Samaritan Woman at the well

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jennifer_J
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Jennifer_J

Guest
I have a question about the Samaritan woman Jesus meets at the well in John 4. I have recently been told that this scripture refers to her worshiping to several gods and not about her having 5 husbands and living with someone not her husband. :eek: Any insights into this? How do we translate the word HUSBAND in this passage?

Thanks
 
After reading John 4, it seems that it is refering the husband in the literal sense. I don’t see any reason to look at it differently, but I’m open to other viewpoints.
 
Husband is translated as husband. The woman’s sin was having more than one common law husband who were not validly married to her. She was still “living in sin” with her latest “husband” as we Catholics would say.

Samaritans worship Jehovah, same as the Hebrews. However, they took on different rituals, split from the Jews over certain doctrines and had a different locus of worship (not Jeruselem). They were not polythiestic or pagan. They would be to Judaism what, say, Pentacostals are to Catholics. I’m afraid you’ve been misinformed about the Samaritan woman.

You may want to look up the verses on the Samaritan woman at the well and check your footnotes on those passages.

Mike
 
That’s what I thought! This was a letter to the editor in our local “Catholic” paper. I’m trying to formulate a response to this letter, which was praising a “women’s issues” series given by a Sister. Apparently, the sister stated this in her talk! It doesn’t surprise me that she made it up.

I tried looking up any notes in my bible, and there weren’t any pertaining to “husband” that’s why I needed to ask.
 
Jennifer J:
I have a question about the Samaritan woman Jesus meets at the well in John 4. I have recently been told that this scripture refers to her worshiping to several gods and not about her having 5 husbands and living with someone not her husband. :eek: Any insights into this? How do we translate the word HUSBAND in this passage?

Thanks
This is one of my favorite Biblical stories. The essence of the story is that she was a woman not of faith (Samaritan/not Jewish) and was living an immoral life devoid of God. Jesus didn’t talk to her w/ high theology or condemn her for her life. He talked to her on her level and where was today in her faith journey (not very far 🙂 ) and then he addressed her need deep in her heart for greater meaning (living water).

Although she didn’t fully grasp the magnitude of what had happened to her (conversion), she was able to go forth, witness Christ and take future steps on her faith journey to Christ.
 
Jennifer J:
I have a question about the Samaritan woman Jesus meets at the well in John 4. I have recently been told that this scripture refers to her worshiping to several gods and not about her having 5 husbands and living with someone not her husband. :eek: Any insights into this? How do we translate the word HUSBAND in this passage?

Thanks
It’s a play on words. It ends up with a double meaning. While she did have 5 husbands, the Samaritans had the same word for husband as they did for one of their gods: Baal.

When the 10 Northern tribes were carried off into the pagan nations, the pagans in those areas were also brought in to replace the population. Thus Samaritans are a cross between pagans and Judaism, which is why the Jews hated them so much.

The pagans had 5 Baals. So when Jesus tells her you have had 5 Baals/husbands, He is addressing her personally, and the Samaritans misguided worship of not worshipping the One True God.
 
This is from Scott Hahn:

One interesting fact that you might not be aware of – what is the Hebrew word for husband? There are different words, but one very common word for husband is Baal. Interesting, isn’t it? You see, there were two different kinds of marriages in the Old Testament. You can see this reflected in Galatians, chapter 4, where Paul says, “You desire to be under the law. Don’t you hear the law, for it is written that Abraham had two sons, one by a slave and one by a free woman.” You see he had two sons because he had what? Two marriages: One by a slave woman, Hagar, and one by a free woman. But the son of the slave was born according to the flesh, the son of the free woman through promise. Then he goes on to show how Hagar, the slave wife, the concubine, bore Ishmael and how Sarah, the free wife, the first wife, the only wife Abraham was supposed to have, bore Isaac, the child of promise.

You see, back in the ancient times, if you were a husband, if you were a man, you were a patriarchal figure and you wanted to extend your own power and influence, you wanted to acquire more power, you used sex. You would multiply concubines because in multiplying wives or concubine slave women, you would be multiplying slaves, because all of the children they would have would be, in effect, your slaves later on. So Hagar bore children for slavery, whereas Sarah bore Abraham children for freedom. Sarah would address Abraham as “'adon,” the word for husband in Hebrew that a free woman would utter; whereas Hagar would describe Abraham as “Ba’ali,” my “Baal,” my master, my Lord husband, because a concubine understood that she was owned by her husband. So there were two forms of marriage – one for freedom and the other one for slavery.
Code:
That woman had a tragic series of unfortunate marriages, but she began to see through the eyes of faith how her own struggles with immorality, perhaps, with the abuse by men or whatever other problems that she faced, that reality of her own life was providentially tailored, designed by God to prepare her to recognize Christ. Many interpreters suppose that when Jesus said, "And the one you are with now is not your own husband," that that supposes that she is sleeping with a man. That isn't necessarily all that the text is suggesting. The idea is probably, at least in my opinion, that you've had five husbands and the one you're with right now, that is me, I'm not your husband.
He’s meeting her at a well. In the Old Testament, do you know enough of the Old Testament to recognize what often takes place at a well? You meet your spouse-to-be; you meet your future spouse. That’s where Isaac’s future spouse was first encountered. That’s where Jacob meets his wife. That’s where Moses meets his wife. Throughout the Old Testament, the well is a meeting place where you meet your future husband.

Here is this Samaritan woman meeting Jesus and he points out how you have five husbands and she sees that. And then He says, “But the one you are with now is not your husband.” Not yet, at least. And she recalls the prophecy. She vividly remembers how all the prophets said that you are going to have these five Baals until the Messiah comes, “the prophet like unto Moses.” And Hosea and Ezekiel both describe how the Lord will send this prophet Messiah and He will betroth himself to the Samaritans, not as the Baals did, not as a taskmaster, not as a Lord Master does a slave woman, but as a free man marries a free woman to bear children for freedom, for responsibility. That’s why she says, “Sir, I perceive you are a prophet. You are a prophet like unto Moses.” You are a Messianic figure.

Notworthy
 
Wow, thank you Scott Hahn (and Notworthy)! What book/lecture is this in? I’d like to read it! So I suppose the sister wasn’t completely off base, but perhaps presented it a questionable way? Thanks again!
 
Jennifer J:
Wow, thank you Scott Hahn (and Notworthy)! What book/lecture is this in? I’d like to read it! So I suppose the sister wasn’t completely off base, but perhaps presented it a questionable way? Thanks again!
Ditto! I never heard or read that interpretation before. Thanks for posting.

Mike
 
I’m looking! I’m looking!

I can’t find the web-site (I’ve got way too many bookmarks!), but luckily I downloaded the entire presentation. Send me an IM and I’ll e-mail it as it’s way too big to post here.

Notworthy
 
Sounds like she would have to go through 5 or 6 annulments before she could be let in the crowd.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top