Six moral vacuum questions

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mort_Alz
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
#1 seems like a clear-cut case where you’d use the principle of double effect. You’d probably try to save as many lives as you can. Similar to if a pregnant woman is dying, and the only way to save her is by performing an operation that will likely kill her unborn child = you try to save one life, instead of doing nothing and having both die. Or a doctor in a triage situation, who, being able to work on only one patient at a time, would have to quickly choose if two patients at the point of death are brought in.

#2 is a case where the PDE would NOT apply, because in order to save the five lives, you have to do something which is intrinsically immoral = directly killing an innocent person. In #1 you are merely flicking a switch, and the person on the track’s death is a foreseen but unintended consequence. In this case, the person’s death is the MEANS by which you are saving the five lives. This is akin to a doctor killing one patient and harvesting his organs to save five other patients who are dying.

#3 Again, this is akin to triage, where neither choice is “wrong” = all the human lives involved are valuable. The person would need to make a decision based on other factors. For example, a two-year-old will feel intense pain if she dies in a fire, whereas the embryos will feel nothing. The two-year-old’s chance of survival is also higher, since embryos need to be kept at a constant temperature in lab conditions and even in optimum conditions most will not survive implantation, let alone after being through a fire. Human emotions will also play a part in how you decide, for example, if the embryos are your children and the two-year-old is unrelated to you, then you will likely favour your own children. Again, neither choice is “wrong”.

#4 Yes, you’re perfectly entitled to shoot the person. You are morally (and legally) allowed to kill someone in self-defence, or in defence of another innocent person.

#5 I don’t understand this question. If the person has no authority (i.e. he’s not a police officer trying to kill you because you’re threatening to kill him first), then this is again a case of self-defence. It’s not the “sin of murder”. I don’t think maybe you understand what “murder” is. It’s not simply killing someone. It’s killing an innocent person.

#6 Killing the abortionist achieves nothing. He’s not some random guy holding a gun to a stranger’s head, who you can take down and then the stranger will be safe. If you kill the abortionist, you will be sent to prison, and then another abortionist will perform the abortion anyway. The abolitionists didn’t go around using violence against slave traders, because they knew that doing so would not achieve anything. It would only result in all abolitionists being treated as criminals and making it even more difficult to eliminate slavery altogether. Similarly, pro-life people know that killing abortionists (who may not even fully understand that they are killing an unborn person in an abortion) will not prevent abortions from happening, and will in fact hinder progress in making abortion illegal in the long-term.
This answer is pretty darn good.
 
You will never be able to iron out the contradictions of an embryo having all the rights of a full fledged person, yet not being deserving of a person risking their life or freedom to save them from death the way they would if they were seeing a born baby about to be murdered.

Most people reject questions that would cause them to reexamine their positions for flaws. Hence “embryos are people”…except when they’re not. When all else fails, say the question is ridiculous and move on.
 
You will never be able to iron out the contradictions of an embryo having all the rights of a full fledged person, yet not being deserving of a person risking their life or freedom to save them from death the way they would if they were seeing a born baby about to be murdered.

Most people reject questions that would cause them to reexamine their positions for flaws. Hence “embryos are people”…except when they’re not. When all else fails, say the question is ridiculous and move on.
There is no contradiction. Most of us, however, are intelligent enough to know that dragging frozen embryos out of the clinic is going to destroy them just as much is the fire would. Also anyone that knows anything at all about in vitro fertilization knows that the majority of these embryos are going to be destroyed anyway. In addition The fire is not going to cause in any pain and suffering to frozen embryos as it would to a little girl . The real solution to this so-called dilemma is to quit creating the embryos in the first place .

I have found the questions like these are not designed to force pro-life adherents to re-examine their positions but are really an attempt by those who support the killing of the unborn to rationalize their support of abject evil
 
The train dilemma is pretty well-known. The majority would choose to redirect the train in scenario 1- so the train would kill one, but five people are saved. The change comes with scenario 2- basically, you have almost the same situation, you could choose to save five lives but let someone die. Still the majority would not push that man out of the train. Most plausible explanation seems to refer to our sense of responsibility- in the first scenario, we don’t feel responsible for what is happening- we have nothing to do with the entire situation and only act to prevent a greater tragedy. In the scenario 2, we would have to directly kill someone who was up to that point safe in order to save others.

Scenario 4- I am not obliged by anyone in this scenario, but in my opinion, killing someone to prevent him/her murdering someone would be an acceptable (if tragic) course of action. So would be running for your life in this situation and if I am sincere this is what I’d probably end up doing.

Scenario 5- Bringing the issues of authority and very serious legal punishment…but it doesn’t explain in what way does this person has bogus authority. If it means that he/she is planning to cover up the murder using his/her position of authority (as in a policeman trying to cover up a murder by lying about acting in self-defense)- the same answer as in scenario 4 as I might have a chance to prove the entire thing.

If it means that he/she is using a real but unfair law (as in a law that would allow policemen to execute someone for theft or drug possession)- no, I would not be the hero that spends the rest of her days in a prison or is executed.

#3, 6 Obviously targets people who believe that embryos should have the same rights as people so N/A
 
The first 2 have a false premise: You cannot stop the train.

Yes you can.

Put a bunch of things on the track, derails the train.

Place an empty truck on the tracks. Crashes and stops the train.
 
The first 2 have a false premise: You cannot stop the train.

Yes you can.

Put a bunch of things on the track, derails the train.

Place an empty truck on the tracks. Crashes and stops the train.
Stopping the train by other means is clearly morally preferred. What is the next best option (morally speaking)? I think this can be answered by appeal to moral principles (and has been).
 
Stopping the train by other means is clearly morally preferred. What is the next best option (morally speaking)? I think this can be answered by appeal to moral principles (and has been).
Check this out.

snopes.com/science/train.asp
In July 1999, three Indiana youngsters were charged with having caused the South Shore passenger train to jump the tracks in Michigan City after they placed a brick on the tracks.
If a brick can be used to derail a train, I’m sure other items could be used.

As I said, the first two examples are based on a false premise (cannot stop train) and thus the moral dilemma does not exist for those two.
 
First:
“This woman I am on a date with wants to have sex with me, should I?”

Catholic answer: no

“Ha! What if I am on a date with my wife?”

CA: duh, yes

Circumstances are a factor in all things. So assuning your situations are face value “total info known to the person involved” mixed with the assumption it is 2016 in our times I will knock these out 🙂
The first three are rather similar to each other as are the last three.

#1: A train is running on tracks that are about to fork. One path will run over a single individual who is tied down to the tracks, killing them. The other path will run over five individuals who are tied down to the track, killing them. You cannot stop the train. You must decide which path the train will take by flipping a switch. Which path are you obligated to choose (and are you obligated to act at all? Are you obligated to do nothing and to let the train run whichever way it was going to before your awareness of the dilemma?).
Go for the One. And pray and do everyhting you can to tryand find a way out. If not you did what you could.
#2: A train is running on a single track that is destined to run over five individuals tied down to the track, killing them. There is a large individual whose mass you know will be enough to stop the train if he were placed in the train’s path. Pushing this individual into the path of the train (thus killing him) is the only way which the train can be stopped before it kills the five individuals tied to the tracks. Are you obligated to push the man into the path of the train? Are you obligated to do nothing? If your answer to this question is incongruous with your answer to #1 can you explain why?
No push. Simple and clear. It is in the catechism to not commint direct evil to achieve “good”.
#3: A laboratory has caught fire which contains many fertilized human embryos that are waiting to be implanted so that they may be born. Also in the building is a two-year old girl (presumably the daughter of someone who works there). You are in the unique position where you only have the time and the means to save either the two-year old girl or five of the fertilized embryos from dying in the fire. Obviously you are obligated to save one or the other. Which are you obligated to save? Why?
Given my personal understanding (wrong or not) of embryonic science the survival rate is almost nil for the embryos as they inject many to get one to “take” and I believe they use more than 5 at a time :confused:

Given that I would say the girl.
#4: An individual is about to murder someone right in front of you. You perceive this and realize the only way to stop the murder is to kill the perpetrator. Are you obligated to do this? Are you obligated to do nothing?
Murderer is going night night 🙂
#5: Exact same scenario as #4 except in this case the perpetrator has legal authority to murder and you will face legal punishment if you kill him. The reasons this person has legal authority are bogus and his killing of the individual in front of you will still be the sin of murder. Are you obligated to kill the perpetrator under these circumstances? Are you obligated to do nothing? Does your answer to this question differ from your answer to #5? If so, why?
Depends on much and such will be explained in #6
#6: A doctor is on his way to perform a legal abortion. You are the only person who can stop this from happening, but the only way to do it is by killing the doctor before he performs the abortion. Are you obligated to do this? Are you obligated to do nothing? How does your answer to this question compare to your answers to #4 and #5? If they differ substantially, why?
In the circumstance of the info here + 2016 you do nothing physically. However you should vocalize and hope to pluck a heart string.

Why?

Just war theory

Killing this man would do more harm than good. Circumstantially you create a reverse Martyr. There are times to go out in a blaze of glory accomplishing good against evil. And times that the result of such would be to further the cause of evil.

In some instances if you stand peacefully and let evil kill you you spark a movement.

In some standing and fighting to the death will spark the movement.

In some, retreat is in order to cause the most good.

In Summation:

We must do good and can only do so within what we can see/know. So none of these questions are “moral vaccum” they are laughably easy answers. The issue of “what would you do” is not always the same as “should”. But should is generally an easy answer 😛
 
A better moral question, who does it edify, lift-up, strengthen or give peace to pose these questions to your neighbor? What fruit of the spirit is being encouraged in those who answer?
That is no fun
On a logic level, these questions are all a form of the** Kobiashi Maru.** They are a straw man argument with no possibility of winning. Therefore, there is no morality in question because God is not random.
I complete most things in the same way Kirk completed this 😛
On a theological level, God is fully in control and is not a school boy with a magnifying glass on an ant hill. Do you glorify Jesus as Lord through this discussion?
Without going through his posts and evaluating what I might view as his motivators…

It is entirely plausible that he has been presented with these and cannot comprehend how to justify his own faith. He may have been presented these as an act of malice by another, and to cast him out as a wolf is to send a wounded sheep into a wolf den…

:tsktsk:
 
Check this out.

snopes.com/science/train.asp

If a brick can be used to derail a train, I’m sure other items could be used.

As I said, the first two examples are based on a false premise (cannot stop train) and thus the moral dilemma does not exist for those two.
Agree 100%. Now, what’s the next best option after placing an object on the tracks?
 
Agree 100%. Now, what’s the next best option after placing an object on the tracks?
When I found one very effective way, which can be done quickly and in time to make sure people are not killed, why are we doing “paralysis analysis” and trying to find other ways?

You’ve got seconds to act to save lives, no time to call in a committee meeting!
 
A train is running on tracks that are about to fork. One path will run over a group of 30 Catholics celebrating mass while holding hands during the Our Father . The other path will run over 30 individuals who are Reading Harry Potter books while engaging in Yoga. You cannot stop the train. You must decide which path the train will take by flipping a switch. Which path are you obligated to choose (and are you obligated to act at all? Are you obligated to do nothing and to let the train run whichever way it was going to before your awareness of the dilemma?).
 
Does not one forfeit their soul if they hold hands during the Our Father. Im pretty sure i read that on CAF someplace. If we really wanted to cause a problem we could change the Catholics to women wearing dresses that were 2 inches above their knees.
 
Seeing as I’m late to the thread, and the correct answers have been given, I’ll refrain from answering all of the six questions myself.

The first person to give a very succint and accurate answer is sugarmouse in post #11; thanks for that.

I’d like to comment on some of the responses in this thread. I see a lot of people saying that these questions are futile, or even agendized. I must beg to differ.

I can’t judge the intention of the OP, of course, but I do think that hypothetical questions such as these are very useful to elucidate certain moral principles. There is actually a “correct” answer to each of the 6 questions, but those answers are difficult to understand unless one has a comprehensive understanding of the principle of double effect, the definition of murder, and the practical application of moral principles.

If one does not have such understanding, these hypothetical situations are useful for growing it.

I would like to add to the previous posters’ explanation of the following:
#5: Exact same scenario as #4 except in this case the perpetrator has legal authority to murder and you will face legal punishment if you kill him. The reasons this person has legal authority are bogus and his killing of the individual in front of you will still be the sin of murder. Are you obligated to kill the perpetrator under these circumstances? Are you obligated to do nothing? Does your answer to this question differ from your answer to #5? If so, why?
The question as stated is unclear. If the perpetrator has “legal authority to murder”, that means that the law has given this person legal authority to “kill an innocent man”. In this case we are dealing with an evil government, and it is your duty to defend the innocent just as in situation #4.

But I don’t think that’s what the OP meant, since he might have misunderstood the meaning of “murder”. I think he meant “legal authority to kill”, which means that this is probably a case whether the person to be killed is an enemy of the common good, and so the state has lawfully determined that he should be killed. This kind of capital punishment can take shape in many ways, and thus the moral question depends on the circumstances.

Is the victim at the chopping block at the behest of the state? You mustn’t stop it.
Do you believe the victim is innocent even though the state has determined he is guilty? In this case, you can choose to save him or not, depending on how sure you are of his innocence. I don’t think, though, that you have a moral obligation either way unless you yourself are an agent of the state capable of legally changing the outcome.
 
You are correct that the Church would not condone killing the doctor. But, change the hypothetical slightly and the answer would be different. And it is difficult for me to see why it would be different.

Modified Hypo: The doctor has laid a YOUR live baby on the sidewalk and is about to bash its brains out with a sledge hammer. The only way to stop him is to kill him. Would you do it? Are you morally obligated to do it? IWhy would the answer be different merely because the baby is not your own or because the doctor will do the deed behind closed doors? Should the answer be different because the laws of the society condone one form of murder (abortion) but not the other? Would the answer be different if you were a police officer?
I can help you see the difference.

In the situation described by the OP, there would be little good done by killing the doctor because:
  1. The mother is the one choosing to have the baby die, and will probably pursue that end with another doctor
  2. The state condones the murder of the unborn child, and so would facilitate the child’s abortion later and jail you
  3. Your murder of the doctor would give society further reasons to continue abortion, because they can paint pro-life people as murderers.
  4. In real life you would be able to stop the abortion doctor from killing the child by means other than killing him, which makes that killing of him unnecessary (and immoral) anyway.
In your hypothetical, none of the four above points would apply.
  1. You are the parent, so by saving your child you are really saving him, and you won’t be aborting him later.
  2. The state does not condone the killing of born infants, so would be on your side, helping you save the child.
  3. Society can’t complain.
  4. There is no way to stop the doctor other than killing him (I suppose that’s your hypothetical). If there was another way to stop him, such as by simply pushing him over before the hammer comes down, you should do that instead.
I hope this helps.
 
I recognized your train dilemma in #1 and am answering each scenario before reading the next one.

#1: I’ve seen this moral dilemma before in other locations but this is the first time that those in danger have been portrayed as incapacitated. The prior versions I’ve seen were that there were 5 workers on the rails simply unaware of the danger, and a single worker on the other track likewise unaware of the oncoming train. The train was posited to definitely strike the 5 if the actor chose “do nothing.” That dilemma was easy for me, if the 5 were so reckless with their own safety that they not only would work on a rail line might have an incoming train on it but also not assign even one of them to keep watch then they had already chosen their own fate. The single worker’s lack of watchfulness might be attributable to his previously taking efforts to affirm that the track he was working on would not have any trains travelling on it.

Your version poses that all of those in danger as innocent victims of a nefarious Snidely Whiplash wannabe. None of them have chosen to be on the tracks and cannot escape the oncoming train should they become aware of its approach. However you also posit that the track the train will travel upon without any intervention remains undetermined. If it is really possible that the train could go down either track but the only way to know for sure which one it will go down is to affirmatively choose that track then I would do nothing and allow the train to go without my involvement. I had nothing to do with this nefarious plot and have no obligation to involve myself in any way in determining which way the train will travel. On the other hand I cannot say that everyone is obliged to refrain from acting.

I think that the dilemma would be much more poignant if you stuck to the default that the 5 would die from inaction. That would be much harder to simply stand by and watch. I think that I would eventually hit the switch and sacrifice the one to save the five. The result would be the same in a slightly different scenario where all six people were tied down to the same track, with the five first and then further down the one. If the train hits the five it will derail sparing the one, but if any of the five are untied the train will still reach and kill the one. If there is only time to get to one of the groups (5 or 1) then the logical choice is to save the five.

#2: The fat man is an innocent bystander who has taken care to be in a place of relative safety. It is unjust to sacrifice his life to preserve the lives of the also innocent victims. It might be different if there was time to inform the fat man of the situation and obtain his consent, that is he jumps in front of the train to stop it. His choice to heroically sacrifice his own life to save others, even if influenced by my intervention, would be a valid solution to the dilemma, but killing him against his will is not. Everyone is obliged to do nothing. I perceive no incongruity with my answer to scenario #1 as they are not perfectly analogous.

#3: Obligation is to save the girl. IVF has a notoriously low live birth rate per embryo. Most guidelines recommend the transfer of at least two embryos to achieve a single live birth. Many clinics will implant even more to increase the odds and then use “selective reduction” to avoid too many octo-moms. On top of that the current legal system does not recognize any rights inherent to the isolated embryos, the parents of which may dispose of them on a whim or even “donate” them for use in medical research experiments. Bottom line, the majority of embryos conceived in IVF are already under a death sentence and saving them from the fire will not change that. The girl on the other hand has recognized rights that society will enforce once she is rescued from the fire. Her parents cannot toss her into a dumpster or donate her for medical research experiments so my efforts will not be in vain.

#4: I would kill the would be murderer and save the innocent, no hesitation. While I would hope most people would act in the same way, I cannot say that anyone is morally obligated to do so. There is no moral obligation to do nothing in this circumstance.

#5: My answer is precisely the same as I wrote in #4. Consequences to me are irrelevant to the moral calculus.

#6: This scenario is too implausible to merit an answer. I see how you have tried to make it seem analogous to scenarios #4 & #5 but it isn’t. All I have to do to prevent this one doctor from performing the abortion is to break one of his fingers (he’d spend the day getting treated and his abortion client would need to reschedule). Either way, maim or kill, it will not prevent the abortion. The mother will simply go to another abortionist to get the job done. There is no obligation to act and I would say there is an obligation to refrain from killing as it simply cannot achieve the perceived goal. Now if he was the last living person on the surface of the planet who was willing to perform an abortion and no one else would ever assist in any abortion ever again then my decision might be a little different…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top