Sordid claims about popes?

  • Thread starter Thread starter WJL
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
No matter what the position, Galatians 6:7-8 still holds true:
“Do not be deceived, God is not mocked; for whatever a man sows, that he will also reap. For he who sows to his flesh will of the flesh reap corruption, but he who sows to the Spirit will of the Spirit reap everlasting life.”

It’s a warning for all of us to heed, no matter what our position/status is in the church. There is no everlasting life for those who sow to their flesh.
Thank you for reminding me of this Scripture verse! I must remember to use it in discussions on OSAS and Purgatory. Thanks!
 
Thank you for reminding me of this Scripture verse! I must remember to use it in discussions on OSAS and Purgatory. Thanks!
You’re more than welcome…OSAS and Purgatory are two of my biggest beefs too! 😉
 
Doesn’t make him any less fallible than all the other Popes who may have not.
I hadn’t really even considered the question of infallibility (I don’t believe any human being is infallible). But behaviour like what was being described certainly does point to someone being a wolf in sheep’s clothing.
 
So sad… We have to pray for our clergy and especially the Pop that they don’t fall into this. Imagine how many souls are damned by the bad examples of them.:crying::bighanky:
 
SLIGHTLY off-topic, and I apologize for it:

Does anybody else almost sympathize with Julius II? I mean, certainly he wasn’t THAT good of a pope, but in my opinion he doesn’t belong on the list of bad popes.

🤷

P.S.: Context is everything. The Pope was the head of the Papal States during the Middle Ages. Compare his actions to the actions of other Italian dukes, and some of the papal actions could fit right in. Sometimes the actions (such as the excessive spending) of popes are better than the actions of contemporary Italians. For example, did you know that Ferdinand I of Naples stuffed his enemies, and clothed them too? The popes just so happened to be the head of the Church, and not the head of a city-state.
 
I hadn’t really even considered the question of infallibility (I don’t believe any human being is infallible). But behaviour like what was being described certainly does point to someone being a wolf in sheep’s clothing.
One would say the same thing about predators amongst Protestant clergy as well as secular institutions such as public schools.
 
A new book with many details on popes, good and bad, is entitled Absolute Monarchs by John Julius Norwich. I found it fascinating. The book seems to be a well-researched history and Norwich is quick to praise as well as criticize pontiffs. It’s quite shocking and amazing how some Popes lived, some of them very greedy, some practicing nepotism, some extremely anti-Semitic, some lecherous, etc. On the other hand, there were many very saintly ones, also.
The Protestants don't have a Pope, so any comparisons with Protestant clergy doesn't quite fit. There have been no ministers who have had the power and position even approaching that of a pope. And people like Jeffs are not Protestants. He has led a splinter group of Mormons who have a very different Christianity, of course - different scriptures, different prophet(s), etc.
 
I hadn’t really even considered the question of infallibility (I don’t believe any human being is infallible). But behaviour like what was being described certainly does point to someone being a wolf in sheep’s clothing.
The Apostles weren’t infallible when teaching, preaching, and writing the NT?

You belief means the Bible is fallible.
 
The Apostles weren’t infallible when teaching, preaching, and writing the NT?

You belief means the Bible is fallible.
What is being said is that fallibility is not a characteristic of an inanimate object, which is what “words on paper” are. The Bible contains no error…Therefore it is “inerrant”.
However -
The inerrant words of the Bible can be rightly understood by one person and wrongly understood by another…Just look at the whole “Rapture” thing…
Same Bible, Same words, different understandings…

The Church, God’s representative on Earth is the infallible teacher and guardian of the inerrant writings of Scripture.

Does that help?

Peace
James
 
Some of you seem to have confused the difference between infallibility (when speaking on matters of faith mad morals, something the non-exemplary popes never had time for) and impeccability (the freedom from personal sin, something none of us have). One can be sinful and still be infallible in teachings, and this is something that the promise of Christ has never failed in. The gates of Hell never prevailed against His Church, though constant assailing it.
 
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top