Serious Moral Dilemma

  • Thread starter Thread starter Fergal
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

Fergal

Guest
Hi Folks,

I am looking for advice on the following recent scenario.
On friday lasy I entered the Parish Office to photocopy a sheet for an upcoming meeting.
Whilst at the photocopier, I noticed that a job was underway and had a closer look to see how much longer was involved.
I noticed, on inspection, that it was information on contraception, sterilisatiion and emergency contraception.
I asked those who worked there what it was and they said it was a job one of the Priests asked them to do. They said that they did not pay much attention to it and therefore did not really know its contents, they just loaded it into the copier.

On further inspection I found that it offered phone numbers to abortion referral services and information on abortifacients. I was shocked and horrifed at the graphic nature of the content and at the fact that it was being photocopied for a Priest of our Parish. I do not know whether he was doing them for himself or whether he was doing them for someone else. So I took one copy of each of the leaflets home with me for further study.

I just assume that he was copying them for distribution but where are when I have no idea.

I do know the copies are for a Priest in our Parish. I do know he is in charge of the Marriage Preparation programme in our Parish but I have no proof that they will be used there.

I do not know where they are going or who they are intended for.

I do know that they contain information about gross immoral procedures that directly and abominably contradict some of the Churches strongest ever teachings on human life and the sacrament of marriage.

I cannot remain silent about this and yet I have no idea where they are going or who they are for. This is what I have learned on the Church Law side of things so far:

Canon Law Number 1398 states, quite simply, in Latin and English; Qui abortum procurat, effectu secuto, in excommunicationem, latae sententiae, incurrat. (Those who successfully abort a living human fetus bring on themselves instant excommunication.)

‘Abortum procurat’ means anyone who works to kill a human foetus in any manner at all. This may be the boyfriend or husband who drives the mother to the abortion mill, pays for the abortion in full or in part, or even advises that abortion may be an option in her case.

Canon Law 1398 (quoted above) and Section 2 of Canon Law 1329 outline quite clearly the penalty for assisting in an abortion. The latter Canon Law states that “Accomplices, even though not mentioned in the law or precept, incur the same penalty [latae sententiae excommunication] if, without their assistance, the crime would not have been committed, and if the penalty is of such a nature as to be able to affect them; otherwise, they can be punished with ferendae sententiae [inflicted by clergy] penalties.”

If they are for him and if he is intending they be used at the pre-marriage course then under canon 2350 the same priest has incurred an automatic excommunication.

My question. With so many assumptions and holes in my knowledge what do I do? Admonish the sinner? Combat the error by issuing tracts on the Church’s teachings on contraception? Go to the Parish Priest? Go to the Bishop?

There must be action but in what way?
 
Before jumping to conclusions, why don’t you ask the priest who wanted the copies? It doesn’t look good, but they might have a legitimate use… 😦
 
Very troubling, but yes, Isidore’s suggestion sounds like the right one to me. Until you really know what the situation is, you shouldn’t assume the worst, however bad things may appear. I think that the conscientious response would be to ask the priest directly.
 
I have sincerely asked twice to speak with the Priest concerned and have received no reply.

I would dearly love to but it is not going to happen.
 
Sometimes this helps when faced with a really unpleasant, difficult or impossible situation:

Close your eyes and say “Holy Spirit, give me the words and resources to deal with this…”

And then…

Go and kneel before the Tabernacle… Look Jesus in the Eye … and say, “I can’t do this… I don’t know what to do… but YOU do and YOU can.”

And then leave… go about your business… having put it directly into Jesus’ hands.
 
Tell the priest that you saw these materials being photocopied for him and that you want to know what they are about. If he refuses to tell you, tell him you are going to let others in the parish know about what you saw unless he does tell you. If he has nothing to hide and is using these for legit purposes, he will tell you. Otherwise you can assume he is doing something wrong, and start raising awareness and letting other people know what’s going on - perhaps even speak to the Bishop.
 
40.png
Flopfoot:
Tell the priest that you saw these materials being photocopied for him and that you want to know what they are about. If he refuses to tell you, tell him you are going to let others in the parish know about what you saw unless he does tell you. If he has nothing to hide and is using these for legit purposes, he will tell you. Otherwise you can assume he is doing something wrong, and start raising awareness and letting other people know what’s going on - perhaps even speak to the Bishop.
Good advice Flopfoot.
 
Fergal, perhaps you should consider minding your own business and just assume that the priest knows what he’s doing.
I do not know where they are going or who they are intended for.
This statement sums up the situation nicely. You are assuming the worst. The priest is under no obligation to explain himself to you.
 
Extort? Please… he’s trying to find an answer out before having to take it up with the Bihsop… nothing wrong with that. If this Priest is referring ppl to an abortion ( read: MURDER ) clinic and telling them to use contraceptives ( this is murder also )… then he needs to be talked to… and maybe excommunicated for leading the flock astray.
40.png
St.Sharky:
Of course, lets extort the priest!!! Thats a lot of fun
 
He has every right to have the Priest expain to him the situation. IF this Priest is leading the flock astray he needs to be reeled in… ASAP!
40.png
Benedictus:
Fergal, perhaps you should consider minding your own business and just assume that the priest knows what he’s doing.

This statement sums up the situation nicely. You are assuming the worst. The priest is under no obligation to explain himself to you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top