Star signs

  • Thread starter Thread starter John_of_Woking
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

John_of_Woking

Guest
We had one of these ‘learning at work’ days. I went to a course and they asked us to say our birthday and star sign. I thought I’d go along with it. Even though I reject horoscopes. In a situation like that what would you do? It didn’t seem the time & place to delve into the topic of superstition. I did later say “I don’t believe in all that.” Did I sin. What would you have done? Is this scrupulosity on overkill ?
 
(as to sin… not being you it is difficult to say…on the subjective side…you will have to ask yourself what you judged at that moment…)

What I would have said? Well what I usually say…

“I do no believe in such things…my sign is the sign of the cross”
 
No you did not sin. Everyone knows about astrological signs these days. If you don’t take it seriously, it is not a problem, just like saying you were born in May or whatever month your were born in.
 
😉
We had one of these ‘learning at work’ days. I went to a course and they asked us to say our birthday and star sign. I thought I’d go along with it. Even though I reject horoscopes. In a situation like that what would you do? It didn’t seem the time & place to delve into the topic of superstition. I did later say “I don’t believe in all that.” Did I sin. What would you have done? Is this scrupulosity on overkill ?
Closest thing I have to that John, is choosing to participate something called Chinese Grab Bag (not my words) at the office Christmas Party. The idea of this is you pick a number and when your number is called you take a gift and open it in front of everyone else. The next person whose number is called gets to pick a gift of their own or take the previous persons gift. Most calls from the crowd are to take it form the previous person.

Some people find it good natured teasing. I find it horrible and far from the spirit of giving and I decline to participate each year. I don’t say why, I just watch while others participate.

You do not believe in Astrology so it is not sinful. Furthermore “Whats your sign” is also a more a very outdated pop culture converstation starter and nothing deeper than that.
 
Thanks for the replies. I think If it had been consulting horoscopes I definitely would have quoted catechism chapter & verse :)but the intention was to order a line of people in a queue in respect to their birthday. (Jan 1 - Dec 31). I just thought it didn’t warrant being un-co-operative at that point.

Bookcat - I wish I had your courage. That would have been a cool thing to do. I am doing the Padre Pio Novena every night - praying for the grace of courage.

Pray for me 🙂
 
We had one of these ‘learning at work’ days. I went to a course and they asked us to say our birthday and star sign. I?
Was this a class on how to cast horoscopes, or simply an ice-breaker to get to know people. Hardly a problem or moral issue to state your birthday. It is no more idolatry to refer to certain dates as being in one house of the zodiac than it is to state your birth day and month, since they also trace their origins to pagan religions and concepts. The constellations and zodiac signs are simple acceptable references to the position of the stars at certain times of the year and in common use by science. As long as you are not trying to forecast the future or worshipping the pagan deities invoked there is absolutely no problem. People who try to invent one are indeed being scrupulous.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top