Scruple or what?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ae22
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

ae22

Guest
Hi!

First, a bit of information about myself. I was baptized as an infant, went to CCD as a child and got my first communion, but fell away from the Church after that. My parents aren’t really religious at all. I had my share of struggles and sin during my teenage years and young adulthood. A few years ago, I began praying and asking God to direct me where He wanted me to go. Long story short, now I’m back in the Church, as of fairly recently. I had a dream, and in that dream Jesus appeared and told me to return to the Church. So, I ran with His advice.

Since coming back, I’ve become increasingly agitated with myself. I’ve always been a perfectionist, and it’s certainly no exception when I am working to not disappoint God rather than simply trying not to disappoint myself or others. I’ve been going to confession every week, and I’ve always had at least one thing that’s definitely a venial sin to confess (and sometimes, like last week, a mortal sin). However, I try to hold myself to a higher standard than what’s “required”. For example, on Good Friday, rather than eating one meatless meal and two snacks, I ate nothing (I wasn’t sure whether I should have gone up and received, since it would break my voluntary penance to do so, but I did). Although praying the rosary isn’t “required”, I try to pray all twenty mysteries rather than just the five daily mysteries that are supposed to be prayed.

Some days, I just don’t feel well (I’ve been dealing with some sort of mystery ailment for a little while, it affects my stomach as well as my energy level, leaving me with no energy at all to do anything). On these days, I don’t pray as much as I probably should. On other days, I try to “make up” for it. I’m constantly asking myself “am I doing enough to help the poor? Am I doing enough to help out at my parish? Am I spending enough time in front of the blessed sacrament? Am I concentrating enough in prayer?”…it often takes me a very long time to pray the rosary because, if I am not meditating well enough on the mysteries, I apologize profusely to Mary and start over. I often do this multiple times.

I only work part-time, and bring home $150 on a good week. I really can’t afford much…but I put a minimum of 10% of my income in the collection plate each week. But, even then, I think to myself “could I have put in more? Am I being greedy? I am putting myself before the Lord! I am totally unlike the widow about whom Jesus spoke in the temple, who put the only two copper coins she owned into the treasury!”…I try to concentrate fully during Mass, but sometimes my mind wanders. I think to myself “I am selfishly thinking about unimportant things rather than giving my full attention to the greatest gift ever given to humanity!”…so even if I go to confession RIGHT BEFORE Mass, I’m still uneasy about receiving. I haven’t ever NOT gone up and received because of this, but I still get upset about it, and I’m pretty sure that isn’t normal. Another example…I live about five miles away from my parish, and had no way of getting there this past weekend. The blessed sacrament was in the monstrance until 1:00, and I got there until 12:15. I spent the next 45 minutes apologizing to our Lord that I could not keep watch with Him for one hour because I didn’t walk fast enough to get there by 12:00.

I’m really not sure if these are just healthy habits to keep the big picture in mind, that of constantly honoring Jesus and Mary rather than selfishly blowing it off, or whether I am being overly scrupulous. Please advise.

EDIT: One thing that is definitely NOT the case, as I’ve read is common among scrupulous people, is me having a negative image of God. Quite the opposite. I KNOW that I am forgiven after going into the Sacrament of Penance/Reconciliation, and I NEVER feel the need to re-confess sins. It is God’s endless mercy, and the suffering, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ to redeem humanity, that makes me not WANT to ever let Him down. How can I ever repay Him for all the blessings He has given me? By sinning and turning away from Him and not following His commandments? No! I can never even come close to repaying Him, but I certainly do not want to disappoint Him by sinning and doing wrong.
 
Praying for your intentions.
Thank you. Your prayers are much appreciated.

Like I said, I am not sure if I am simply being sensitive to sin (which is a good thing) or scrupulous (which is not a good thing). I feel like I am pestering my poor parish priests and senior deacon with stupid questions and frustrating them (not that they’ve indicated that I am indeed doing so).
 
Praying for you. I believe it could be scruples. In that case a good Catholic priest and a good Catholic psychiatrist could help. God bless you.
 
Sounds like scruples, if perhaps probably not the worst case of them ever, but it is probably best to seek the advice of a priest.

In particular: it is not required that every spare coin we have is donated. We do have an obligation to give, of course, and if you’re concerned about whether or not you are meeting that obligation, it is probably best to discuss things with your priest. (Of course, exceeding that obligation - so long as it does not cause harm to our families or people we are responsible for providing for - is admirable, but as to whether or not you are doing less than you SHOULD, nothing you said suggests so and if in doubt you should speak with a priest.)

While we should remain focused during mass, accidentally losing focus is not a sin because of the “accidental” part, so long as we try to prevent it and re-focus as soon as we notice. I don’t know if this is normal, but I would be surprised if it’s not at least somewhat common. (I do know, at least, that I have to struggle with staying focused.) Accidental thoughts are real and common, and since they are accidental it is what we do about them that matters.

As for being late to adoration - first, adoration is not mandatory, so it would not be sinful to refrain from going at all (though again, going is admirable, but refraining from doing something that is admirable but not mandatory is not a sin). And even then, we run into the accident thing. You didn’t intend to be late, and God is not going to sit in heaven staring at you saying “that guy meant well, but he should have walked faster that one time - sin.” Accidents are not sins. Negligence that leads to accidents can be, but you can’t commit negligence in not planning for something you don’t have an obligation to plan for. Which isn’t to say that if I was 15 minute later than I had planned to be for adoration that I wouldn’t be disappointed or apologize, only that there is no sin involved. The apology would be more or less like apologizing for getting stuck in traffic - there’s nothing we could do about it, everyone knows that, but we still wish things were otherwise.

Short version - thinking that you could do better and trying to do so can be good and healthy, but if it devolves into being concerned that bad things that are beyond your control are not just things to try to figure out how to avoid, but actually sinful, or that it is sinful to refrain from doing something that you are not required to do but could maybe pull off if you just tried a bit harder, then you may be veering into scruplosity territory.
 
Another thing…

My brother is away at Basic Training, and his fiancé is caring for their two small children while going to school full-time. She has a lot on her plate, and asked me to type an essay for one of her classes. It was on the history of the Spanish Empire, which is a subject I know aa lot about, and I agreed.

But no matter what I had done, I see a moral problem with it…

Anything short of typing it for her, and I would feel I wasn’t doing enough to help her, and I would feel I was being slothful while she ran around doing a bunch of stuff. She also was going to see my brother graduate from BCT in Georgia this week.

By typing it for her, I am being dishonest in enabling her to pass the class without doing the requisite work, which is unfair to the other students, the professor, and the integrity of the university.
 
Sigh…

I talk about all this, then I turn around and do something that is (at the very least) grave matter, and I’m not being scrupulous about that at all.

Disappointing. Thank God for the Sacrament of Penance.

Please pray for me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top