Proselytizing? why not?

  • Thread starter Thread starter caroljm36
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

caroljm36

Guest
I found this interesting article over at the Orthodoxy Today site

orthodoxytoday.org/articles4/UzzellProselytize.shtml

They’re saying that proselytizing has become a dirty word all over the world and discusses why this happened. It really bothers me because I do not see any real proselytizing going on in my parish, at all, not even at the homeless shelter. It’s as if it was considered rude or embarrassing. I guess I’m still whining because no one proselytized me back when I was really interested and I think an earlier conversion would have changed my life significantly.

…Consider the following examples. In 1961 the World Council of Churches pronounced “proselytism” to be “a corruption of Christian witness” that uses “cajolery, bribery, undue pressure, or intimidation, subtly or openly, to bring about seeming conversion.” In a footnote to the documents of Vatican II the Roman Catholic Church defined proselytism as “a corruption of the Christian witness by appeal to hidden forms of coercion or by a style of propaganda unworthy of the Gospel. It is not the use but the abuse of the right to religious freedom.”

It’s just never discussed in homilies or in literature that I see. I’m still not convinced the Church wants new members, oh except for babies and spouses maybe. When I was in RCIA it was like, why are you here? Are you marrying a Catholic? If not, oh yes it’s a “beautiful religion” as if my interest were aesthetic only. Yet I see conversion, especially of the unbaptized like I was, as the key to turning this horrible culture around. Is there any place where the Church or orders religious actually try to make new Catholics?
 
40.png
caroljm36:
I found this interesting article over at the Orthodoxy Today site

orthodoxytoday.org/articles4/UzzellProselytize.shtml

They’re saying that proselytizing has become a dirty word all over the world and discusses why this happened. It really bothers me because I do not see any real proselytizing going on in my parish, at all, not even at the homeless shelter. It’s as if it was considered rude or embarrassing. I guess I’m still whining because no one proselytized me back when I was really interested and I think an earlier conversion would have changed my life significantly.

…Consider the following examples. In 1961 the World Council of Churches pronounced “proselytism” to be “a corruption of Christian witness” that uses “cajolery, bribery, undue pressure, or intimidation, subtly or openly, to bring about seeming conversion.” In a footnote to the documents of Vatican II the Roman Catholic Church defined proselytism as “a corruption of the Christian witness by appeal to hidden forms of coercion or by a style of propaganda unworthy of the Gospel. It is not the use but the abuse of the right to religious freedom.”

It’s just never discussed in homilies or in literature that I see. I’m still not convinced the Church wants new members, oh except for babies and spouses maybe. When I was in RCIA it was like, why are you here? Are you marrying a Catholic? If not, oh yes it’s a “beautiful religion” as if my interest were aesthetic only. Yet I see conversion, especially of the unbaptized like I was, as the key to turning this horrible culture around. Is there any place where the Church or orders religious actually try to make new Catholics?
When I converted a priest I met was angry/confused that I converted. It’s just not ecumenical you see to follow the truth :mad:
 
Hello caroljm36,

I think that proselytizing has become a dirty word primarily because of Protesant TV evangalists. I had a roomate from India. He said watch this. He started counting down five, four, three, two, one, then he pointed at the screen and the preacher imediately started talking about sending money. Then my roomate laughed. The TV evangelist had “the message” timed to the second as to when to ask for money. When you see these evagalists with their makeup and tears you have to admit it is quite the show for those watching. However, to common people in the world, they see these “proselytizers” as phony, greedy people out to get a buck and gain worldly exaltation over others as “God’s chosen few”.

From what I hear on the street, it is these TV evangelists and preachers like them that they think of in regards to proselytizing. This seems to be what turns off many people in the world from listening to any Christian, Catholic or Protestant, when they try to convert someone. This is why I think Catholics are gun shy when it comes to proselytizing.

Peace in Chirst,
Steven Merten
www.ILOVEYOUGOD.com
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top