Removing Filioque from the Creed

  • Thread starter Thread starter mardukm
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I have to say, I like the specific Latinate words like “conglorified”, “consubstantial”, etc.

I would be interested in seeing how this variant historically developed.

Thanks for posting, Patrick.
This is very true for us in 2010. We had to borrow from the Latin in order to make these concepts work in English. And maybe it can be better understood if we break it up as follows into sets of possible meanings:

con {“with, together”}
  • sub {“under, inferior, secondary, less than, in place of, secretly”}
  • stantis (past participle of stare {“to stand as, to be”})
  • vernacular ending
so “consubstantial with the Father” makes better sense in my opinion than “one in substance with the Father” and certainly “one in being with the Father.”

A similar breakdown for “conglorified” can also be made.
 
Dear brother Patrick,

This is certainly a revelation! The usual non-Catholic rhetoric is that Henry II was trying to force the introduction of filioque into the creed, and the Pope gave in. What you have written here changes the whole matter. But if the issue was really the introduction of the Creed itself into public worship, it would seem that the Pope was simply introducing the Creed as already regularly used by the Latins, not that he introduced filioque into the Creed of Rome for the first time.

Just some thoughts.

Blessings
Actually, it was both: Henry II tried to convince the Pope to include the Creed, with the Filioque, into the recitation of the Roman Mass. Benedict VIII was an able warrior (for instance, he allied himself with the Normans who settled in Italy and orchestrated the defeat of the invading Saracens in Sardinia), but he was not much interested in ecclesiastical affairs. He was in debt to Henry, who helped restore Benedict to his see when the latter was opposed by an antipope, Gregory VI (1012), and thus paid lip service to reform to gain favor with the emperor.
 
I’m sure the Eastern Catholics didn’t mean it this way, but it seems to across as an insult to Roman Catholic theology. I mean, since Eastern Catholics and Roman Catholics belong to the one Catholic Church, our faith is mutually the same (admittedly with differences in emphases and terminology). So the* filioque* should be doctrinally translatable into Eastern theology, no?
How can it be an insult when the Supreme Roman Pontiff himself is telling the Eastern Catholics to remove the Filioque? I think its been mentioned earlier in this thread, from the Latin perspective the Filioque makes perfect sense. But not from the Greek. And the Eastern Churches came from the Greek, they translated the Filioque from Greek, not Latin. Even their philosophy is Greek.

The Filioque is not forces the same way as Original Sin and Purgatory is not forced into Eastern Catholics. The Entrance of the Theotokos to the Temple is a major feast in the Byzantine Rite both Catholic and Orthodox, even though the Roman Church has never accepted the tradition found in the Protoevangelium of James. There are many things the Eastern Catholics do that are more Orthodox than Roman Catholic. Its false to assume that Eastern Catholics are nothing more than Roman Catholics following the Byzantine Rite Liturgy.
 
Thanks. I think I understand your point and concern.

My own perception is that “triumphalism” is more a concern, realistically, for the West rather than the East.

And, as the Catholic Church in dialogue with the Orthodox recognize that no theological barriers exist regarding the “filioque” (see e.g. usccb.org/seia/filioque.shtml) I really don’t see a need for any new creed.
The problem I think is as long as there is a difference in creeds, there will be those who will make an issue of it. I’d rather have one universal creed that is word-for-word the same everywhere. I know this is catering to the petty, but to foster unity we should try to resolve the issues and leave as less doubt as possible.
 
The Filioque IS a teaching of the Latin Church and many other Latin teachings have this as a basis. This is not a simple one-word removal for us to even be discussing.
The theology behind doesn’t need to change. Besides, shouldn’t a traditionalist like yourself adhere to the traditional, and that is the Creed without a Filioque? Wouldn’t from the traditionalist perspective see the Filioque as a modern innovation?
 
Dear brother Vince,

Can you please exlain what you mean here?
I mean just what I said. The West seems more prone to triumphalism than the East.
In case you did not know, the theological commission has no authoritative standing within EO’xy. It is indeed a hopeful sign, but until there is official recognition of its contents from the EOC, I maintain that removal of filioque would do more damage than good.
Of course. I know that. My point was simply to indicate how theological discussions are ongoing between Catholics and Orthodox, and the “filioque” clause of the Creed is not necessarily a barrier to unity.
 
The problem I think is as long as there is a difference in creeds, there will be those who will make an issue of it. I’d rather have one universal creed that is word-for-word the same everywhere. I know this is catering to the petty, but to foster unity we should try to resolve the issues and leave as less doubt as possible.
I agree
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top