Questions about my decision to convert

  • Thread starter Thread starter ZiggysGal
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Z

ZiggysGal

Guest
For clarity, the history of the situation (feel free to skip this part):

My husband and I are on the path to join the Catholic Church. This shared journey began approximately 3 years ago following each of our experiences on ACTS retreats. Prior to that, the subject had come up because we have family history in the Church (my grandparents and his parents prior to his birth… among others) and my previous marriage included exploration of the faith.

Spring of 2012, we met with a priest at our local parish and picked up packets to begin our annulments. (He had been married once before. I had been married twice before but one ex is deceased.) It took approximately one year to complete and gather information and witnesses.

Feb 2013, we submitted our packets with an acceptance date of 3/13/13.

In anticipation of the full estimated one year process, we began RCIA that Fall. Sadly, Easter 2014 came and went and all of our fellow RCIA classmates were welcomed into the church and we ‘sat on the sidelines’ because we still had no response on the annulments.

It hurt to wait and wait and wait… but there was absolutely no way we could just give up, no matter how long it took.

March 4, 2015 we received the final word that both declarations of nullity had been granted. We have an appointment to meet with the priest on Monday after work. (I can’t tell you what a relief this is!)

(End of the history)

Upon receiving the notice of our annulment status, I shared this amazing blessing with many friends and family by word of mouth as well as social media. I had so much joy in my heart that I was bursting to share it!

Quite a few people have asked me questions about my conversion decision, but the one that strikes me as the most … frustrating?.. is this one.

***Why in the world would you want to become Catholic? ***

Of course, someone bold enough to question my faith decisions like this is neither going to understand nor accept any answer I am capable of giving… but worse than that is the follow up asking why I would hope that my adult children would follow suit. A coworker who was raised Catholic (claims to not attend Mass but does send her young children to CCD) actually posed this question and went so far as to leave me feeling ashamed for saying “I have faith one day it will all work out.” (in regards to my kids following suit)

Why do people see this as appropriate just now? In the past two years, no one has said a word about why we would wait so long for a church. Now that it’s very close to completion, though…

An old high school buddy sent me a message saying she wishes she could have a conversation with me about why Catholic before our final steps occur…

I get that some people view the Church as something to save people from, but man… I wish I could find words enough to share the healing I’ve found even in the early stages of my journey. A new definition to prayer and forgiveness and even a new perspective on the Passion of Christ. That feeling in Mass that must surely be the Real Presence. Finally having understanding of things that were unclear as I shifted from church to church seeking definition and authority.

The healing, though… I can’t tell you how powerful it is. I am an abuse survivor, enduring many unpleasant things in my youth that have made adult life challenging. Reaching a point where forgiving my abusers makes more sense than not… THAT is healing. I accomplished this as part of the past three years’ journey.

Anyways… very long post, sorry. Trying to understand why anyone would ask me these things… it’s not like I’ve ever heard anyone ask why any other religion… but maybe they do that too?

If you made it this far, thanks for reading. Keep us in your prayers as we prepare to finally complete this leg of the journey.
 
Easter 2014 came and went and all of our fellow RCIA classmates were welcomed into the church and we ‘sat on the sidelines’…
Been there and doing that! I started in Dec of 2013. For various reasons 2014 didn’t happen for me either. At first that was very hard to deal with, but it wasn’t long before I became determined and now I’m looking forward to *this *Easter Vigil. It’s been worth the effort.
Quite a few people have asked me questions about my conversion decision, but the one that strikes me as the most … frustrating?.. is this one.
***Why in the world would you want to become Catholic? ***

I wish I could find words enough to share the healing I’ve found even in the early stages of my journey. A new definition to prayer and forgiveness and even a new perspective on the Passion of Christ. That feeling in Mass that must surely be the Real Presence. Finally having understanding of things that were unclear as I shifted from church to church seeking definition and authority.
Yeah, I have run up against that same thing too. Most people who have asked that are not real interested in the answer(s). As a result, not too many people around me even know about my journey home and that’s OK with me. I have enough to do right now without having to constantly explain my decisions or launch into Catholic apologetics. However it sounds like you have a good answer to that in your own words (above)! Say that, then move on.
 
Welcome Home and may God bless you for your patience!

The world and the worldly will always be hostile to Christ and His Church. This should not surprise us.
 
Remember, our Lord Jesus Christ said “You will be hated because of me…” (Matt. 10:22)

You decide, but maybe your friend who asked you why in the world you would want to become Catholic can benefit from the book “Catholicism for Dummies”. 🙂
 
I admire your patience and persistence. Sometimes fallen away Catholics can be the most critical and anti-Catholic persons. Keep in mind your actions, words and prayers have a positive impact on some people.

Welcome and many blessings to you.

Mary

When I took the habit, the Lord immediately showed me how He favours those who do violence to themselves in order to serve Him. No one saw what I endured… At the moment of my entrance into this new state I felt a joy so great that it has never failed me even to this day; and God converted the dryness of my soul into a very great tenderness.
Saint Teresa of Avila
 
Welcome home! As someone who grew up Southern Baptist, I can certainly appreciate the questions you are getting. Here are a couple of things to keep in mind as you respond to these folks:
  1. The Catholic Church is the Church founded by Christ himself through the Apostles and their successors, and there is an unbroken line of succession that can be traced all the way back to St. Peter. Some may scoff at this, but if you read the early Church Fathers (some of whom knew the Apostles personally, if you go way back), their theology is instantly recognizable as that taught in the Catholic Church today. John Henry Newman, himself a former Protestant and harsh critic of the Catholic Church prior to his conversion, said, “To be deep in history is to cease to Protestant.”
  2. There is so much incorrect information about the Catholic Church taught to Protestants by other Protestants. Most Protestants who criticize/question you have never been to a Mass and only know what they have been told about our Faith by those who don’t practice it. Things I heard growing up were Catholics can’t pray directly to God, only through a priest, and Catholics worship Mary. Neither of these are true. Most of it comes not from malice but ignorance. It’s a great opportunity to correct these errors and increase understanding.
  3. Many Catholics who have left the Faith were poorly instructed in it while they were Catholics. They, too, are ignorant and left because they didn’t understand the why and wherefore of what the Church believes. Try not to let these folks persuade you. They don’t know any better.
  4. The best reason of all? We have the most personal relationship with Christ possible through the Eucharist. No one can be closer to the Lord than when they partake worthily of the Eucharist, because He is with us Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity at that very moment. This is a belief that can be traced all the way back to the Church Fathers and was only called into question by Martin Luther in the 1500s, a millennium and a half after Christ’s crucifixion.
Hope that helps!
 
For some people, they will think of anti-catholic stuff when getting similar question. But you can see it from another side: most of them are curious.

I was in the RCIA class, i got the same question and asked the same question. People are just curious, most of the people who asked wanted to be enlightened: hear a good testimony and each of convert does have interesting story.

[edited]
For (lukewarm) Catholics, you can be the one to renew their faith 🙂 and for those who are not Catholic, you can be the one to explain what Catholicism really is all about so they will not missunderstand the faith anymore.

When i’m asked why i chose Orthodoxy, i didn’t see it as anti-orthodox stuff, but as a chance to explain
[/edited]
 
  • if they are not going to accept or understand, it’s okay, i hope you won’t get upset 🙂 i know it can be annoying and frustration why they even feel the need to question, but patience is needed. If the questioner becomes upset, i usually say,“i feel your hatred and i’ll pray for you” 😃
A lot of people want to force us to believe what they believe
 
Remember, our Lord Jesus Christ said “You will be hated because of me…” (Matt. 10:22)

You decide, but maybe your friend who asked you why in the world you would want to become Catholic can benefit from the book “Catholicism for Dummies”. 🙂
Excellent suggestion! All too often ( thank you F. Sheen) people don’t really know what we believe but they sure hate what they think we believe. Get a copy of the book and keep it with you. Good source for qiuck answers when you need them and your brain goes blank.
 
"because it’s the only Church instituted by Christ Himself. "

End of story. There is no response to that. It’s a historical fact.
God bless you.
Anyone who can’t be happy fro you is not living whatever Christian faith they profess.

Be at peace, and welcome! 😉
 
Many wonderful answers so far. 👍

Not much I can add, but as I was reading the replies and thinking about that question, “Why in the world would you want to become Catholic?”, I started thinking, do non-Catholic Christians ask this same question of friends who switch from one protestant church to another?
For example, If they have a friend that switches from Nazarene to Church of Christ, or from Church of Christ to Lutheran, or from Lutheran to Methodist…do they ask, "Why in the world would you wan to become (fill in the blank)?

I get the sense that this doesn’t really happen much. Out of curiosity someone might ask why they are switching but not with the “…in the world…” added in.

Just thinking I guess…

As others have said, it’s up to you how - or even if - to respond to such questions, but I don’t’ think you can do any better than to share the things you have shared here. If anything, I think that these are the very things that your non-Catholic friends might understand better than any theological arguments. Peace, healing, the presence of Christ in the mass…these are the reasons to give them.

That’s my 2 cents worth…

Peace
James
 
Hi ZiggysGal. You stated that the co-worker who asked you this question was Catholic. Perhaps you could in a polite way ask her "Why in the world would you ever *leave *the Catholic Faith? Maybe, when she witnesses the transformation that has overcome you since your conversion, it will have a profound effect on her as well. And just maybe, it may nudge her to consider taking another look at the Catholic Church. As you yourself so beautifully stated; “I wish I could find words enough to share the healing I’ve found even in the early stages of my journey. A new definition to prayer and forgiveness and even a new perspective on the Passion of Christ. That feeling in Mass that must surely be the Real Presence.”

May God Bless You ZiggysGal!

Peace, Mark
 
In my pastor’s homily today, he mentioned something G.K. Chesterton once said. It went something along the lines of this:

I am Catholic for thousands of different reasons that all amount to one thing - the Catholic Church is true!

Basically, it can be very hard to explain why one is Catholic, because so many factors can go into one’s faith, but one fundamental reason why Catholics are (and everyone should be) Catholics is because the Catholic Church and its teachings are completely in line with reality, and therefore Truth, and no other earthly institution can (honestly) claim this! That in itself is amazing to me. It just doesn’t make sense to reject reality, so at the base of my faith is the Truth of the Catholic Church!
 
Why do people see this as appropriate just now?
Why do women tell pregnant women childbirth horror stories when they announce with joy they are pregnant? Why do people tell divorce stories to people announcing their engagement? Why do people tell horror stories about diets or exercise to people seeking encouragement to lose weight?

Why do people do insensitive, stupid things? Because they are people. Sinners. Imperfect.

IGNORE THEM.
 
I have been on both sides of this, so maybe my story will help. When I was much younger, I drove a carpool of my daughter and her friends to school. One day, one of the little girls (only a 7 grader) announced that she had decided to become Catholic! This girl and her family were Methodist, like me. I questioned her mother who said that this girl felt strongly called to Catholicism so they were letting her explore the faith! I hated Catholics- they were a cultish sect, in my opinion. I began to try to discourage the little girl, but she stood firm saying only that she felt that the Catholic Church would help her grow closer to God. I became extremely uncomfortable and felt that she wasn’t understanding the Methodist faith. After all, I was very close to God! 😃 As the little girl explored Catholicism, her parents joined her- and they became Catholic. They seemed to have found a treasure for they were filled with a peace- and I became livid. Every time I was around them, I would question their decision verbally ( and probably obnoxiously) but their peace persisted. Finally, I stealthily visited a Catholic Mass- by myself, didn’t even tell my family. Long story short, I felt called to RCIA and decided to explore the faith. I experienced hostile questions from my husband who was shocked :eek: as well as my brother and his wife, a former Catholic. Ultimately, I became a Catholic, as did my family and my brother’s family!! I now am an RCIA leader, and hear from a lot of people exploring the Catholic faith that the motivating factor that led them was the example of a good catholic friend or co-worker! So persist in your journey to join the church- and know that you are a witness leading others to the faith. Some of the more outspoken may also be experiencing a call that they are attempting to resist. Congratulations and welcome home. I will pray for you as you continue this journey!
 
Oh yes. I think we all have stories! One of my oldest and dearest friends, who had moved to Chicago, refused to be an annulment witness, after prayerfully considering it. She sent a long, well-thought out email about her reasons and our relationship has not been the same since, including her not attending my wedding.

Joining the Church, like becoming a mother, is a beautiful burden.
 
Thank you all for the replies. My husband and I were received into the church at Easter vigil and it is a significant blessing. It took so long and was no easy task to get here that I don’t really understand why anyone born (or led) to the church would choose anything else.

Then again, perhaps that is an additional blessing that came from our journey?

(We are Catholic now!)
 
Thank you all for the replies. My husband and I were received into the church at Easter vigil and it is a significant blessing. It took so long and was no easy task to get here that I don’t really understand why anyone born (or led) to the church would choose anything else.

Then again, perhaps that is an additional blessing that came from our journey?

(We are Catholic now!)
And may the Lord grant more blessings to you both!
 
Congrats! I am so happy that you and your husband decided to convert. Welcome home!
Just know that throughout your life there will be people who question your faith/conversion to the Church–some hostile, some out of sheer curiosity–and while at times it will be difficult to remain composed especially among someone who has hatred towards the Catholic Church, try to remain calm and answer their questions. Sometimes even just seeing this type of patience, kindness, and serenity is a wonderful representation of the Church and it’s people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top