Resurrection: the most plausible alternatives

  • Thread starter Thread starter pneuma07
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
In my year at CAF, I have never witnessed such obtuse troll baiting in my life. Mind has been blown!
 
You said, as someone claiming to be a “Christian,” you are able to entertain the thought that there are plausible alternatives to the resurrection of Christ.
Yes, I just haven’t heard one yet. But one might be out there that I’ve never heard (though I really doubt it).

I think the most plausible alternative is that Jesus didn’t really die on the Cross (but this only works if the Apostles all thought he did). If the soldier had not used his spear then I think I could construct a plausible (though unlikely) alternative scenario which fits the known facts. But that spear gets in the way every time.
I say no plausible explanations exist. If you ever think you thought of one, I would love to hear it.
Figure out how someone who is hanging on a cross plausibly survives getting stabbed by a Roman spear and I will tell you one.
Christ followers are called to the truth and not to entertain fantastical alternatives to the truth.
And you say this in an apologetics forum? Are you kidding me??? We deal with fanciful alternatives to the truth all the time (it’s what we do here).
I know my wife. I never question her existence.
And I know mine. But there were alternatives. I had always wanted to study engineering at Georgia Tech - and I was accepted. But, had I gone, it would have ended our relationship (which, at the time, was not very serious). I chose her (and it’s the best decision I ever made).
 
**You said, as someone claiming to be a “Christian,” you are able to entertain the thought that there are plausible alternatives to the resurrection of Christ. **
Yes, I just haven’t heard one yet. But one might be out there that I’ve never heard (though I really doubt it).
You say you are a Christian, but you accept that there may yet be a plausible alternative to God being true?

How is this possible? :confused:
I think the most plausible alternative is that Jesus didn’t really die on the Cross (but this only works if the Apostles all thought he did). If the soldier had not used his spear then I think I could construct a plausible (though unlikely) alternative scenario which fits the known facts. But that spear gets in the way every time.
The spear is the only thing that gets in the way for you from accepting it is plausible that Christ is a fraud and did not die His sacrificial death?

Those who have met the risen Lord today never can accept that it would be plausible that our Lord is a fraud.

It sounds like you are not really sure of what you are actually saying here, so I will just assume that.
**Christ followers are called to the truth and not to entertain fantastical alternatives to the truth. **
And you say this in an apologetics forum? Are you kidding me??? We deal with fanciful alternatives to the truth all the time (it’s what we do here).
And Christ followers should never accept that any of those fantasies are plausible.

This is what I said earlier.

How can the Christ follower, as he/she already knows otherwise?
**I know my wife. I never question her existence. **
And I know mine.
Do you question her existence?

…
 
You say you are a Christian, but you accept that there may yet be a plausible alternative to God being true?
I am both a Christian and an apologist. I would consider (and counter) any argument that questioned the existence of God (although this is a very broad topic, and is not really on-topic for this thread). However, if someone presented me with irrefutable evidence that God could not possibly exist, then I would cease to believe in God.

I am easily persuaded by irrefutable evidence, although I have encountered it only once (namely, in the Catholic Church).
The spear is the only thing that gets in the way for you from accepting it is plausible that Christ is a fraud and did not die His sacrificial death?
Yes. If not for that spear, I could construct a plausible (though unlikely) alternate scenario in which Jesus was actually a deluded insane person who completely tricked the Apostles. This scenario would include the possibility that Jesus was lightly scourged (which is not typically represented in modern cinema, but is not contradicted by the Bible). And it would include the possibility that Jesus was still alive when the Roman soldier stabbed him with his spear - and require that the injury was very light. That’s the big problem; Roman soldiers were trained to make a deep thrust into vital organs. It is very non-plausible that a trained Roman soldier could not render a fatal thrust against an immobile target.

However, had Jesus been lightly scourged, and the Roman captain had been completely incompetent, it is plausible (though unlikely) that Jesus could have survived the Cross. Because both of these conditions are unlikely to be true (especially the second), I regard this alternate account as very implausible (ie, unlikely). However, if some evidence surfaced that Roman soldiers (at that time) were very restrained in their scourgings and many were completely untrained in the use of the spear, this alternative would become much more plausible.

The ONLY reason why I cannot advance a plausible alternative explanation is because Roman soldiers were very adept at killing people - they conquered the known world by employing this skill. Had the captain of the guard simply pronounced Jesus dead by visual observation (without using his spear) then I could make a case for a plausible alternate scenario which conforms to the known facts. That spear (wielded by a trained Roman soldier) is the ONLY thing that separates my theoretical account from a plausible (though unlikely) account.

But, even if we discovered that Roman soldiers of that time were gentle and incompetent (thus giving rise to a plausible alternate scenario), I would still believe that Jesus actually suffered and died for my sins. I would freely admit that there was a plausible alternate explanation, but I would continue to support and defend the doctrine of the Church (although, I must admit, it would introduce a refreshingly new challenge to consider - sometimes it seems like those of us who participate in the CAF apologetic forum are simply a broken record, saying the same thing over and over and over again).
 
The most plausible alternative in my estimation is that Gospels are essentially midrash or the retelling of Old Testament events applied to the life of Christ by his followers 40 or so years after his death. The problem is Paul, writing earlier, knows about the resurrection. Although there are details given through Paul not contained in the Gospels. That essentially leads to the theory that his earliest followers understand his resurrection in symbolic terms.
 
I lol’d at the “Jesus had a secret twin brother separated at birth” one. That was good. It would be hard to never be seen again after his ascension (maybe he got all the apostles tripping on mushrooms or used some post-hypnotic suggestion on them). Maybe he sailed over to America and did his bit with the American Indians, and Joseph Smith was right all along. 👍

To you lot getting up in arms over this, I don’t think anyone here is actually saying “We don’t believe Christ is the Son of God and thus was able to defeat death.” Just enjoy the plausible explanations, yeesh!
 
The most plausible alternative in my estimation is that Gospels are essentially midrash or the retelling of Old Testament events applied to the life of Christ by his followers 40 or so years after his death. The problem is Paul, writing earlier, knows about the resurrection. Although there are details given through Paul not contained in the Gospels. That essentially leads to the theory that his earliest followers understand his resurrection in symbolic terms.
Hi Rightlydivide ! Thanks for reminding this quite popular line of explanation. One of the difficulties which are presented against this proposal, is that the Resurrection tales in the Gospels do not contain theological reflection, as you could expect about the description of such a foundational and fictional event elaborated 40 years afterward. Much has also been said about choosing women as the first witnesses. As to a mere symbolic resurrection as the earliest belief, there seem to be good hints that this was not Paul’s teaching. Eg in his essential Creed in 1 Cor 15 he states that Christ was buried just before stating His Resurrection, impling a strong link between the two. Moreover Paul sees baptism as our own “resurrection” We were therefore buried with him through baptism into death in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead through the glory of the Father, we too may live a new life. Romans 6. In baptism the body is “buried” into the water and comes out of that, therefore that appears to point to a belief in a bodily Resurrection of Christ. P7
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top