Question on oaths

  • Thread starter Thread starter Wulfgar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

Wulfgar

Guest
Hello, this is my first post. I was hoping it would be something spectacular, but I find it more important to attain necessary information first. Oh well.

At any rate, to lay foundation to the question, I participated in a mock trial run-through and as a witness was required to go through the standard “Do you swear to tell the truth…so help you God?” Being scrupulous in numerous areas of life (including religion), I was a bit worried at this but nonetheless said “I do”, trying to tell myself just to do my best even though I feared I may slip up. During questioning I was asked about vehicle damages and accidentally said a wrong measurement (I was also unsure about it; I forgot but said what I thought was right). What is worrying me is that later, I was asked something along the lines of “…and you said it was so-and-so cm long…”. The lawyer said a different measurement than what I had previously said, but in nervousness about the whole oath ordeal I tried to say something that wouldn’t be perjury, and instead responded “I believe so…”, which of course I didn’t, but being a mock trial run-through and not a real trial I was more concerned with getting past trivial details (the measurements themselves not appearing to be important) without frustration and confusion from the lawyers and others. Admittedly, I may also have been worried about personal standing. Had it been a real trial, I would certainly hope I’d spend extra time to bring forth the true evidence.

All in all, at the time I was in doubt about this, because it was a mock trial and thus more like acting (by the way, it’s a school activity, and has nothing to do with preparations for a real trial, etc. It’s entirely fictitious). However, perjury is perjury, so I still worry. So, to formulate an actual question, was this a mortal sin? Apologies for the long response… I want to reveal as much of my conscience as possible. If this seems ridiculous, forgive me.
 
Hello, this is my first post. I was hoping it would be something spectacular, but I find it more important to attain necessary information first. Oh well.

At any rate, to lay foundation to the question, I participated in a mock trial run-through and as a witness was required to go through the standard “Do you swear to tell the truth…so help you God?” Being scrupulous in numerous areas of life (including religion), I was a bit worried at this but nonetheless said “I do”, trying to tell myself just to do my best even though I feared I may slip up. During questioning I was asked about vehicle damages and accidentally said a wrong measurement (I was also unsure about it; I forgot but said what I thought was right). What is worrying me is that later, I was asked something along the lines of “…and you said it was so-and-so cm long…”. The lawyer said a different measurement than what I had previously said, but in nervousness about the whole oath ordeal I tried to say something that wouldn’t be perjury, and instead responded “I believe so…”, which of course I didn’t, but being a mock trial run-through and not a real trial I was more concerned with getting past trivial details (the measurements themselves not appearing to be important) without frustration and confusion from the lawyers and others. Admittedly, I may also have been worried about personal standing. Had it been a real trial, I would certainly hope I’d spend extra time to bring forth the true evidence.

All in all, at the time I was in doubt about this, because it was a mock trial and thus more like acting (by the way, it’s a school activity, and has nothing to do with preparations for a real trial, etc. It’s entirely fictitious). However, perjury is perjury, so I still worry. So, to formulate an actual question, was this a mortal sin? Apologies for the long response… I want to reveal as much of my conscience as possible. If this seems ridiculous, forgive me.
No, since you were not giving real testimony.

However, if it were real and you made an honest error in measurement, or got confused over the measurement, the proper second answer would be that you made an error and spoke using the wrong measurement. It’s not perjury if you give an honest answer to the best of your understanding of the question or your best recollection.

Especially when one gets confused or the lawyer repeats the question using the wrong previous answer. If you said the distance from a car to the intersection was 50 feet and it was actually 30 feet and the lawyer comes back with “so you previously testified 30 feet”, you can correct him – as to your testimony since you believed it to be 50 feet – or that you made an error - and yes, it was 30 feet. If you honestly don’t catch it or you honestly don’t recall, it’s proper to say “I believe so.” or “I do not recall.” It’s not perjury if there’s a mistake on your part or the part of the attorney asking the question.
 
Hello, this is my first post. I was hoping it would be something spectacular, but I find it more important to attain necessary information first. Oh well.

At any rate, to lay foundation to the question, I participated in a mock trial run-through and as a witness was required to go through the standard “Do you swear to tell the truth…so help you God?” Being scrupulous in numerous areas of life (including religion), I was a bit worried at this but nonetheless said “I do”, trying to tell myself just to do my best even though I feared I may slip up. During questioning I was asked about vehicle damages and accidentally said a wrong measurement (I was also unsure about it; I forgot but said what I thought was right). What is worrying me is that later, I was asked something along the lines of “…and you said it was so-and-so cm long…”. The lawyer said a different measurement than what I had previously said, but in nervousness about the whole oath ordeal I tried to say something that wouldn’t be perjury, and instead responded “I believe so…”, which of course I didn’t, but being a mock trial run-through and not a real trial I was more concerned with getting past trivial details (the measurements themselves not appearing to be important) without frustration and confusion from the lawyers and others. Admittedly, I may also have been worried about personal standing. Had it been a real trial, I would certainly hope I’d spend extra time to bring forth the true evidence.

All in all, at the time I was in doubt about this, because it was a mock trial and thus more like acting (by the way, it’s a school activity, and has nothing to do with preparations for a real trial, etc. It’s entirely fictitious). However, perjury is perjury, so I still worry. So, to formulate an actual question, was this a mortal sin? Apologies for the long response… I want to reveal as much of my conscience as possible. If this seems ridiculous, forgive me.
With scrupulosity like this you really should sit down with a priest and have a long talk otherwise being so scrupulous will simply make your life miserable.
 
Thank you for your responses. I have been very confused lately.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top