Shopping at LDS run stores?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Honour
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I doubt that it’s a sin to shop at a LDS store for clothes etc., but I wouldn’t buy any religious books or bibles from them because they would have much error. 😦
 
Most LDS under the age of 30 probably have no idea this was ever taught."
That’s because it was NEVER taught as doctrine. The LDS Church has never claimed to know how Jesus was conceived but does believe the Bible (noted in my original post) and Book of Mormon references to Jesus being born of the Virgin Mary. The earliest “official” statement (and the “official” part is key 🙂 ) I could find on the topic comes from Charles W. Penrose, in the First Presidency and a member of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, which echoes other subsequent official references:

''Question 10: Do you believe that Jesus Christ was begotten by the Holy Ghost, as described in Matthew 1:18-20; Luke 1:35?

Answer: We believe that Jesus of Nazareth ‘was the only begotten of the Father.’ It is not stated in either text cited that he was ‘begotten of the Holy Ghost,’ and the contrary is described in Luke 1:35. It was the ‘power of the Highest’ that overshadowed Mary, and Jesus was ‘the Son of the Highest.’ The Holy Ghost came upon her, she ‘conceived’ under the influence of that divine Spirit, but Jesus is nowhere declared as the Son of the Holy Ghost, but as ‘the only begotten of the Father, full of grace and truth.’ (John 1:14; Hebrews 1:5.) Even the sectarian creeds do not fall into the error that beclouds the minds of some apostates, but say of Jesus that He is the Son of God, ‘conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary,’ etc." Charles W. Penrose, “Peculiar Questions Briefly Answered,” Improvement Era 15 no. 11 (September 1912).

Because it is a sensitive, sacred topic (which is rarely even discussed by members or the leadership), LDS Christians simply try to clear the record so that our actual beliefs are more accurately understood. For those few who might care to understand more fully, here’s the LDS apologetic link to the topic.

And because this is so far off topic, I’ll leave the topic here with no malice towards those who wish to comment as they will.

Cheers,
~Nick
 
That’s because it was NEVER taught as doctrine. The LDS Church has never claimed to know how Jesus was conceived but does believe the Bible (noted in my original post) and Book of Mormon references to Jesus being born of the Virgin Mary. The earliest “official” statement (and the “official” part is key 🙂 ) I could find on the topic comes from Charles W. Penrose, in the First Presidency and a member of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, which echoes other subsequent official references:

''Question 10: Do you believe that Jesus Christ was begotten by the Holy Ghost, as described in Matthew 1:18-20; Luke 1:35?

Answer: We believe that Jesus of Nazareth ‘was the only begotten of the Father.’ It is not stated in either text cited that he was ‘begotten of the Holy Ghost,’ and the contrary is described in Luke 1:35. It was the ‘power of the Highest’ that overshadowed Mary, and Jesus was ‘the Son of the Highest.’ The Holy Ghost came upon her, she ‘conceived’ under the influence of that divine Spirit, but Jesus is nowhere declared as the Son of the Holy Ghost, but as ‘the only begotten of the Father, full of grace and truth.’ (John 1:14; Hebrews 1:5.) Even the sectarian creeds do not fall into the error that beclouds the minds of some apostates, but say of Jesus that He is the Son of God, ‘conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary,’ etc." Charles W. Penrose, “Peculiar Questions Briefly Answered,” Improvement Era 15 no. 11 (September 1912).

Because it is a sensitive, sacred topic (which is rarely even discussed by members or the leadership), LDS Christians simply try to clear the record so that our actual beliefs are more accurately understood. For those few who might care to understand more fully, here’s the LDS apologetic link to the topic.

And because this is so far off topic, I’ll leave the topic here with no malice towards those who wish to comment as they will.

Cheers,
~Nick
Uh, yes it was. Have you ever checked out the Journal of Discourses which is full of General Conference addresses of LDS prophets and apostles, all of whom were “prophets, seers and revelators”? Even your Relief Society/Priesthood manuals (the Teachings of the Presidents series) heavily rely on the Journal of Discourses for their source material. Many of the statements made by LDS prophets and apostles regarding the carnal conception of Jesus were made by the apostles and prophets in their “official” capacity as LDS church leaders.

I find it rather humorous that you provided a link to FAIR which is “not official”.

The thing is is that Brigham Young and other early prophets and apostles taught all kinds of things as official doctrine in General Conference such as the carnal conception of Jesus, Adam-god doctrine, priesthood ban for blacks and blood atonement. It was only when LDS church leaders after World War 2 became more PR-minded and gradually moved away from such teachings. Gordon Hinckley, who was very PR-minded, worked very hard to make the LDS church appear more mainstream which is why hardly anyone who came of age during Mr. Hinckley’s tenure has heard of things like blood atonement, Adam-god doctrine, Joseph Smith’s polygamous relationships, etc. Brigham Young has been thrown under the bus so many times, he must be spinning in his grave. I would not be surprised if in 100 years time, the teachings of today’s LDS prophets and apostles as officially stated in General Conference are disavowed and referred to as “unofficial” and “opinions of a man”. Either LDS prophets and apostles speak for Heavenly Father or they don’t. If they do speak for Heavenly Father, the least you can do is own up to what they teach.

The issue of the LDS teachings on the conception of Jesus was addressed in a thread last year. Link is below.

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=814520&highlight=mary+lds
 
I’ll be sure to seek your counsel when I have a moral dillema of my own. No sin in giving money to the LDS church, and not even any rules at all against ecumenical services with an organization that denies the deity of Jesus? Good deal!
Mormons don’t deny that Jesus was God. They identify Jesus as Jehovah, creator of heaven and earth.

Purchasing used clothing from the LDS church isn’t the same as giving to the LDS church.

Also, since 1994, a portion of LDS tithing monies has gone directly to Catholic Charitees.

The only LDS owned used clothing store I am aware of is Deseret Industries. You may have noticed they focus on employing the disabled. Also, I’ve seen Catholic bibles there. I’m pretty sure the Mormons don’t take the time to edit or change them. 🙂 Nor do they put magical symbols in the clothing they sell you. 😃 Please feel free to correct me if you find anything weird there. 👍
 
When I was LDS, I was taught that Heavenly Father had sex with Mary to conceive Jesus in early morning seminary and at a BYU religion class in the 1990’s. Both teachers were ultimately paid by the LDS church.
Please name the teachers. I’m not challenging your honesty; I’m going to write a letter to the BYU editor. It would not be the first time someone’s taught apostate doctrines at a church school (IIRC that’s happened at Catholic schools too, has it not?)
 
I’ll be sure to seek your counsel when I have a moral dillema of my own. No sin in giving money to the LDS church, and not even any rules at all against ecumenical services with an organization that denies the deity of Jesus? Good deal!
Why so snarky? If you disagree, why not just state that along with your reasons why?
 
Why so snarky? If you disagree, why not just state that along with your reasons why?
Your question strikes me as appropriate. I guess I got ‘snarky’ because his ‘free pass’ came right on the heels of a solid answer which explains why shopping at an LDS-run store is not a good thing. Then he comes along and says, “Naah, no problem at all!” Maybe he just needs to be shown how ridiculous his laissez-faire attitude is. But maybe I didn’t achieve that end.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top