Protestant family

  • Thread starter Thread starter katy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

katy

Guest
I am the only Catholic in my family. The rest still go to the Presbyterian church in my (our) neighborhood. The place is huge and rather aligned with the Catholic church on issues such as pro-life and gay marriage.
Many folks there still assume I’m a member because I go with friends or family members to a class or event. Is there anything wrong with this? I don’t want to be in their faces about it, and I enjoy being with these folks in ways that don’t seem to compromise my Catholic faith. Anyone have ideas or been in the same situation?
 
40.png
katy:
I am the only Catholic in my family. The rest still go to the Presbyterian church in my (our) neighborhood. The place is huge and rather aligned with the Catholic church on issues such as pro-life and gay marriage.
Many folks there still assume I’m a member because I go with friends or family members to a class or event. Is there anything wrong with this? I don’t want to be in their faces about it, and I enjoy being with these folks in ways that don’t seem to compromise my Catholic faith. Anyone have ideas or been in the same situation?
It’s all good as long as you are fulfilling your obligations as a Catholic and it isn’t compromising your faith.

Eamon
 
Hi Katy, I too am a convert and my family are also protestants. They were raised Southern Baptist, were missionaries for an interdenominational protestant mission in South America and now attend a Presbyterian Church. I am still their " little girl" and when I go to visit they like to have me go to church with them ( my daddy likes to play show and tell with me, he is a very proud papa of his little soldeir girl). HOWEVER, they are also very understanding ( of which I was very pleasently surprised) and supportive of me attending Mass. There is a Catholic Church in their town and it works out great because I and the kids can go to early Mass then we go meet my parents at their church to sit with them. My son made a comment one SUnday ( just to me). He said “You know Mom, going to church without the Eucharist is like eating an empty ice cream cone”. I thought that was very well put. I worried if going to both services might confuse my children, but as long as I keep teaching them about the differences I think it is allowing them to see for themselves why the Catholic Church is the church instituted by Jesus. I’ve invited my parents to go to Mass with me, and my mom has gone with me a couple of times. I know they love the Lord, our Lord, very much and yet I feel sad for them because there is so much they are missing, so much that the protestant denominations just don’t have anymore.

When I do go to visit, very often religion is the topic of discussion, just because it is, and I pray ernerstly that when the time comes that God will put the right words in my mouth that I may be able to articulate just how wonderful God’s Catholic Church is. I want to be able to dispell the untruths they were raised to believe about the Catholic Church.

I never stop thanking God for the gift of my faith and for the miracle of bringing me into HIS Church.

So what does your family think about you being Catholic, Katy? I guess that really is so vital as a starting point. If they don’t like it vs. if they are OK with it will have an impact on what you can say and how. If they are OK with it, invite them to Mass with you. I’ve noticed things in my mom’s house that I never saw growing up before, like an Advent Wreath for one. And this past year, during Lent, she abstained from dinner. These were things that we never did growing up, and I know most of it is coming from the church they are presently going to, but I also know where those traditions originated from. And there are so many where those came from.

Anyway, didn’t mean to be so long winded but to answer your question, yes I am in the same situation. And it is a situation that I take very seriously because I am now a witness to them about the Catholic Faith. That is one reason I come here so often to continue to learn and read all I can so that when I do have to answer questions for them that I will do so correctly and in a manner that will Honor and Glorify His Sacred Heart.

sgt. pat
 
Me too, Katy! 👋
Lone catholic in a sea of evangelical and otherwise protestant friends and family.
I think it is very important to keep your ties with these people, while at the same time clinging closely to your catholic faith. Be Salt and Light, and a very flavorful catholic. Show them how you love your faith! This is why people convert! Like someone else said - as long as you keep your catholic obligations and don’t comprimise your beliefs you are free to associate with these people - and you SHOULD!
 
40.png
ridesawhitehors:
Me too, Katy! 👋
Lone catholic in a sea of evangelical and otherwise protestant friends and family.
I think it is very important to keep your ties with these people, while at the same time clinging closely to your catholic faith. Be Salt and Light, and a very flavorful catholic. Show them how you love your faith! This is why people convert! Like someone else said - as long as you keep your catholic obligations and don’t comprimise your beliefs you are free to associate with these people - and you SHOULD!
🙂 ditto
 
Ditto for me too Katy-------(don’t know if you’ve seen any of my other threads or not).

I’m the only Catholic (as of Easter) for years in my huge family of Prots. with many pastors in it as well, including dad.

I say be youself, like you always have been, only if someone asks you, tell them you finally found the “True Church”, "The Church Jesus began 2000 years ago, and how you’ve discovered Jesus did not mean for all these splits in denominations. Awesome. This might just open the door for further discussion. Then you can share. I have. Some, well most have frowned on it, but only God knows what seeds might be planted. 🙂

God Bless~

P.S. Oh–I have gotten now to the point where I just cannot go to the Prot. church any longer. If my hubby or kids want to go–fine, but I can’t. It seems to lacking, so empty, and I just don’t support that.
 
Thank you all for your support and great replies. I would have responded earlier, but I was in Rome!!! with my daughter, who is a Tech Sgt. in the Air Force, Ramstein. As a matter of fact, we saw and heard the Pope and went to Mass in St. Peter’s! It was a welcome strengthening experience, since I pretty much have to go it alone. I wish my daughter was practicing her faith, esp. since she is to be deployed to Baghdad in a few months, but God works in his own ways and I hope this was one of them.
I have been sort of out of the Catholic loop for a while, not even going to Mass. My Dad was dying from Parkinson’s, much like JPII over the last few years, and I just kind of drifted to the Presbys where he was and where there are many committed Christians, but it was just not the same. I went to Confesssion last April and am so surprized at how inwardly joyful I feel, even tho my Dad and also my Mom-in-law have died. I am so greatful that God sort of haunted me back to where I belong and has forgiven all the ways I messed up along the way.
I know my stepmother will not approve, as she is always making comments about priests liking little boys or being homosexual,and criticized the Passion movie for showing so much about Mary’s involvement. She is a fine person in many ways, but somewhat bigoted. Don’t know how that will work out. My sisters figure it’s one of my excentricities, sort of like dying my hair purple. My husband is fond of the Catholic church, and a member, but doesn’t really think about it much, just follows me around. Both daughters ID as Catholic, but nonpracticing. One son is contemplating practicing again; the other is a declared agnostic. I feel that I failed my kids somehow, but was not well taught myself and mistakenly thought the RE programs actually taught the faith. It seems they were actually almost working agains me. I did the best I knew how at the time and have to hope the seeds that were planted take root sometime.
I would hate to lose my Prot. friends who may conclude I am unappreciative of their support during my father’s illness, but know I can’t please everyone. We recently joinedan inner city parish that is very faithful to the teaching of the Church. Since I no longer have to attend to young children (they are grown) or my Dad (died), I am hoping to become involved somehow. Time will tell.
I have read all your responses on the Rome USO computer station, but so many were waiting, I did not want to take more time to respond until returning to the base. Thaks again for your welcome and helpful support. It is also comforting just to know I am not the only one in this situation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top