Sister dating non-religious guy

  • Thread starter Thread starter skigirl1689
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

skigirl1689

Guest
My sister is in her final semester of college, and she started dating this guy who seems to be really nice, though I’ve only met him once and it was just basic introductions, so I don’t know him at all. My sister has only dated one other guy for a month last year, and I think she was getting nervous she wouldn’t meet someone in college.

My sister is very religious (we’re both Lutheran as is our mom; Dad is a Christian but does not attend church), but her boyfriend, in her words, is “not religious.” To me this is a huge red flag. She told my mom she already told her boyfriend that she will be raising her kids Christian and will take them to church until they are on their own. She also brought him to a college Bible study at the church where both of us attended/attend during college (all my siblings went to the same college). She did not say how that went.

Knowing how people judged me when growing up due to my dad not going to church with us, I think it’s a bad idea for her to think of marriage with this guy no matter how great he is. At least my dad fully supported our faith, and we share the belief in Christ. He said prayers with us every night when we were little, and he still reminds us to pray, in addition to having open conversations about faith issues with us. I cannot imagine not having parenting issues when one spouse is not a believer.

I am aware, and I assume she is too, of the dangers of being unequally yoked in a marriage. I think it is a bit different when it’s a denominational difference, but I would think she would have came out and said if he was at least a Christian or had a Christian background, but she didn’t.

So my dilemma: do I tell her how I feel and most assuredly upset her, perhaps even damaging our relationship, or just say nothing and pray it works out for the best? I am sure my dad warned or will warn her, but I feel burdened by this, though I know it is her life and she will have to live with whatever the consequences are. Plus, who am I to give advice as I have never dated or been in a relationship because I have a significant disability and the opportunity has never presented itself?
 
I wouldn’t assume so many things about him. Not necessarily your sister’s case, but I know this college girl (my little sister ) has a boyfriend that doesn’t go to church but is a believer (mainly because his parents never took him to church although they are believers ). But we all know for certain (including the guy himself ) that once they marry (if ever) they will go to Church together.

Even if the guy says himself that he isn’t interested, he has a long way to convert and she can be that instrument of God he needs.
 
If she asks what you think about her dating him, tell her your opinion, otherwise let your sister conduct her relationship in peace. It doesn’t sound like she is any where near thinking about spending the rest of her life with this guy.
 
I can’t speak for this man, but I was raised by a Christian mother and an atheist father. He has always supported my freedom to choose my own religion, and has encouraged me to pray, attend church, etc. It isn’t always a parenting issue. It can be done. 🙂
 
It isn’t necessary for you to say anything unless she asks you. Your concern is understandable, but this is really for her to figure out.

My husband was not raised in the faith. I struggled with this a lot when we were dating, and he and I had many conversations about what our life together would look like. There are issues that we come across still, but in general he is supportive and attends Mass with me and our son often.

No one, friends or family, ever said anything to me about it- even to this day and we have been married several years. I would have been upset if they had. I prayed a lot about it and when we were married, I did not have any doubts whatsoever that I was making the right choice (I still do not). My parents love my husband like their own child, and do not presume that his religious convictions are any of their business.

Pray for your sister, that she is guided by God in her discernment of a spouse. Try not to get ahead of yourself especially if they just started dating. Just talk to her about him in the way that you’d talk to her about any other guy, and trust that your sister, who you say is very religious, will ask for your advice if she feels that she needs it.
 
Thank you for your replies. I am not going to say anything unless she specifically asks. They will be separated after December due to her graduating and taking a job out of state, so I guess we’ll see how they weather that. I am fervently praying for them and especially his salvation. It’s just surprising to me how open CAF members are to these types of arrangements when all my parents get is criticism for being of different denominations, especially from Catholics we know…just an observation, not a judgment :).
 
Thank you for your replies. I am not going to say anything unless she specifically asks. They will be separated after December due to her graduating and taking a job out of state, so I guess we’ll see how they weather that. I am fervently praying for them and especially his salvation. It’s just surprising to me how open CAF members are to these types of arrangements when all my parents get is criticism for being of different denominations, especially from Catholics we know…just an observation, not a judgment :).
👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top