Review: Sword Art Online

  • Thread starter Thread starter AndrewRaZ
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

AndrewRaZ

Guest
Sword Art Online

Sword Art Online is one of the best anime series I have yet seen—or at least the first half is. It fuses drama, action, and fantastic production values in a universe that is really engaging. As a Christian, it is nice to see some themes that I can agree with as well, especially in a media that so frequently objectifies people for a cheap thrill.

Plot:

(minor spoilers)
Sword Art Online (SAO) is based on a light novel series, and succeeded in some ways by Accel World,. SAO is about a Virtual Reality Massively-Multiplayer Online RPG, made possible by the brand new NERV Gear, which translates thoughts into the game. But the game’s designer removes the logout and adds the feature that if the headset is removed or if one dies in the game, one dies in real life. SAO ceases to be a game and becomes a real and dangerous war in a fantasy world where the main protagonist, Kirito, feels responsible for protecting other players. Episodes 1-14 take place in SAO where the villain is the game’s creator. Episodes 15-25 take place in a combination of real world and a spin-off game called Alfheim Online where the villain is pretty much the epitome of creepy evil, the kind everyone loves to hate.

Production values:

The art is gorgeous, bright, and colorful. The animation is fluid and expressive. The characters are well designed. The costumes are practical, and they really try to avoid the half-naked skimpy female costumes, mostly (but not entirely). The music was pretty good, but honestly, I didn’t pay much attention. The voice acting is superb in Japanese. If you can handle the English, great, but the original Japanese is better.

Romance:

The romance in SAO is really the driving force of the story. But unlike other stories, Kirito and Asuna don’t hook up at the end—they get together relatively quickly, and it is their continuing relationship that drives the story. Unlike other “damsel in distress” tropes, the first half establishes Asuna as a strong female character able to hold her own. Part of the reason they work so well together is that they are a partnership of equals.

One of the great things about this storyline was an exploration of a digital relationship within the SAO world. At one point, Kirito remarks that what one does in the game affects one’s soul and rejects the temptation to act however he wishes within the game. This is a core of Christian moral theology which involves intention and will, and really cuts to the heart of the “it’s just a game” idea. Kirito and Asuna feel that as much as they love each other, they are unwilling to reduce their love to mere sexual intimacy.

Instead, they get married in the game, and adopt a daughter, Yui. Their love instinctually forms the basis of a family, and the conflicts that arise force them to react not only for selfish preservation, but in order to protect the members of their family. What is more, even when Kirito is freed from the game, he still feels bound by the vows he made in game to protect his family and willingly faces danger again in order to protect them. Even the inevitable “woman offers herself to the guy” scene is turned upside down: Kirito insists she has misunderstood, and that he only wants to “be by her side.” I can’t tell you how refreshing it is to see this kind of treatment of relationships and female characters. It really bespeaks St. Paul’s words, “Husbands, love your wives as Christ loved the Church and gave himself up for her” (Eph 5:25).

Christian Themes:

Kirito is in many ways a figure of Christ in the series. He is an image of masculine strength and courage in the face of adversity, and yet the vulnerability of suffering. He endures the hatred of other players so that he can protect them. He refuses to infringe on other players’ rights to choose for themselves, but is also a strong advocate of justice in the game. He is also willing to die that others might live (though it’s portrayed as stubbornness or even prideful rebellion against the Game Master rather than an act of love). Complimenting Kirito, Asuna could be seen as a figure of the Church, who is devoted to her spouse and fiercely devoted to her family. Being tricked into the game and unable to escape and told to make use of any means necessary, which some players do resort to, brings to mind references to the Garden of Eden and the fall of Man. The theme which is brought up a couple times of a “true self” which transcends simple bodies and depends not only on material actions but on intention reminds us that our attitudes are in need of conversion and the discipline of virtue. SAO certainly does not have Christian storyline, but one can see some analogies.

(continued)
 
Cons:

While Sword Art Online is one of the best anime series I’ve seen, it does have some downsides. First, the second season (episodes 15-25) is much weaker than the first season. Asuna becomes a powerless damsel, Kirito really has no character growth (he enters Alfheim with his high stats from SAO, making him unstoppable), and in general, there is no character development in the second series. There is also one scene involving scantily-clad women throwing themselves at Kirito (a reversal of the strong women theme developed in the first season), and Asuna gets attacked by some tentacle creatures, making references to certain less virtuous anime. There is also quite a bit of violence that, while not gory, may be troubling for younger viewers, especially with so many deaths in the series. I would rate it TV-14.

Conclusion:

Overall, I would give Sword Art Online 4.5 out of 5 stars. The weak second season, a few suggestive themes, and a reliance on violence weigh down its good record. But with outstanding art, a truly powerful first season and engaging romance spanning over two seasons, in addition to the Christian analogies sprinkled throughout make it a great choice for anime fans. I look forward to the forthcoming third season coming out soon.
 
Summary : One of the best anime in years!

Good review, though I haven’t been able to watch season 2 yet T_T the first season, however, was easily one of the best anime of the last decade. Asuna and Kirito are also one of the most believable couples I’ve ever seen in an anime, and I loved watching them grow together!
 
I’m a big fan of this series as well. It’s probably more suited for late teens and up, especially those who play MMO games similar to the setting of this game (such as World of Warcraft, Dungeons & Dragons Online, and others), who will enjoy the many in-jokes and similaries of SAO to their “real” games.

Parents should also be mindful of the love interest’s marriage (they are under the age of 18). Although they are in a virtual world, they are also in a virtual marriage, so that’s a theological pickle you should relate to family members. The show plays a tiny bit with sexual themes (as noted by the OP), primarily issues of modesty and accidental touching due to accident, not ill virtue, but does tend to sexualize younger teen females more than Western animation (underwear scenes once in a while, blurred nudity in a brief shower).

A specific game guild uses crosses on their member’s gear and armor. This is not uncommon to see in Japanese animation (see TV Tropes’ take on Anime Catholicism) which often does not “get” Christianity theology or symbology, but, like Westerners to Eastern philosophy and religions, often “spice” it up or brand a version for themselves, never mind any accuracy of interpretation, simply because its “cool” to their worldview.

One notable scene of charity is of one young woman who chose to stay on the beginning level of the game and to gather up children who were logged in and likely would not survive in game-play. It doesn’t seem as if anyone asked her to do this, making her work quite pious and generous. The young woman cares for dozens of kids in a church structure, keeping them fed and happy and protected until they are all able to leave the game. The young woman is dressed in conservative clothing that suggests a nun-like role, but again, Japanese culture often transposes vowed religious appearances in Christianity for something else. Still, it’s a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it part of an episode that was heartwarming to me amidst other good moments of the series.

CA members that are also video gamers can enjoy my game-specific review of this program on this link of my blog.
 
An official SAO thread on CAF!? OH HAPPY DAY!!! 8D

I haven’t fully read your review but so far the only disagreement I have is about the second season. Yes, you’re right to point out that it’s relatively weaker but I think you’re leaving out the part where good still wins over extreme evil. The villain in the second season got served in ways I wish more troll characters would die.

Seriously what is up with some people and liking the trolling types?

Anyways, I hope to God they animate the third arc GGO. I finished it right after finishing the anime. The sad part about it is that Asuna doesn’t get a lot of screen time again but the new female lead has got waaaaaaaaaaaaaay more substance than Sugu/Lyfa. Shino/Sinon is actually one of the few female characters I love in a non-fanboy way. I really can’t help but relate to her and her attitude towards games.
 
Parents should also be mindful of the love interest’s marriage (they are under the age of 18). Although they are in a virtual world, they are also in a virtual marriage, so that’s a theological pickle you should relate to family members.
Good points Spencerian. I forgot to mention the age. I honestly didn’t remember the shower scene. Other Christian elements (accurately used or not) do abound. Like you pointed out, it’s not all used correctly from an actual Christian perspective, but it is good to see some parallels. “Seeds of the Word,” St. Justin said.
I enjoyed your review too. I probably didn’t get many of the gaming references in the series, but I got enough to laugh hard enough to draw attention sometimes.
Anyways, I hope to God they animate the third arc GGO. I finished it right after finishing the anime.
Lost Wanderer: I said above that season 3 (or 2, depending on how you count them) is coming out soon. That seems to be rumor, unfortunately. It’s a persistent rumor, though. I don’t read Japanese, so I can’t do much digging. I’m hoping to have time to read the novels at some point, but I have no time during the semester. I hope they do animate some more of the series though!
 
I got into the series through Netflix on Monday, and I am blown away by how good the story line is! The characters are genuinely believable, and the depths to which the storyline can go grabbed me again and again! Admittedly, there were rougher moments (two involved female characters in their underwear, and a shower, as some have pointed out, but opening up a tab and waiting for it to go by helps; Two-three instances of God’s name paired with a curse word happen, but they’re at pretty memorable scenes, so muting at the right moment is easy, too.), but the overall story is one of sacrifice, selfless bravery, discovering what real love asks of us, and showing that every decision we make affects us and the ones around us. I haven’t seen anything like this show in a long while, and I recommend it whole-heartedly!

(SPOILER AHEAD!) The 2nd story arc, in my mind, gave a lot more gravitas to the story. The villain was more menacing, and a genuine threat to both the hero and everyone else. The knife attack by Sugou at the season 1 finale episode really solidified how dementedly evil he was, and how it ended showed how Kasuto had finally managed to get his full grip on reality, even when it would have been so easy to take the life of the perverted narcissist who tormented him and Asuna.

And I think the sub-plot between Suguha and Kasuto was something I hadn’t expected. In a strange way, it was almost a reverse Cyrano de Bergerac. She had to realize putting his happiness before her own could help her find a happiness she didn’t expect.
 
I got into the series through Netflix on Monday, and I am blown away by how good the story line is! The characters are genuinely believable, and the depths to which the storyline can go grabbed me again and again! Admittedly, there were rougher moments (two involved female characters in their underwear, and a shower, as some have pointed out, but opening up a tab and waiting for it to go by helps; Two-three instances of God’s name paired with a curse word happen, but they’re at pretty memorable scenes, so muting at the right moment is easy, too.), but the overall story is one of sacrifice, selfless bravery, discovering what real love asks of us, and showing that every decision we make affects us and the ones around us. I haven’t seen anything like this show in a long while, and I recommend it whole-heartedly!

(SPOILER AHEAD!) The 2nd story arc, in my mind, gave a lot more gravitas to the story. The villain was more menacing, and a genuine threat to both the hero and everyone else. The knife attack by Sugou at the season 1 finale episode really solidified how dementedly evil he was, and how it ended showed how Kasuto had finally managed to get his full grip on reality, even when it would have been so easy to take the life of the perverted narcissist who tormented him and Asuna.

And I think the sub-plot between Suguha and Kasuto was something I hadn’t expected. In a strange way, it was almost a reverse Cyrano de Bergerac. She had to realize putting his happiness before her own could help her find a happiness she didn’t expect.
Just so you know: over two years have passed since the last post in this thread, so most of the posters are likely departed from the conversation by now.
 
I figured as much, but I felt like adding to the thread when I found it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top