V
VonDerTann
Guest
“Are you willing to even consider the possibility of a natural explanation? Or that one may be found in the future?”
–No one can credibly consider that, in essence, “one day a better explanation will come along.” That’s as good as saying, “we can’t explain it now.”
“Miracles of the sun don’t meet the bar, with what we know now about the eye and the brain.”
–With what who knows about the eye and brain? You? Are you an MD? A psychologist? A physicist? Was the author of the supposedly scholarly work you linked us to?
“Moreover, how do you explain that the eyewitness accounts themselves differ on many particulars.”
–That’s just the thing…I find the fact that the eyewitnesses were not uniform to be evidence that a miracle occurred.
“Before we get into this, the burden of proof is on you, not on me.”
-No, you’re the one alleging that this mircle was a natural phenomena. You scolded others for not refuting your “scholarly backing.”…so I did, in about 10 minues.
“A perfectly plausible natural explanation has now been proposed”
-Based on two episodes of self-experimentation by an author not trained or skilled in literally ANY of the areas he purports to have researched. That may be “plausible” to you…to me, it leaves me asking, “where does the evidence lead?” And it certainly does not lead me to the conclusions that the author alleges we should draw.
“False, descriptions of [12 miracles] what happens are taken from all of them.”
–Not in the same article you linked us to.
“Obviously medical images of the eyes are going to unavailable, or at least not without significant expense (for those still alive, even for the most recent 20 years after the event in Rwanda).”
-Saying, “we can’t find data!” does not support the conclusions as being allegedly based on science.
“[the author] is not speaking “authoritatively” (whatever that means) on anything. What your scientific credentials, may I ask, to say the opposite of what he’s saying?”
–Hmmm…how quick you are to admit that the author is not an authority, YOU held his article up as some sort of authority for a “plausible scientific explanation” of Fatima. I have NO scientific credentials, and I found 7-8 holes in his article in a quick skim.
As to saying "every devout, pious Catholic would [find the article a crock], you commit the fallacy of assuming pious Catholics must beleive this [not true] and assume you know every pious Catholic. I can speak only for myself. I personally find your article, which you provided as some sort of authoritative study, to a crock.
–No one can credibly consider that, in essence, “one day a better explanation will come along.” That’s as good as saying, “we can’t explain it now.”
“Miracles of the sun don’t meet the bar, with what we know now about the eye and the brain.”
–With what who knows about the eye and brain? You? Are you an MD? A psychologist? A physicist? Was the author of the supposedly scholarly work you linked us to?
“Moreover, how do you explain that the eyewitness accounts themselves differ on many particulars.”
–That’s just the thing…I find the fact that the eyewitnesses were not uniform to be evidence that a miracle occurred.
“Before we get into this, the burden of proof is on you, not on me.”
-No, you’re the one alleging that this mircle was a natural phenomena. You scolded others for not refuting your “scholarly backing.”…so I did, in about 10 minues.
“A perfectly plausible natural explanation has now been proposed”
-Based on two episodes of self-experimentation by an author not trained or skilled in literally ANY of the areas he purports to have researched. That may be “plausible” to you…to me, it leaves me asking, “where does the evidence lead?” And it certainly does not lead me to the conclusions that the author alleges we should draw.
“False, descriptions of [12 miracles] what happens are taken from all of them.”
–Not in the same article you linked us to.
“Obviously medical images of the eyes are going to unavailable, or at least not without significant expense (for those still alive, even for the most recent 20 years after the event in Rwanda).”
-Saying, “we can’t find data!” does not support the conclusions as being allegedly based on science.
“[the author] is not speaking “authoritatively” (whatever that means) on anything. What your scientific credentials, may I ask, to say the opposite of what he’s saying?”
–Hmmm…how quick you are to admit that the author is not an authority, YOU held his article up as some sort of authority for a “plausible scientific explanation” of Fatima. I have NO scientific credentials, and I found 7-8 holes in his article in a quick skim.
As to saying "every devout, pious Catholic would [find the article a crock], you commit the fallacy of assuming pious Catholics must beleive this [not true] and assume you know every pious Catholic. I can speak only for myself. I personally find your article, which you provided as some sort of authoritative study, to a crock.