W
Warandpeace
Guest
Sorry, it’s here, question 50 ccel.org/ccel/aquinas/summa.toc.html hope this helps
Sorry, it’s here, question 50 ccel.org/ccel/aquinas/summa.toc.html hope this helps
If it is for the purpose of bringing about new and more prosperous life, then yes. If you were cutting away the “bad branches”, certainly. If you were destroying indiscriminately and only for the sake of destruction, certainly not.That’s a creative use of language. If I caused the death of almost every living thing on Earth, would you call me a pruner?
cornbread_r2 said:(For the sake of discussion, I’ll go along with the notion that the serpent in Genesis is Satan, but that’s not what the Bible indicates. In fact, as I understand it, when Satan is identified as such in the OT, his role is more as a prosecutor (see Job) rather than as the embodiment of evil.)
I was not implying that God created evil.
The Catholic Catechism seems pretty clear that sin, death and our propensity to sin came about because of The Fall – a singular act of disobedience. Adam and Eve could have been tempted, by whatever, until the cows came home, but none of those things would have resulted if they hadn’t willfully disobeyed.
I agree with that. God could have done it any which way he desired, but He willed Satan to be the evil one and Hell to be his domain. Who are we to question God’s design?If Satan never fell from grace, God could have still created a place of eternal punishment for unrepentant human sinners. Satan’s existence is not a necessary condition for the existence of Hell.
Not everybody does. Look harder.I’m not seeing how evidence of a perfectly malevolent entity proves the existence of a perfectly good one.
Did you miss the last part of that paragraph from the CCC?Your last point here is one that I frequently read here and other places, including the CCC: that God permits evil to bring about a greater, future good. To me, that explanation not only seems ad hoc, but it implies that the means can be justified by the ends – a rationalization that is rightly condemned in all other situations.
…and it appears we’re back to square one. Let’s try it this way—>What would YOU suppose Satan’s purpose is?God’s current use for Satan isn’t obvious to me at all. Please elaborate if you care to.
Summa Theologica has a long discourse on angels (including Satan)If it is for the purpose of bringing about new and more prosperous life, then yes. If you were cutting away the “bad branches”, certainly. If you were destroying indiscriminately and only for the sake of destruction, certainly not.
You probably ought to go with the notion that the serpent is Satan, because the CCC 396-398 indicates so. You are right, Adam and Eve did willfully disobey God, but this was only after they fell to the temptation of the Devil.
I agree with that. God could have done it any which way he desired, but He willed Satan to be the evil one and Hell to be his domain. Who are we to question God’s design?
Not everybody does. Look harder.
Did you miss the last part of that paragraph from the CCC?
“It is a great mystery that providence should permit diabolical activity, but “we know that in everything God works for good with those who love him.””
That means that the answer to that question hasn’t been revealed to mankind in this lifetime, but we still must love and trust in Him. I’ll admit, it’s a tough concept to make peace with, but then again, Christianity is littered with mysteries that have no earthly answer. That’s where prayer, meditation and plain 'ol faith come into play. If God’s end plan for me is to dwell in Heaven with Him, then I really have no objection to the mean by which he executes that plan. Wouldn’t you agree?
…and it appears we’re back to square one. Let’s try it this way—>What would YOU suppose Satan’s purpose is?
integratedcatholiclife.org/2012/09/kreeft-the-winning-strategy-2/This is an awesome article by the great Peter Kreeft:
integratedcatholiclife.org/2012/09/kreeft-the-winning-strategy-2/
I urge you all to read it it is very good about what we are facing today as Catholics.
I fear you’ve misunderstood. I don’t believe in God. That God would sustain the existence of such an evil entity as Satan and permit it to wreak such havoc among his beloved creatures are among the reasons I don’t.If it is for the purpose of bringing about new and more prosperous life, then yes. If you were cutting away the “bad branches”, certainly. If you were destroying indiscriminately and only for the sake of destruction, certainly not.
You probably ought to go with the notion that the serpent is Satan, because the CCC 396-398 indicates so. You are right, Adam and Eve did willfully disobey God, but this was only after they fell to the temptation of the Devil.
I agree with that. God could have done it any which way he desired, but He willed Satan to be the evil one and Hell to be his domain. Who are we to question God’s design?
Not everybody does. Look harder.
Did you miss the last part of that paragraph from the CCC?
“It is a great mystery that providence should permit diabolical activity, but “we know that in everything God works for good with those who love him.””
That means that the answer to that question hasn’t been revealed to mankind in this lifetime, but we still must love and trust in Him. I’ll admit, it’s a tough concept to make peace with, but then again, Christianity is littered with mysteries that have no earthly answer. That’s where prayer, meditation and plain 'ol faith come into play. If God’s end plan for me is to dwell in Heaven with Him, then I really have no objection to the mean by which he executes that plan. Wouldn’t you agree?
…and it appears we’re back to square one. Let’s try it this way—>What would YOU suppose Satan’s purpose is?
I kind of had an idea this was the case, but I didn’t want to come outright and say it for fear of offending you. For the sake of curiosity, would you identify yourself as an Atheist? To me, the lines between Atheism and Agnosticism often blur. Have you come from any kind of Christian background?I fear you’ve misunderstood. I don’t believe in God. That God would sustain the existence of such an evil entity as Satan and permit it to wreak such havoc among his beloved creatures are among the reasons I don’t.
I sincerely appreciate that you’ve made the attempt to explain it to me, but if it all ultimately comes down to blind acceptance of mystery, then I reckon we’ve gone as far down this road as we’re able.
Have a good one.
Satan’s existence from a Jewish perspective:Why does God sustain Satan’s existence?
Because human drama is what life is about, ever since Adam made that decision.Why does God sustain Satan’s existence?
I figure Jesus defeated Satan’s ability to do evil, but there is still a great deal of residual evil. Sin entered the world through one Man, and through another Man we were saved from it. I feel like the Charlie Brown, or the Fall Guy. People can blame me for whatever they think somebody needs to be blamed for, and I’ll take it. I’m like the septic system of the Body of Christ at times.He taught them a lesson. “Consider the fig tree and all the other trees. When their buds burst open, you see for yourselves and know that summer is now near; in the same way, when you see these things happening, know that the kingdom of God is near.
Amen, I say to you, this generation will not pass away until all these things have taken place. Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will not pass away.
You wouldn’t have offended me in the least. As I steadfastly refuse to accept some theists’ assertion that people are atheistic simply because they want to be given a license to perform evil deeds and/or to be relieved of any responsibility for those deeds or just to spit in God’s eye, I’m not ashamed of my position.I kind of had an idea this was the case, but I didn’t want to come outright and say it for fear of offending you. For the sake of curiosity, would you identify yourself as an Atheist? To me, the lines between Atheism and Agnosticism often blur. Have you come from any kind of Christian background?
The main reason I’m here is to understand Catholic positions on any number of issues so that I don’t mis-characterize those positions.The fact that you’re debating this with myself and anyone else you may be speaking with here tells me that you’re looking for a definite reason to believe or not to believe in God.
All of those things at least have the potential to be understood. Religious mysteries seem to be designed to be forever beyond human understanding.There is so much of this existence here on Earth that is simple mystery. The demise of the dinosaurs… gravity… string theory… the big bang theory, etc, etc. Mankind has allot of ideas and conjecture as to what was the beginning and ending to the examples listed and many others that are not. I know these examples pale to the debate of whether God is present, but it’s still something to ponder.
As a great priest once said: “I’ve got a soul to save too.” Therefore, I cannot, in good conscience simply walk away from this without a second thought. I’ve been given the task as a follower of Christ to serve, though sinner (and a grievous one at that!) I am. If you wish to keep in contact, please, by all means respond here or PM me if you would rather go that route. If not, then at the very least know that my prayers are with you, whether or not you want or believe in them. May God bless you and enlighten you.
I don’t need to believe in prayer to be able appreciate good wishes from other people. Thanks-Kenny