1
1ke
Guest
Well, baptism imparts what the Church calls an ontological character. It’s permanent in nature. You are baptized and can never be un-baptized. When baptized into the Catholic Church, you are Catholic-- and under Catholic authority and canon law. And, you can’t be un-Catholic (no matter how hard you try!). It’s an onotological character.Perhaps this is where I’m stumbling - I certainly thought I had formally left, but perhaps this is not so?
Now, a Catholic can “defect” by committing apostacy, schims, or heresy. But, one is still Catholic. One can be reconciled by rejecting the error of the defection and returning via Confession. Some acts of defection include an automatic excommunication. But, people misunderstand excommunication. They think it means they are “kicked out” of the Church. This is not true. It is a canonical penalty that prohibits the reception of the Sacraemnts, holding of ecclesial offices, etc. It is meant to be a “wake up” to the Catholic that this is serious and they need to repent. All censures and canonical penalties are for this purpose-- to call the sinner to repentance.
Within Catholic canon law there are two types of defection mentioned:
Notorious defection
Formal defection
Both of these mean one has “left” the Church, but such a person is still Catholic and can return by means of reconciliation through the priest/bishop.
Notorious defection is what you did-- made a public act of joining a non-Catholic denomination. This has penalties associated under canon law for those who hold religious offices. It also would be considered either schism, heresy, or apostacy depending upon what type of religion (or none) one joins. This means one is barred from the Sacraments and there are possibly other automatic canonical penalties depending upon a host of factors. But, these penalties can be remedied via returning to the faith through the sacrament of reconcilitation, and any other paperwork the priest deems necessary.
Formal defection includes the formal writing of the Bishop to inform him of the decision to leave the faith, along with a convincing statement that the Catholic knows the serious nature of what they are doing, and it includes a “reception” of the defection from the Bishop. There is then a notation on the Baptismal record (sacramental records) that one has defected. The ONLY thing this does under canon law is remove the requirement for a Catholic to marry in the Catholic form of marriage. A person who has formally defected is still a Catholic and can be reconciled with the Church via a request to the Bishop to return.
I know you are finding this difficult to accept, but the Church is our Mother and we can never be anything other than her children. We are her children by rebirth in baptism just as you are your own biological mother’s son by natural birth-- even if you were to walk away from her and never have anything to do with her. You cannot change biological fact. Neither can we change the ontological fact that we are always Catholic once joined to the Catholic Church.
I hope you will find this comforting, that you may return, resume the sacramental life, and complete your sacraments of initiation by seeking Confirmation.