Someone has to do it, might as well be me?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Chris_McAvoy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Chris_McAvoy

Guest
If my reason for being interested in ordination to the priesthood or diaconate is simply “because someone has to do it and no one is, may as well be me” does that represent a legitimate reason for attempting to serve my Church in this manner?
 
I say this because I think that if every church of 500 parishoners had 5 priests and 10 deacons, I may not pursue these vocations as someone else already was.

In this way I have differentiated diocesan vocations from the the monastic vocations. In a monastic or eremetical environment such as Mt Athos the quantity of vocations is I think less significant, essentially for them it’s the more the merrier. This is probably a setting that I’d be happier in as well because I think celibate life is less lonely when you are in a fraternal community of brothers and sisters on a daily basis with more evenly shared responsibility (you can see I have the impression that diocesan priests have too much responsibility and loneliness)

However at the same time I don’t think I would mind being a diocesan deacon or priest if I was ordained as a married man as this guarantees a familial environment and that I would be left with less responsibility as I would never have time to serve all the parishoners because my family would come first. It would serve as a permanent excuse to have a less active role. But while I say I would not mind being a married priest, I don’t know that I would pursue it if plenty of other people had the interest (which they don’t).

Have I a flawed understanding of the priesthood to view it as a position filled or unfilled? I’m aware that theres an indelible mark upon ones soul but lots of jobs leave such big marks on people, so thats not unsual, except that it is the soul.
 
The priesthood is not simply a day-time job. It is not simply a profession. It is a vocation. A person should only become a priest if called. This requires spiritual discernment. A priest has significant influence on the souls of the Christians under his care. If a person who does not have a true vocation to the priesthood is nontheless ordained, there is a serious danger that everybody will suffer.
 
Why would everyone suffer? Could you give me a specific example of the evil that would occur?

if a noble virtuous person in prime mental, physical and spiritual health who loves to pray all day is ordained, what can go wrong?

Is it better for the Church to have no priest or deacon? Does the bad outweigh the good?

The old saying is that beggars can’t be choosers.
The question is: Is the church begging?
I admit desperate behavior often leads to dangerous effects…
 
Originally Posted by Chris_McAvoy:
Why would everyone suffer? Could you give me a specific example of the evil that would occur?
if a noble virtuous person in prime mental, physical and spiritual health who loves to pray all day is ordained, what can go wrong?
Is it better for the Church to have no priest or deacon? Does the bad outweigh the good?
If a person is not called to the priesthood; If a person is too eager to become a priest, and not entirely for the right reasons, then yes, there may be problems. The key question is: what is the person’s vocation? Even were the person in prime mental, physical and spiritual health, this is no sure indication of a priestly vocation. Yes, it may seem that such a person may be an excellent priest (and indeed perhaps God intends him to be such). But, as Scripture mention on several occassions, God works in ways mysterious to man, often working through human weakness rather than human strength. God will provide his Church with what and whom she needs.
 
When hundreds of people constantly ask someone over a period of 7 years if I they are a seminarian or say that they might make a good priest this is also not a sign of a vocation and should best be ignored as nonsense, especially if the people suggesting it are themselves clergy.
 
When hundreds of people constantly ask someone over a period of 7 years if I they are a seminarian or say that they might make a good priest this is also not a sign of a vocation and should best be ignored as nonsense, especially if the people suggesting it are themselves clergy.
Don’t ignore, just simply ask them to pray for you being able to recognize your true vocation and to follow it faithfully.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top