Question re: Haydock citations

  • Thread starter Thread starter rhiamom
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

rhiamom

Guest
In the Haydock commentary there are citations of the Bible and early Church Fathers. I can usually figure them out, but one has me stumped. There are numerous references to a source simply called C. These references follow the same format as the Bible references, with a chapter in small Roman numerals followed by a verse in Arabic numerals. Or possibly a chapter and page of a book. Does anybody know what this source is? It is perhaps the single most often cited source, so knowing what it is would be most helpful.
 
Why not send an email to the man who put the Haydock Commentary online. Probably he has a hard copy of Haydock and in the beginning there might be an explanation of abbreviations.
 
In the online version of the Haydock Catholic Bible commentary, the transcriber has tried to expand some of the original abbreviations for ease of understanding.

“C.” or “c.” followed by Roman numbers (in lower case letters) almost always stands for “Chapter.” Thus, for example, “C. iii. 5.” almost always means “Chapter iii., verse 5.” of some book. Which particular book is determined from the context. Here are some examples:

Example #1: On Matthew 1:12, the Haydock commentary reads:
In comparing the present genealogy with that of S. Luke, (C. iii.) we find that in this last part S. Matthew has suppressed many generations, to bring the list to the number 14; for there are a greater number from Zorobabel to Jesus Christ in S. Luke, but in a different branch. V.
In this case, with its reference to S. Luke, “C. iii.” means “Luke, chapter iii.”

Example #2: On Matthew 2:15, the Haydock commentary reads:
S. Jerom understands these words to be taken out of the prophet Osee, (C. xi. 2.) and granted they might be literally spoken of the people of Israel: yet as their captivity in Egypt was a figure of the slavery of sin, under which all mankind groaned, and as their delivery by Moses was a figure of man’s redemption by our Saviour Christ, so these words in a mystical and spiritual sense apply to our Saviour, who in a more proper sense was the Son of God, than was the people of Israel.
In this case, with its reference to Osee, “C. xi. 2.” means “Osee, chapter xi., verse 2.”

Example #3: On Matthew 10:22, the Haydock commentary reads:
We are also assured of the same truth in Ezechiel. If the just man shall turn away from his justice, and shall commit iniquity, he shall die in his sins, and his justice which he hath done shall not be remembered. C. iii, v. 20.
In this case, with its reference to Ezechiel, “C. iii, v. 20.” means “Ezechiel, chapter iii., verse 20.”

Example #4: On Matthew 21:2, the Haydock commentary reads:
Here was manifestly fulfilled the prophecy of Zachary. C. ix.
In this case, with its reference to Zachary, “C. ix.” means “Zacharias, chapter ix.”

Example #5: On Luke 21:37, the Haydock commentary reads:
In this last week, Christ, after preaching in the day-time in the temple, when constantly in the evenings to pray in the garden of Gethsemani, as Judas knew very well. See C. xxii. v. 39.
In this case, which lacks an obvious reference to another book, the same book (Luke) is to be understood, so that, “C. xxii. v. 39.” means “Luke, chapter xxii., verse 39.”

If you are still having trouble with a particular citation, I would be happy to help you try to decipher it.
 
Thanks, Todd, I didn’t want to bother you with another email. I went looking at the web version and figured out that some of the references were to the same book, but I did not see that some got the book from the context. I wasn’t reading, after all, just skimming to create links for scripture citations.

This helps me enormously.
 
I have the Haydock books. Here are the abbreviations they show in the beginning section titled “Advertisement”:

B. = Bristow
C. = Calmet (first name given as Aug., so assume full name is Augustine Calmet)
Ch. = Dr R. Challoner,
D. = Du Hamel
E. = Estius
M. = Menochius,
P. = Pastorini or Walmesley
T. = Tirinus
W. = Worthington
Wi. = Witham
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top