M
MarcoPolo
Guest
This answer is pretty darn good.#1 seems like a clear-cut case where you’d use the principle of double effect. You’d probably try to save as many lives as you can. Similar to if a pregnant woman is dying, and the only way to save her is by performing an operation that will likely kill her unborn child = you try to save one life, instead of doing nothing and having both die. Or a doctor in a triage situation, who, being able to work on only one patient at a time, would have to quickly choose if two patients at the point of death are brought in.
#2 is a case where the PDE would NOT apply, because in order to save the five lives, you have to do something which is intrinsically immoral = directly killing an innocent person. In #1 you are merely flicking a switch, and the person on the track’s death is a foreseen but unintended consequence. In this case, the person’s death is the MEANS by which you are saving the five lives. This is akin to a doctor killing one patient and harvesting his organs to save five other patients who are dying.
#3 Again, this is akin to triage, where neither choice is “wrong” = all the human lives involved are valuable. The person would need to make a decision based on other factors. For example, a two-year-old will feel intense pain if she dies in a fire, whereas the embryos will feel nothing. The two-year-old’s chance of survival is also higher, since embryos need to be kept at a constant temperature in lab conditions and even in optimum conditions most will not survive implantation, let alone after being through a fire. Human emotions will also play a part in how you decide, for example, if the embryos are your children and the two-year-old is unrelated to you, then you will likely favour your own children. Again, neither choice is “wrong”.
#4 Yes, you’re perfectly entitled to shoot the person. You are morally (and legally) allowed to kill someone in self-defence, or in defence of another innocent person.
#5 I don’t understand this question. If the person has no authority (i.e. he’s not a police officer trying to kill you because you’re threatening to kill him first), then this is again a case of self-defence. It’s not the “sin of murder”. I don’t think maybe you understand what “murder” is. It’s not simply killing someone. It’s killing an innocent person.
#6 Killing the abortionist achieves nothing. He’s not some random guy holding a gun to a stranger’s head, who you can take down and then the stranger will be safe. If you kill the abortionist, you will be sent to prison, and then another abortionist will perform the abortion anyway. The abolitionists didn’t go around using violence against slave traders, because they knew that doing so would not achieve anything. It would only result in all abolitionists being treated as criminals and making it even more difficult to eliminate slavery altogether. Similarly, pro-life people know that killing abortionists (who may not even fully understand that they are killing an unborn person in an abortion) will not prevent abortions from happening, and will in fact hinder progress in making abortion illegal in the long-term.
