Some Fatima Eyewitness Accounts

  • Thread starter Thread starter AirLiner
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
“Are you willing to even consider the possibility of a natural explanation? Or that one may be found in the future?”

–No one can credibly consider that, in essence, “one day a better explanation will come along.” That’s as good as saying, “we can’t explain it now.”

“Miracles of the sun don’t meet the bar, with what we know now about the eye and the brain.”

–With what who knows about the eye and brain? You? Are you an MD? A psychologist? A physicist? Was the author of the supposedly scholarly work you linked us to?

“Moreover, how do you explain that the eyewitness accounts themselves differ on many particulars.”

–That’s just the thing…I find the fact that the eyewitnesses were not uniform to be evidence that a miracle occurred.

“Before we get into this, the burden of proof is on you, not on me.”

-No, you’re the one alleging that this mircle was a natural phenomena. You scolded others for not refuting your “scholarly backing.”…so I did, in about 10 minues.

“A perfectly plausible natural explanation has now been proposed”

-Based on two episodes of self-experimentation by an author not trained or skilled in literally ANY of the areas he purports to have researched. That may be “plausible” to you…to me, it leaves me asking, “where does the evidence lead?” And it certainly does not lead me to the conclusions that the author alleges we should draw.

“False, descriptions of [12 miracles] what happens are taken from all of them.”

–Not in the same article you linked us to.

“Obviously medical images of the eyes are going to unavailable, or at least not without significant expense (for those still alive, even for the most recent 20 years after the event in Rwanda).”

-Saying, “we can’t find data!” does not support the conclusions as being allegedly based on science.

“[the author] is not speaking “authoritatively” (whatever that means) on anything. What your scientific credentials, may I ask, to say the opposite of what he’s saying?”

–Hmmm…how quick you are to admit that the author is not an authority, YOU held his article up as some sort of authority for a “plausible scientific explanation” of Fatima. I have NO scientific credentials, and I found 7-8 holes in his article in a quick skim.

As to saying "every devout, pious Catholic would [find the article a crock], you commit the fallacy of assuming pious Catholics must beleive this [not true] and assume you know every pious Catholic. I can speak only for myself. I personally find your article, which you provided as some sort of authoritative study, to a crock.
 
Says nothing about whether these visions could be produced by natural processes occurring in the eye and brain. In other words:

YOU CAN’T REFUTE THE CLAIM but you will continue to trumpet Fatima as a miracle which “confounds” unbelievers anyway.
Yup - I will and all Catholics since it was proclaimed legit by the Church after many years of investigation.
 

Circumstances and Dialogue of the 1917 Apparitions

Yet another astonishing aspect of the Miracle was that all of the thousands of people, most of whom were soaked to the bone and dirty from the mud, suddenly found that their clothes were dry and clean. “The moment one would least expect it, our clothes were totally dry.” (Maria do Carmo)10

“My suit dried in an instant.” (John Carreira)11

The academician Marques da Cruz testified:
This enormous multitude was drenched, for it had rained unceasingly since dawn. But – though this may appear incredible – after the great miracle everyone felt comfortable, and found his garments quite dry, a subject of general wonder … The truth of this fact has been guaranteed with the greatest sincerity by dozens and dozens of persons of absolute trustworthiness, whom I have known intimately from childhood, and who are still alive (1937), as well as by persons from various districts of the country who were present.12
In one aspect, this is the most astonishing effect of the miracle and an indisputable proof of its authenticity: The amount of energy needed to accomplish this process of drying in a natural way and in such a short a time, would have incinerated everyone present at the Cova at that time. As this aspect of the miracle contradicts the laws of nature radically, no demon could ever have achieved it.


  1. *]Frère François de Marie des Anges, Fatima: The Astonishing Truth, p, 179.
    *]Ibid.
    *]Ibid.

    12 Frère Michel de la Sainte Trinité, The Whole Truth About Fatima, Volume I, p. 340. See also Father John de Marchi, I.M.C., Fatima From the Beginning, (Missoes Consolata, Fatima, Portugal, 1981, third edition, first published in 1950) p. 141; and Joseph A Pelletier, A.A., *The Sun Dances at Fatima, *(Doubleday, New York, 1983) pp. 129-130.
 
I’m still waiting for the prophesied “conversion of Russia”, BTW…
There was a Fatima presentation by an authority (church related) recently. I attended because one of the RE classes I was teaching had to be there. The presenter said that one of the revelations of Fatima was that Russia would be a huge problem if the country was not consecrated to Jesus. Note that this was before the Bolshevik revolution. For whatever reason, the pope didn’t do the consecration, and Russia did become a big problem. It exported God-less communism to China, eastern Europe, Cuba, Vietnam,Cambodia, Laos, Angola, and probably some countries that I don’t remember offhand.

Later on (late 1980’s I believe), the pope DID consecrate Russia to God, and within a short time the Berlin wall fell, and the USSR broke apart. Today, religion is a required subject in Russian schools. That is quite a conversion if you ask me.

This isn’t an area of expertise for me, but others may know more about it.
 
No observatory saw it nor forecasted it. But 70,000 people came to one spot and saw it. It was observed from 30 miles away.
You don’t know that 70,000 people saw it. You don’t have testimony from all 70,000. You don’t know what they saw. Neither do I.
As I stated on an earlier post - many of these people were illiterate peasants and did not write their memoirs…
That may be, but we still don’t have their testimony as to what they saw. Guessing what they may have seen is just speculation.
And…God often uses natural phenonema in His miracles. He is not restricted.
That is enough for Catholics.
Well, if that’s your definition of miracle, an unexpected natural phenomenon, then I have no more argument.
 
“Are you willing to even consider the possibility of a natural explanation? Or that one may be found in the future?”

–No one can credibly consider that, in essence, “one day a better explanation will come along.” That’s as good as saying, “we can’t explain it now.”
Sure, but if it’s highly likely a natural explanation will be found in the future, or a good reason to think so, that lowers the probability of an event being a miracle. Do you maintain all spontaneous remissions of cancer are miracles? We don’t understand what causes spontaneous remission. But most people, even religious believers, assume an unknown natural cause rather than a miracle. Before general relativity there was no natural explanation for the precession of the perihelion of Mercury. Should everyone have thought that was a miracle?
“Miracles of the sun don’t meet the bar, with what we know now about the eye and the brain.”
–With what who knows about the eye and brain? You? Are you an MD? A psychologist? A physicist? Was the author of the supposedly scholarly work you linked us to?
I’m a physicist and a brain researcher. Yes, there’s more than enough evidence to make plausible (even if we don’t have a complete explanation) the idea that chemical reactions in the retina could cause a certain firing pattern in the optic nerve which would cause the brain to “see” an illusion, and put miracles of the sun in the same category as spontaneous remissions of cancer or precessions of orbits before GR.
“Moreover, how do you explain that the eyewitness accounts themselves differ on many particulars.”
–That’s just the thing…I find the fact that the eyewitnesses were not uniform to be evidence that a miracle occurred.
Why? If a natural occurrence, there would be significant inter-subject variability in what was perceived. If a miracle, there could be, but then again might now God want everyone to see the same thing?
“Before we get into this, the burden of proof is on you, not on me.”
-No, you’re the one alleging that this mircle was a natural phenomena.
You’re begging the question, assuming that it is in fact a miracle. The burden of proof is always on one asserting miracle, since the prior probability of a miracle is much, much, much less than a natural phenomenon.
“A perfectly plausible natural explanation has now been proposed”
-Based on two episodes of self-experimentation by an author not trained or skilled in literally ANY of the areas he purports to have researched. That may be “plausible” to you…to me, it leaves me asking, “where does the evidence lead?” And it certainly does not lead me to the conclusions that the author alleges we should draw.
That makes it plausible. Not certain or proven. But plausible. He saw a disc and saw colors. It shows that seeing this, at least, is possible via natural means. Now it’s not a big stretch to think the illusion of motion might take place in a different subject or had he gazed at the sun for a longer period of time.
“False, descriptions of [12 miracles] what happens are taken from all of them.”
–Not in the same article you linked us to.
Yes, in the same article. Read it again.
“Obviously medical images of the eyes are going to unavailable, or at least not without significant expense (for those still alive, even for the most recent 20 years after the event in Rwanda).”
-Saying, “we can’t find data!” does not support the conclusions as being allegedly based on science.
Yeah, so in science one performs preliminary investigations which can be done “on the cheap” before doing more expensive experiments. Preliminary investigations don’t prove one’s hypothesis, but they can show it to be plausible in order to justify the effort and expense for a more detailed investigation.
“[the author] is not speaking “authoritatively” (whatever that means) on anything. What your scientific credentials, may I ask, to say the opposite of what he’s saying?”
–Hmmm…how quick you are to admit that the author is not an authority, YOU held his article up as some sort of authority for a “plausible scientific explanation” of Fatima. I have NO scientific credentials, and I found 7-8 holes in his article in a quick skim.
Well, in that case, since I have plenty of scientific credentials, are you going to defer to my opinion that your “holes” are not such? I rather doubt it. So the “authority” and “credentials” bit is a red herring on your part. Anyway, one should attend to what is being said rather than who is saying it.
As to saying "every devout, pious Catholic would [find the article a crock], you commit the fallacy of assuming pious Catholics must beleive this [not true] and assume you know every pious Catholic. I can speak only for myself. I personally find your article, which you provided as some sort of authoritative study, to a crock.
It’s not a fallacy. Yes, I know, the Church can’t demand belief in the miracle under pain of heresy. Nevertheless, the Church has promoted devotion to “Our Lady of Fatima”, encouraged things like First Saturday devotions, Popes have taken pilgrimages there, and so on. A devout, pious Catholic might, conceivably, have some internal doubts about the miracle; however, he or she would never go public with it and publicly oppose the Church hierarchy. He or she would therefore be forced to publicly deny the possibility of a natural explanation. Since I presume you are trying to be devout and pious I’m suggesting you may therefore be a bit biased in your evaluation.
 
Yup - I will and all Catholics since it was proclaimed legit by the Church after many years of investigation.
OK then - just don’t be surprised if I, and others, see in this attitude - “I don’t care if there’s a plausible natural explanation - it’s a miracle because the Church says so” - a willingness to put ideology ahead of reason.
 
Yet another astonishing aspect of the Miracle was that all of the thousands of people, most of whom were soaked to the bone and dirty from the mud, suddenly found that their clothes were dry and clean.
Clean??? No support is given for that.
“The moment one would least expect it, our clothes were totally dry.” (Maria do Carmo)10
“My suit dried in an instant.” (John Carreira)11
The academician Marques da Cruz testified:
This enormous multitude was drenched, for it had rained unceasingly since dawn. But – though this may appear incredible – after the great miracle everyone felt comfortable, and found his garments quite dry, a subject of general wonder … The truth of this fact has been guaranteed with the greatest sincerity by dozens and dozens of persons of absolute trustworthiness, whom I have known intimately from childhood, and who are still alive (1937), as well as by persons from various districts of the country who were present.12
In one aspect, this is the most astonishing effect of the miracle and an indisputable proof of its authenticity: The amount of energy needed to accomplish this process of drying in a natural way and in such a short a time, would have incinerated everyone present at the Cova at that time. As this aspect of the miracle contradicts the laws of nature radically, no demon could ever have achieved it.
How long had it stopped raining for?
 
Are you willing to even consider the possibility of a natural explanation?
I am. And the Church is okay with that. It’s not established dogma that all Catholics must accept that miracles happened at Fatima. That’s the plain truth. Sure, you could say “It’s been approved by the Church” … “Popes have made pilgrimages there” … and even “The Church calendar has a Feastday for Fatima” etc. But at the end of the day, it’s perfectly okay for a Catholic not to believe any of it. They’re not going to get a slap on the wrist. You can throw all the arguments at this as you can … but at the end of the day, it doesn’t matter. The Church says that private revelations are not required to be believed.

Everyone got that?

Good.

Now, here’s a question for you, NowAgnostic … are YOU willing to consider the possibility of a supernatural explanation? Probably not.

Catholics are free to believe or disbelieve in Fatima and still remain Catholic. Agnostics are not free. They must disbelieve in Fatima otherwise they would no longer be an Agnostic.

Now, what is the likelihood of Fatima being supernatural from what we know? In my opinion, it’s probably supernatural. I think that’s the more likely explanation. But NowAgnostic is not free to take that position. He must say “No! There could be another explanation!” And that’s right, there could be. But I don’t think that’s likely the case. But NowAgnostic says that MUST not be the case. He can’t even consider the possibility.

My point is: Catholics are not the narrow-minded ones here … the non-believers are.

Now, have I misrepresented you, NowAgnostic? I apologize if I have. Please hasten to correct me if so.
 
I am. And the Church is okay with that. It’s not established dogma that all Catholics must accept that miracles happened at Fatima. That’s the plain truth.
Yes, I know, and I said so earlier, but you’re talking about oranges while I am talking about apples.
Sure, you could say “It’s been approved by the Church” … “Popes have made pilgrimages there” … and even “The Church calendar has a Feastday for Fatima” etc. But at the end of the day, it’s perfectly okay for a Catholic not to believe any of it.
Interiorly, with a well-founded doubt.
They’re not going to get a slap on the wrist. You can throw all the arguments at this as you can … but at the end of the day, it doesn’t matter. The Church says that private revelations are not required to be believed.
But a pious, devout Catholic should not go public with his doubts about or denial of Fatima… that would be considered temerarious, disobedient, impious, when this devotion has been established by the Pope. He would not be sinning against faith but he would be against other virtues.

And then you have posters like buffalo who say will continue to support Fatima as a miracle regardless of the possibility of a natural explanation.
Now, here’s a question for you, NowAgnostic … are YOU willing to consider the possibility of a supernatural explanation? Probably not.
Well you’re wrong. In fact in the past, not only did I consider it, but I actually believed it to be supernatural. Back when I still believed, I did the five First Saturdays (twice, even!)
Catholics are free to believe or disbelieve in Fatima and still remain Catholic. Agnostics are not free. They must disbelieve in Fatima otherwise they would no longer be an Agnostic.
This might be a point against atheists, but not agnostics. I can be agnostic about Fatima just as I can be agnostic about the existence of God. I’m not saying I know beyond a shadow of doubt Fatima was not supernatural. There’s a possibility it is. It’s true the possibility of Fatima being a genuine miracle has severely diminished in my mind now that a plausible natural explanation has been advanced. But let’s imagine a different alleged miracle, one in which I estimate the probability of it being a genuine miracle as 0.5. I neither believe nor disbelieve, I just say I don’t know but it’s possible. That’s perfectly consistent with agnosticism.
Now, what is the likelihood of Fatima being supernatural from what we know? In my opinion, it’s probably supernatural. I think that’s the more likely explanation. But NowAgnostic is not free to take that position. He must say “No! There could be another explanation!” And that’s right, there could be. But I don’t think that’s likely the case. But NowAgnostic says that MUST not be the case. He can’t even consider the possibility.
My point is: Catholics are not the narrow-minded ones here … the non-believers are.
Now, have I misrepresented you, NowAgnostic? I apologize if I have. Please hasten to correct me if so.
Yes you have misrepresented me, I can and do consider the possibility of the supernatural. Saying there could be another (natural) explanation is not the same as saying that the natural explanation is necessarily the true one. And, it’s perfectly consistent with agnosticism to admit an event in which the probability of a miracle is greater than a natural explanation, because that is only one piece of evidence, and that may not be enough to swing the “total picture” to make the epistemic probability of God very high.
 
OK then - just don’t be surprised if I, and others, see in this attitude - “I don’t care if there’s a plausible natural explanation - it’s a miracle because the Church says so” - a willingness to put ideology ahead of reason.
The Church is not eager to pronounce authenticity. The process is rigorous. Since I cannot do the work myself I trust their take on this.

There have been many miracle claims the church has denounced.
 
Yes, I know, and I said so earlier, but you’re talking about oranges while I am talking about apples.

Interiorly, with a well-founded doubt.

But a pious, devout Catholic should not go public with his doubts about or denial of Fatima… that would be considered temerarious, disobedient, impious, when this devotion has been established by the Pope. He would not be sinning against faith but he would be against other virtues.
Well … is this true? Is there some rule that a Catholic can’t publicly express doubts about Fatima?
And then you have posters like buffalo who say will continue to support Fatima as a miracle regardless of the possibility of a natural explanation.
I’m not sure what Buffalo is saying, but if he’s saying that a Catholic is obligated to believe in it … or something along those lines … then Buffalo is in error. An error that many Catholic have fallen into.
Well you’re wrong. In fact in the past, not only did I consider it, but I actually believed it to be supernatural. Back when I still believed, I did the five First Saturdays (twice, even!)
I remembered that you said you had not been an Agnostic … but of course I was implying that, given your outlook now, would you consider it.

But yes I suppose you gave an answer here:
This might be a point against atheists, but not agnostics. I can be agnostic about Fatima just as I can be agnostic about the existence of God. I’m not saying I know beyond a shadow of doubt Fatima was not supernatural. There’s a possibility it is. It’s true the possibility of Fatima being a genuine miracle has severely diminished in my mind now that a plausible natural explanation has been advanced. But let’s imagine a different alleged miracle, one in which I estimate the probability of it being a genuine miracle as 0.5. I neither believe nor disbelieve, I just say I don’t know but it’s possible. That’s perfectly consistent with agnosticism.
I suppose a certain grade of agnosticism could say this. I was thinking … and perhaps you can educate me on this … that you might have subscribed to an agnosticism that said the existence of the supernatural can never be known. If you were one of those, then I think my comment could also be applied to you.
Yes you have misrepresented me, I can and do consider the possibility of the supernatural. Saying there could be another (natural) explanation is not the same as saying that the natural explanation is necessarily the true one. And, it’s perfectly consistent with agnosticism to admit an event in which the probability of a miracle is greater than a natural explanation, because that is only one piece of evidence, and that may not be enough to swing the “total picture” to make the epistemic probability of God very high.
Well, I am glad to hear this. And I apologize for misrepresenting you.

Now, would you say that if an agnostic can potentially say that something seems to be more miraculous than not … that it would follow that the existence of God is likewise more likely true than false?
 
Well … is this true? Is there some rule that a Catholic can’t publicly express doubts about Fatima?

I’m not sure what Buffalo is saying, but if he’s saying that a Catholic is obligated to believe in it … or something along those lines … then Buffalo is in error. An error that many Catholic have fallen into.

I remembered that you said you had not been an Agnostic … but of course I was implying that, given your outlook now, would you consider it.

But yes I suppose you gave an answer here:

I suppose a certain grade of agnosticism could say this. I was thinking … and perhaps you can educate me on this … that you might have subscribed to an agnosticism that said the existence of the supernatural can never be known. If you were one of those, then I think my comment could also be applied to you.

Well, I am glad to hear this. And I apologize for misrepresenting you.

Now, would you say that if an agnostic can potentially say that something seems to be more miraculous than not … that it would follow that the existence of God is likewise more likely true than false?
Buffalo said God is not restricted to excluding natural phenonemon in miracles.

Buffalo said he believes the pronouncement made by the Church on Fatima.
 
Some points (general & specific), having re-read the link & this thread:

Ultimately, I find the evidence for a miraculous occurrence at Fatima very persuasive:
  1. There were many, many eyewitnesses. The sheer number of eyewitnesses alone is compelling,
  2. Those eyewitnesses told of events which now, many decades later, canot be easily explained by other means. Note I said “easily.” The most often seen arguments against these seem to be some permutation of “they were all hallucinating,” or “their stories do not fully coincide” or now, what NewAgnostic posits of, “they stared at the sun too long.” The problem with these, thinking hard about them, is that the fact that people may have witnessed differing events does not tend to disprove a miraculous occurrence. First of all, none of these “explanations” seemed to work when the event happened. Thousands of people, who were at Fatima, weren’t “locked up after the event for being nuts”…nor did they say to one another, “I didn’t see what you saw, I guess I missed it,” nor were there episodes of mass blindbess reported.
No, quite the contrary, many, many thousands of eyewitnesses beleived they’d witnessed a miracle…whether because of the sun, the water drying, whatever. Those events may. in truth, be explained naturally…but teh morerelevant question is, how hard is it explain it naturally? The lack of real ability to do so – despite decades of atheists tryig - seems to suggest otherwise.
  1. The eyewitnesses included atheists, skeptics, etc., who converted. That as well seems to suggest something at a minimum highly compelling.
Now some specific posts in response to NewAgnostic:
  1. You seem to advocate a rational approach to all this. OK, so be it, But part of the problem with any argument that contemplates witnesses essentially “staring at the sun too long” leads to the problem of WHY the witnesses, in such large numbers, stared at the sun to begin with. Why would they even look at the sun at all, if nothing was happening to compel them to do so? Rationally, they wouldn’t. The fact that they did - and did not, for example, go blind – seems to suggest an ocurrence which was, again, very, very unusual, and one which now, decades later, defies easy explanation.
  2. Let’s consider that you offered a link to a supposedly scholarly article in support of a belief that staring at the sun too long can essentially “explain away” a purported miraculous event. Maybe it can. However, the article itself has several major holes which were found by a non-scientist (me) in a quick skim.
You scolded someone for not refuting the articule…so I did. Yet in response to my statement of, essentially, “who is the author and what are his qualifications,” you countered by asking ME what were MY qualifications. This is of course, the fallacy of challenging my arguments by essentially an ad hominem attack – that fact that I am not a scientist does not make your author more any more of an authority on what ocurrred.
  1. Now, however,you have gone further, by describing yourself as a “physicist and brain researcher.” In essence, you are now holding yourself up as a) an expert, and b) someone who can vouch for the credibility of your article. I’m sorry, you convince no one on both accounts. First, you never said you were a scientist, at all, until it was held out that your supposed expert was not really an expert. Second, you never said, “I have a PhD from Cornell Unversity’s program in astronomy,” so being a “physicist” – if you are one, and we really have no way to tell – really does not help you vouch for another’s research. Third, even if you ar a physicist, that does not mean you can pass judgmeht on the chemical processes of the and brain any more than I can. Fourth, saying you are a “brain researcher” is meaningless, inasmuch as anyone who “thinks about stuff” may charitably call themselves a “brain researcher.” However, what is NOT meaningless is the fact that a non-scientist – me – found a bunch of holes in a purportedly scholarly work which you held up as providing a “rational explanation” for “miracles of the sun.”
  2. Finally, after setting yourself up as an expert - a “physicist and brain expert,” you self-authenticate your “conclusions” by stating, “I’m a physicist and a brain researcher. Yes, there’s more than enough evidence to make plausible (even if we don’t have a complete explanation) the idea that chemical reactions in the retina could cause a certain firing pattern in the optic nerve which would cause the brain to “see” an illusion, and put miracles of the sun in the same category as spontaneous remissions of cancer or precessions of orbits before GR.”
-So where is all this “more than enough evidence?” Certainly you have provided nothing other than your one link, which seems…less than compelling. I note your admission you canot give a complete explanation for what occurred.

But wait…in case I forgot to say so…I’m a brain researcher also…just sos ya know…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top