Receiving on the tongue and petty maladies

  • Thread starter Thread starter chevalier
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

chevalier

Guest
I’m not really smart about anything that’s close to medical. Suppose you have a cold, mild flue or some other petty malady. I’m obviously not talking about when your throat is bulging red but when you barely feel it or when you know you’ve only just got better. Is the risk already/still large enough to mean you shouldn’t go to Communion to avoid transferring your problem to others?

(On the side, what about meeting up with a friend for a coffee, going to a 1 on 1 business meeting or taking a dancing class?)
 
You can receive on the hand and I would think that would be appropriate when you might have something contagious like a flu. You can skip the wine, but they disinfect anyway between each person, if you have noticed.

Meeting with a friend and other non-religious things, I’m going to assume this isn’t a religious question, but I can tell you that when I worked for a big corporation, even though our office would insist we come in to work when we had the flu anyway, our office received out of town hand outs that were passed among us by corporation directives distinctly telling us NOT to show up with something contagious and to take a sick day. The underlying thought is that if you have something contagious and stay home, then you don’t pass it to forty other people who will then be sick and might miss work.

I’d say pass on sharing a flu with others if you can, generally. I’d certainly warn them if I did share a meal with them that I was sick and I would hope they would warn me, lol.
 
The answer is…use your common sense. If you have a cold or don’t feel well…stay home. Most colds are airborne as well as contagious from touching. at least, don’t drink from the Cup while you are ill. Ministers of the Eucharist (lay and clerical) need to use common sense as well. I am a miniser of the Eucharist. We keep a bottle of antibacterial lotion in the sacristy. They are also placed at all entries of the church for anyone to use. a good idea especially during flu season.
 
I’m not really smart about anything that’s close to medical. Suppose you have a cold, mild flue or some other petty malady. I’m obviously not talking about when your throat is bulging red but when you barely feel it or when you know you’ve only just got better. Is the risk already/still large enough to mean you shouldn’t go to Communion to avoid transferring your problem to others?

(On the side, what about meeting up with a friend for a coffee, going to a 1 on 1 business meeting or taking a dancing class?)
Catching colds is good to strengthen your defences. You coould use a mask like the Japanese do.
 
I’m not really smart about anything that’s close to medical. Suppose you have a cold, mild flue or some other petty malady. I’m obviously not talking about when your throat is bulging red but when you barely feel it or when you know you’ve only just got better. Is the risk already/still large enough to mean you shouldn’t go to Communion to avoid transferring your problem to others?

(On the side, what about meeting up with a friend for a coffee, going to a 1 on 1 business meeting or taking a dancing class?)
If you are sick you do not have to attend Mass. The obligation is dispensed with and it is not a sin.
Frankly, anyone with a cold or flu or anything that is contagious should stay away from crowds, including Mass. I’m almost tempted to say it might be a sin to attend Mass when you are sick knowing there is a high probability that you will pass on the cold or flu to other people.
 
If you are sick you do not have to attend Mass. The obligation is dispensed with and it is not a sin.
I think we would properly say that there is no obligation. A dispensation is a type of permission from a priest. When one is ill, one needs no permission to stay home from Mass.
 
I think we would properly say that there is no obligation. A dispensation is a type of permission from a priest. When one is ill, one needs no permission to stay home from Mass.
No need to be pendantic. It was an expression that everyone understood.
No obligation means the obligation is automatically dispensed with.
 
May be it’s a cultural thing but I wouldn’t advise anyone to stay away from Mass, work, etc. because of a cold. I’ve noticed a lot on here that Americans generally advise about staying away from other people and not passing it on. In the UK most people wouldn’t stay away from Mass, stay off work, miss school, etc. for a cold.

Now flu is a different thing. It is very misunderstood. If you really have flu then no one needs to advise you to stay away. You will simply be too ill to go if you really have flu rather than just a very bad cold.
 
There is always the option between missing mass and taking communion.

Go to mass but make a spiritual communion. You only need to receive communion one time per year, in the Easter season.
 
The old maxim - It is more blessed to give than to receive - does not apply to germs etc. 😃
 
Sometimes it is hard to tell the difference between allergies and a cold. Or sometimes it feels like a cold is “coming on” but it’s not really there yet. Or the cold is mostly over, and you feel fine, but you still are coughing a little bit. There are times when it is not easy to decide if you’re sick enough because you’re not blowing your nose constantly, and not coughing and sneezing a lot (these things would be enough to stay home). In those in-between times, it is only courteous to what you can to prevent others from catching whatever germs you are still shedding. Whether or not it is good for the people around you to catch your germs is not really your judgment to make, and it is respectful to err on the side of caution. In those cases, you can use a little hand sanitizer and then receive communion in the hand.

I admit to being a little germ phobic, and I hate shaking people’s hands at the kiss of peace, and then having to receive without washing my hands, especially when those people were sniffling and coughing throughout Mass. The swine flu season, and a few too many stomach bugs really did a number on my stress about catching unnecessary illnesses. So sometime before the kiss of peace, I discreetly open a little handi-wipe (individually wrapped package), and clean my own hands. Since I have allergies, it is common for me to blow my nose even when I’m perfectly healthy, but that doesn’t mean people want to touch the hands that held the dirty tissues. Then I keep the wipe in my left hand until after the kiss of peace, and I use it again, just before receiving. This might seem a little too much for some people, but worrying about giving or getting yucky germs unnecessarily is a distraction that I don’t need during Mass, and this reduces it.
 
I’m not really smart about anything that’s close to medical. Suppose you have a cold, mild flue or some other petty malady. I’m obviously not talking about when your throat is bulging red but when you barely feel it or when you know you’ve only just got better. Is the risk already/still large enough to mean you shouldn’t go to Communion to avoid transferring your problem to others?

(On the side, what about meeting up with a friend for a coffee, going to a 1 on 1 business meeting or taking a dancing class?)
not sure I understand the question
if you are sick with something contagious stay home and away from people, simply Christian charity and common courtesy demands it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top