorny bush. Is that bush not the sins into which a person has fallen?
Christ died for our sins while we were yet far off. He did not wait for the repentance of sinners before taking our sins upon Himself. If we wait until we are free from sin before we begin to pray, when will we begin? We need not be in a state of grace in order to pray.
There is power in prayer to transform the sinner. In one of my earlier posts, I mentioned praying as lifting our hearts and minds to God. It can be the beginning of the conversion process for a person who is in mortal sin, even if he/she has not yet begun to repent of that sin.
I would agree that God will not listen to a person who openly flaunts his/her sin, who remains in defiance of the saving power of God. The power of sin lies in its ability to block the flow of God’s Love. We hide when we feel guilty, as Adam and Eve did after eating the apple. Sin has the power to keep a person paralyzed with guilt, afraid to come into the Light of God’s Grace.Remaining in sin’s darkness can lead a person to even more grievous sin. Prayer on the other hand leads the person out of darkness into the light of day where sins are revealed for what they are. Prayer makes repentance possible.
As has already been mentioned, when a person begins to pray the rosary, Mary becomes the intercessor. It is Mary who is heard and the chains that hold the person bound in his sin can begin to loosen.
…Holy Mary, Mother of God, pray for us sinners now and at the hour of our death.
Prayer does not change God. It changes the person who prays.
 
I got back to the Church as a result of praying the Rosary while under a great load of mortal sin. No sin would make me stop saying the Rosary.

Rove
 
It’s important here to know the differences in the kinds of prayer. The rosary is really predominantly a meditative prayer but can be applied to most any category of prayer. If one is in mortal sin one by definition has a wounded and corrupted capacity for supernatural love that is defective and principally self-centered. This severely impedes one’s ability to pray efficaciously. The only way to repair the relationship is through prayers of repentance/contrition/expiation & confession. If one gains the grace to achieve perfect contrition then one WILL have all their other forms of prayers heard. But it makes no relational sense to offer prayer of petition for temporal help etc. until one has FIRST gained a repentant relationship and formed a state of contrition through repentant prayer.

Here is a list of some of the general categories of prayer:
  • Thanksgiving - Giving God the thanks He deserves.
  • Petition - Bring our spiritual or physical needs and requests before God for ourselves, our family, or our friends and the world at large etc. always made with our willingness to accept God’s will in the matter.
  • Persevering Prayer - These are the prayers for the deepest intentions of our heart. If we pray night and day for this intention then this is persevering prayer. The most sought after grace is the grace of final perseverance - this is a thing all should pray for night and day.
  • Intersession - Similar to petition, but we ask the servants of God already in Heaven to pray for us just as we ask our friends on earth to pray for us to join in in our requests.
  • Meditative prayer - Being still and letting God tell us what HE wants us to hear. Very common in those quiet moments of Eucharistic Adoration or in solitude away from worldly concerns.
  • Adoration/Worship - Similar to Thanksgiving, we praise the greatness of God, and we acknowledge our dependence on him in all things. The Mass and the other liturgies of the Church are full of these kinds of prayers (Gloria, Act of Faith etc.). The Mass is the pinnacle of worship.
  • Expiation/contrition - we acknowledge our sinfulness and ask God for His forgiveness and mercy. Examples: The Confiteor or Penitential Rite at the beginning of Mass, and the Agnus Dei (or Lamb of God) before Communion, The Act of Contrition, Miserere (Psalm 51).
  • Love - prayers of love or charity expressing our love for God, the source and object of all love. The Act of Charity is an example.
On the matter of unconfessed mortal sins. I strongly recommend that everyone always attempt to perform a perfect act of contrition to God before all kinds of prayer. Everyone of us always has some small venial sins and this easily remedies those. And the act of contrition can be a precaution too for the possible case that one has some lingering unconfessed post-baptismal mortal sin one has forgotten to confess from long ago. At a minimum God is owed an apology even if the mortal sin was forgiven in confession due to an innocent forgetfulness during a prior confession (e.g. not consciously held back).

The Holy Spirit will usually bring these sort of forgotten but coincidentally forgiven mortal sins to mind over one’s life in those who are piously committed to advancing their spirital perfection so they can be “apologized for” (even if they were already coincidentally forgiven through innocent forgetfulness during a prior sacramental confession).

The really nice thing about always performing an act of contrition before we pray for specific intentions is that it puts us in a contrite and humble spiritual state and really opens up a clear and unimpeded spiritual channel to God. Contritional prayer are like washing our hands before dinner - they are the responsible preparations necessary to facilitate a fresh and pure tone in our spiritual-music offered to God. I like the analogy of the woodwind musician (e.g. clarinet, saxophone, oboe, bassoon) who replaces his instrument’s old warped and cracked mouthpiece reed to give the purest and sweetest sound before playing his solo before an important audience or auditioning for a chair.

Here is what some of the early-church thought about this:
Early Church Sentiments on Efficacy of Prayer and Confession:
"Confess your sins in church, and do not go up to your prayer with an evil conscience. This is the way of life. . . . On the Lord’s Day gather together, break bread, and give thanks, after confessing your transgressions so that your sacrifice may be pure" (Didache 4:14, 14:1 [A.D. 70]).

"You shall confess your sins. You shall not go to prayer with an evil conscience (Letter of Barnabas 19 [A.D. 74]).

“To all them that repent, the Lord grants forgiveness, if they turn in penitence to the unity of God and to communion with the bishop” (ibid., 8)
That said, there are two kinds of sorrow for sin: contrition and attrition, which are called also perfect contrition and imperfect contrition. Perfect contrition does not mean the perfect degree of contrition, but the perfect kind of contrition—that is, sorrow for sins based on charity, or supernatural love of God. Clearly to gain anything supernatural in both degree or kind requires God’s grace – especially for humans to attain supernatural love. This is the power of grace. Imperfect contrition is sorrow for sin based on anything other than charity (such as being sorry for our sins because we fear the punishment of hell and God’s wrath).

Perfect and imperfect contrition are not mutually exclusive. A person can have both at the same time. Both perfect and imperfect contrition assume the resolve to sin no more. Even with this resolve, it is possible to commit the same sin in the future. What is important is that at this moment in time we make a firm resolution to turn away from mortal sin.

Under normal circumstances, for a mortal sin to be forgiven, it must be confessed in the sacrament of penance. **If the penitent has perfect or imperfect contrition for his sin, confesses all his mortal sins since his last good confession, resolving not to commit the sin again, and receives absolution from the priest, his mortal sins are forgiven. **

Bottom Line:
God ALWAYS hears contrite prayers of contrition and no sincere prayer is ever wasted. But forgiveness for mortal sin can never be assumed unless one has gone to sacramental confession or God has revealed that He has granted a perfect act of contrition.

Advice for Protestants and non-Catholics with no sacrament of confession:
Say the Divine Mercy Chaplet Daily for themselves and for their family and friends. There is a link in my signature below. This is 100% all prayers to God and Jesus with no references to the saintly intercessions and only takes a few minutes to say. If you don’t have the rosary beads you can simply count them out.

James
 
I like the analogy of a musician putting a new reed on his/her woodwind.
There is a reason that prayers of repentance come near the beginning of Mass.
When I originally learned to pray the rosary, we ended not with the Hail Holy Queen, but with an Act of Contrition. The only time we were allowed in my parents’ bedroom was at the end of the day when everybody gathered around the bed to pray the rosary.

It is true that sins may resurface as memories are healed. I like the song that iterates the Biblical truth that our sins are cast as far away as the east is from the west. God is not the accuser. A man asks God what the worse sin he committed was. God replies,“What sin. I forgot the minute you confessed. It is not that I don’t remember, but that I choose to forget.”
Satan’s game, of course, is one of blame, of pointing to our unworthiness to receive God’s grace. God pours out His grace however on the plebeian who acknowledges his guilt and not the pharisee who stands in the synagogue praying to himself. We are all guilty. Christ paid the price for our guilt. We stand redeemed.
Does that mean we have permission to remain in our sins? Absolutely not. We count on the grace of the Holy Spirit to strengthen and guide us. It is God himself who pulls us out of our sinful state. God meets us where we are and brings us to where He is at.
When a person goes to a doctor, it is because of illness. The sicker the person, the greater the need for the healing arts. The graver our sin, the greater our need for God’s mercy and love, and the greater our need to begin to pray.
 
Are you going to take De Montfort’s opinion over the infallible Word of God?
Let’s clear this up from the words of St. De Montfort himself:

To say the Holy Rosary to advantage one must be in a state of grace or at the very least be fully determined to give up mortal sin. This we know because all our theology teaches us that good works and prayers are only dead works if they are they are done in a state of mortal sin. Therefore they can neither be pleasing to God nor help us gain eternal life. This is why Ecclesiastes says: “Praise is not seemly in the mouth of a sinner” (Eccl. 15:9). Praise of God and the salutation of the angel and the very Prayer of Jesus Christ are not pleasing to God when they are said by unrepentant sinners. Our Lord said: “This people honoreth me with their lips, but their heart is far from me” (Mark 7:6). It is as though He was saying: “Those who join My Confraternity and say their Rosary every day (even perhaps the fifteen decades), but without being sorry for their sins offer Me Up service only and their hearts are far from Me.”

I have just said that to say the Rosary to advantage one must be in a state of grace “or at least be fully determined to give up mortal sin;” first of all, because, if it were true that God only heard the prayers of those in a state of grace it would follow that people in a state of mortal sin should not pray at all. This is an erroneous teaching which has been condemned by Holy Mother Church, because of course sinners need to pray far more than good people do. Were this horrible doctrine true it would then be useless and futile to tell a sinner to say all, or even part of his Rosary, because it would never help him.

Secondly, because if they join one of Our Lady’s confraternities and recite the Rosary or some other prayer, but without having the slightest intention of giving up sin, they join the ranks of her false devotees. These presumptuous and impenitent devotees, hiding under her mantle, wearing the scapular and with rosary in hand, cry
out: “Blessed Virgin, good Mother—Hail, Mary!…” And yet at the same time, **by their sins, they are crucifying Our Lord Jesus Christ and tearing His flesh anew. **It is a great tragedy, but from the very ranks of Our Lady’s most holy Confraternities souls are falling into the fires of hell.

…

The learned Cardinal Hugues tells us that one should be as pure as an angel to approach the Blessed Virgin and say the Angelic Salutation. One day, our Lady showed herself to an immoral man who used to say the Rosary regularly every day. She showed him a bowl of beautiful fruit, but the bowl itself was covered with filth. The man was horrified to see this, and our Lady said to him, "This is the way you are honouring me. You are giving me beautiful roses in a dirty bowl. Do you think I can find them pleasing to me?"


Admirable Secret of the Rosary, 41st Rose. Paragraph 117-118
, emphases mine.
 
Prayers of repentance are always heard. Sometimes people cannot physically go to confession, but they can still make an act of contrition (a prayer) and try to avoid sinning again. I am sure sincere prayers for your own well-being or for others are also heard. You cannot grow in sanctifying grace (holiness) while in a state of mortal sin, however.

A big mistake I think people often make after doing mortal sins is giving up until they can get to confession. People get the attitude “I’ve already done this, so why not do that now”, and they indulge themselves.
What if your not sure what you did/or did not do was a Mortal sin?
Scrupulousity kills me with that, I always think it lacks one of the 3 Conditions, but can never be sure.
 
What if your not sure what you did/or did not do was a Mortal sin?
Scrupulousity kills me with that, I always think it lacks one of the 3 Conditions, but can never be sure.
Mortal sin by definition presupposes the knowledge that it is grave matter and was consciously consented to. One can not commit grave sin by accident - its a deliberate choice.

James
 
I find it difficult to see if what i did/ or did not do. Would be classified as Mortal sin, Sometimes i wonder if i’m denying that im in mortal sin. It’s difficult to discern the Gravity.
I’m sorry but scrupulousity, is a stubborn thing,
 
When asked if she was in a state of grace, St. Joan of Arc replied," If I am in a state of grace, I pray God will keep me there. If I am not, then I pray that God will put me there."

I like this prayer written by Thomas Merton:
My Lord God, I have no idea where I am going. I don’t see the road ahead of me. I cannot know for certain where it will end. Nor do I really know myself if I am following your will,and the fact that I think that I am following your will does not mean that I am actually doing so. But I believe that the desire to please you does in fact please you. And I hope that I will never do anything apart from that desire. And I know that if I do this you will lead me by the right road, though I may know nothing about it.Therefore I will trust you always ,though I may seem to be lost and in the shadow of death. I will not fear,for you are ever with me. And you will never leave me to face my perils alone.
 
Your comments seem to conflict with the teachings of the Bible …* James 5:16 - " … The effective, fervent prayer of a righteous man avails much … "
  • Isaiah 59:2 - “ … But your iniquities have made a separation between you and your God, and your sins have hidden His face from you so that He does not hear … ”
  • Proverbs 15:29 - “ … The LORD is far from the wicked, but He hears the prayer of the righteous … ”
  • Psalm 66:18 - “ … If I regard wickedness in my heart, the Lord will not hear … ”
  • 1 Peter 3:11 - “ … Let him turn away from evil and do good; let him seek peace and pursue it. For the eyes of the Lord are on the righteous, and His ears are open to their prayers; but the face of the Lord is against those who do evil … ”
  • John 9:31 - “ … Now we know that God heareth not sinners: but if any man be a worshipper of God, and doeth his will, him he heareth … ”
Very true. Let me add:

Proverbs 28:9 “If one turns away his ear from hearing the law, even his prayer is an abomination.”

Any prayer uttered in the state of unrepented mortal sin is an abomination. That is why the church forbids anyone who is the state of mortal sin, or has been excommunicated latae sententiae or ferundae sententiae, from receiving Holy Communion. That is also why Christ Himself condemned the Pharisees as hypocrites who pray all day and yet are far from Him and promptly said:

Mathew 23:33: You serpents, you brood of vipers, how will you escape the judgement of hell?"

Having said that, there is just one exception. The only exception is a prayer of genuine contrition. Prayers seeking forgiveness is always welcome to God even from the most wicked of sinners. But prayers for the dead, prayers asking favors, or prayers for the intention of other people, are never heard, and are an abomination when in a state of unrepented mortal sins.

How dare you ask God for anything or on behalf of others, when you yourself, by your own free will, knowingly committed a grievous wrong that spurned God?

Ergo, when you know you have incurred mortal sin, the first prayer that must come from your lips is a prayer of lamentation, or sincere contrition and a prayer promising to do penance and amend your evil ways . Only then, may you start praying for others, trusting in the Divine Mercy of our Lord. Then go to confession the first chance you get. But not before.
 
Same goes for prayers of praise and worship. How can you praise and worship the God you have so knowingly and grievously spurned by your unrepented mortal sin? Such would be hypocrisy.
 
This is one of the most prevalent errors among modern Catholics today. They commit the mortal sins of fornication out of wedlock, homosexual acts, masturbation, watching online pornographic content, missing mass, or frustrating procreation using contraceptives. They think nothing of any of these as if God automatically forgives them without asking. They will even pile up on their mortal sins by sacrilegiously taking Holy Communion on those Sundays they find time to attend mass. And yet they wonder why their prayers are never answered.
 
Just make sure you don’t pray the rosary in the state of unrepented mortal sin. I remember an anecdote about an inveterate mortal sinner in whose hypocrisy always prayed the complete mysteries of the Holy Rosary everyday. One day our Lady appeared and showed to the sinner how his prayers looked to her - full bloom roses each caked in all sorts of excrement. Our Lady asked him: “Did you really think I can accept those roses in such conditions?”
 
Is it acceptable to be able to pray the Rosary under mortal sin? Will God still hear our prayer through the Holy Rosary if we are under mortal sin?

:confused::confused::confused:

:blessyou:
If one is in such a situation, pray it with the intention of obtaining the grace of repentance.
If you say the Rosary faithfully until death, I do assure you that, in spite of the gravity of your sins “you shall receive a never fading crown of glory.” Even if you are on the brink of damnation, even if you have one foot in Hell, even if you have sold your soul to the devil as sorcerers do who practise black magic, and even if you are a heretic as obstinate as a devil, sooner or later you will be converted and will amend your life and save your soul, if----and mark well what I say----if you say the Holy Rosary devoutly every day until death for the purpose of knowing the truth and obtaining contrition and pardon for your sins.[St. Louis de Montfort]
 
If one is in such a situation, pray it with the intention of obtaining the grace of repentance.
No argument there. Prayers of genuine repentance are pleasing to God, even if they come form the greatest sinners. But praying for the grace of repentance becomes problematic when you clearly recognize your mortal sins and yet do nothing about it, but just pray.
If you say the Rosary faithfully until death, I do assure you that, in spite of the gravity of your sins “you shall receive a never fading crown of glory.” Even if you are on the brink of damnation, even if you have one foot in Hell, even if you have sold your soul to the devil as sorcerers do who practise black magic, and even if you are a heretic as obstinate as a devil, sooner or later you will be converted and will amend your life and save your soul, if----and mark well what I say----if you say the Holy Rosary devoutly every day until death for the purpose of knowing the truth and obtaining contrition and pardon for your sins.[St. Louis de Montfort]
Between the bible that says prayers from unrepentant sinners are an abomination to God and words from a mere saint however comforting, guess which I will believe?. The statement from de Montfort is actually self-contradictory. How can anyone whose obstinacy to grievous sin with one foot already in hell pray the rosary devoutly everyday without first feeling remorseful? In most likelihood, he won’t even have the grace to look or touch a rosary, much less last through one decade. Obstinacy to sin is one of the sins against the Holy Spirit. How can you be genuinely a Catholic and yet know that you are an obstinate heretic, or a necromancer? That’s what hypocrisy is about. And Christ Himself condemns hypocrites in Mathew 23:33 when He lambasted the Pharisees who pray everyday and yet are full of sins. “You serpents, you brood of vipers, how will you escape the judgement of hell?”
 
There’s no contradiction.

The prayer of a man who intends to continue sinning no matter what is abominable before God, and is reckoned as one of the sins against the Holy Ghost.

The prayer of a sinner (even a heretic), who is stuck in the habit of sin, but has a sincere desire to repent, can ask for the grace to repent and to come to know the knowledge of the truth - and that petition is pleasing to God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top