speaking in tongues

  • Thread starter Thread starter donna369
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This response follows my post 182
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=10966442&postcount=182

All Scripture quotes are from 1 Corinthians, Chapter 14, unless otherwise noted. I am using the bible link in post 171. nccbuscc.org/bible/1corinthians/14#54014001-1

After some thought, I think it best that I approach chapter 14, 1 Corinthians, from the Catholic Charismatic Renewal’s point of view. My source of information is the classic book A Key to Charismatic Renewal in the Catholic Church ISBN: 0-87029-033-9
by Msgr. Vincent M. Walsh. It is on line here.
brendancase.com/uploads/Key_to_the_Charismatic_Renewal.pdf

In the book’s Introduction to chapter four, there is this key sentence.
In this sentence the word mature refers to spiritually mature and not to age.

“A very important distinction is often overlooked between the power to pray in tongues, which seems to be enjoyed by almost everyone, and the charismatic ministry of “speaking in tongues,” which is used only by some mature members of the community.”

The Catholic Charismatic Renewal teaches the above distinction because Paul wrote about that distinction in verses 1 and 2.
“1* Pursue love, but strive eagerly for the spiritual gifts, above all that you may prophesy.a
2 For one who speaks in a tongue does not speak to human beings but to God, for no one listens; he utters mysteries in spirit.”

Notice the plural spiritual gifts which includes the gift of Prophesy. Skip to verses 3-5. for a clarification of Prophesy as one of the spiritual gifts
“3On the other hand, one who prophesies does speak to human beings, for their building up,* encouragement, and solace.b4Whoever speaks in a tongue builds himself up, but whoever prophesies builds up the church. 5Now I should like all of you to speak in tongues, but even more to prophesy. One who prophesies is greater than one who speaks in tongues, unless he interprets, so that the church may be built up.”

The gift of Prophesy is one of the nine gifts listed by St. Paul in 1 Corinthians, chapter 12. These nine gifts are considered charismatic ministries. Prophecy is when a person gives God’s message for the community or for an individual. This message is in the vernacular or native tongue of the assembled community. No need for an interpreter.

Verse 5 starts out with referring to praying in tongues. The reason we know it is praying in Tongues is the desire of Paul that all of you speak in Tongues. In the first quote above from the Catholic Charismatic Renewal book, there is this reference to praying in tongues."… the power to pray in tongues, which seems to be enjoyed by almost everyone."

While the grammar is a tad difficult to follow in verse 5, it also appears to refer to the gift of Interpretation and the gift of Speaking God’s message in Tongues because these two gifts are used to build up the Church.

Both gifts of Prophesy and Speaking in Tongues are to be discerned because they are directed to the community. Praying in Tongues does not need discernment because it is directed to God, the Ultimate Discerner. See verse 2 above.

Praying in Tongues is described in Chapter four of Msgr. Walsh’s book linked at top.
The nine classical gifts in Chapter 12 are explained in chapter five.

Believe it or not, one needs to actually follow the above, understand it, and use it to interpret the rest of Chapter 14. :eek:

As we struggle with this, we need to remember that the Corinthians were very familiar with the basic teachings of Paul in regard to the Holy Spirit gifts.

I will do my best to re-explain this when there are questions.
 
Here is what I struggle with when it comes to tongues. People seem to be making a distinction between different kinds of tongues, but based on what I read in Chapter 14, there seems to be one kind of “tongues” put to different uses. If that is, indeed, the case, then I can only see two paths to its correct usage.
  • Use it during personal prayer when moved by the Spirit to do so.
  • Do it in public when there is an interpreter present.
We have to remember that Paul is not writing to the Corinthians here praising their use of tongues, but actually trying to curtail its use. This part of the letter is one of correction and caution. I’m not trying to be too harsh of a skeptic, but I would be extremely wary of anyone claiming to be able to interpret tongues in this day and age. I can honestly say I have seen a man so gifted in a language he was able to spot interpret a foreign witness who was giving her testimony, but that’s about as close to a gift of “interpreting tongues” that I have run into. Everything else, I get flashes of the oracle and prophets of Delphi 😊.
 
Here is what I struggle with when it comes to tongues. People seem to be making a distinction between different kinds of tongues, but based on what I read in Chapter 14, there seems to be one kind of “tongues” put to different uses. If that is, indeed, the case, then I can only see two paths to its correct usage.
  • Use it during personal prayer when moved by the Spirit to do so.
  • Do it in public when there is an interpreter present.
The Catholic Charismatic Renewal teaches that Tongues is used as part of two different, separate gifts of the Holy Spirit. The Renewal sees a difference between communication with God (the common gift of Prayer Tongues) and communication with humans (the classical gift or ministry of giving God’s message in Tongues to the assembled group).

However, I have started exploring Tongues (one Tongues which is plural by its nature) which is similar to what you propose above as one kind of “tongues” put to different uses.🙂

Please take a look at 1Corinthians 12: 27-31 where Paul refers to varieties (plural) of tongues and then compare that with Acts 2: 1-4 where the inhabitants of the Upper Room began to speak in different tongues (plural) as the Spirit enabled them to proclaim.

The Catholic Charismatic Renewal recognizes* two distinct* manifestations of the Holy Spirit on Pentecost. Acts 2: 4 is the gift of Praying in Tongues and Acts 2: 6 is a “miracle of healing.” From chapter four, Praying in Tongues, “Scriptural Basis for the Gift.”
brendancase.com/uploads/Key_to_the_Charismatic_Renewal.pdf
  1. Are we somehow glossing over the Holy Spirit when we read 1Corinthians, chapter 14?
  2. Is the real key to Tongues the fact that we yield to the one Holy Spirit?
  3. Does the Holy Spirit have the power to give a variety of Tongues? 1Corinthians 12: 28
  4. To understand the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, does one have to begin with chapter 14, Gospel of John?
 
;)I want to be poster # 200

Does anybody notice that all posts on this forum are in a grey area? lol

Anyway,this thread is titled “speaking in tongues”. This gift must always have an interpreter or one is to remain silent.

What is being contested here is Christian ecstatic tongues,a phenomena that was not even recognized as related to what Paul was referring to in Corinthians until 1830.
 
cjforJesus;10972274 said:
What is being contested here is Christian ecstatic tongues,a phenomena that was not even recognized as related to what Paul was referring to in Corinthians until 1830./

QUOTE]

1830?

Many of the Church Fathers writings mention the charism of tongues and are dated prior to the date you give of 1830.

The early Church fathers didn’t write extensively about tongues probably because they had to deal with other issues of more importance.

St. Irenaneus (140-230) commentary on the Baptism of Cornelius by Peter in Acts:
earlychristianwritings.com/text/irenaeus-book3.html

There is also,

Tertullian (150-230) wrote against Marcion and mentions tongues:

earlychristianwritings.com/text/tertullian125.html

1830 comes much later don’t you think?
 
cjforJesus;10972274 said:
What is being contested here is Christian ecstatic tongues,a phenomena that was not even recognized as related to what Paul was referring to in Corinthians until 1830./
QUOTE]

1830?

Many of the Church Fathers writings mention the charism of tongues and are dated prior to the date you give of 1830.

The early Church fathers didn’t write extensively about tongues probably because they had to deal with other issues of more importance.

St. Irenaneus (140-230) commentary on the Baptism of Cornelius by Peter in Acts:
earlychristianwritings.com/text/irenaeus-book3.html

There is also,

Tertullian (150-230) wrote against Marcion and mentions tongues:

earlychristianwritings.com/text/tertullian125.html

1830 comes much later don’t you think?

According to the Pontifical council for promoting Christian unity , many scholars dispute these interpretations that the church fathers were referring to ecstatic tongues.Tongues is a language, Until 1830(why does that date ringa bell? 0h yes St Catherine and the Miraculous medal) the general consensus was that tongues is a language, not unknown ecstatic utterances.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top