In the context of a comedy show, on the one hand, I think it’s a bit funny to expect Colbert to take on the speaker in a way that isn’t appropriate to a comedy routine. On the other hand, as Chesterton points out, the opposite of funny is not serious, and every satirist is using humor for the purpose of what he sees as a serious end, which is to highlight what he believes are the unnoticed absurdities of a particular position. Colbert succeeds partially (the elephant analogy is very much the essential analogical attack on Erhman’s errors). He also ridicules what he believes are unreasonable positions held by Christians.
Anyway, a few points…
I find it quite sad that a not insignificant number of Catholics feel as if they’re on a leash, having to explain themselves to others as if they were clinching to something ridiculous or patently absurd, and then tribally hording together in fear with anyone that claims to be Catholic. So Colbert is vocal about his Catholicism (to whatever degree it exists — teaching Sunday school doesn’t mean anything, as I can rattle off a long list of clergy I’d like to see burned at the stake). So what? Following that kind of desperate, slavish reasoning, why don’t we agree with whatever a confident Pelosi says when defending abortion? Catholicism is not about a community of commiserating cowards. It’s about the truth. Now of course, this requires humility. If you don’t know the answer, or don’t understand it, then don’t pretend you do. But don’t accept an answer from someone just because they’ve got a cross pin on their lapel. That is NOT Catholicism, that is some weak, reactionary, denigrating attitude that doesn’t ennoble a man, but turns him into a depraved subordinate.
I recently saw a video of Colbert talking about Jesus and charity, and he managed to somehow warp it into a “proof” that socialism is the necessary outcome of Christianity. Not only is that a terrible conclusion, but he manages to politicize religion, which unfortunately is not uncommon (conservative or liberal alike). Talk about putting the cart before the horse. Not only that, but he seems to have a “rule-based” understanding of Christianity, and not one grounded in the transcendental of goodness. I suppose he can get away with teaching Sunday school, since you don’t need to have a very deep understanding of Christianity to teach it. I look back and cringe at some of the stuff propagated during my CCD classes.
Second, Erhman is doing what any provincial scholar does, he confuses substance with accident. According to his reasoning, if Mark were to report that Jesus was wearing a blue jacket, and Luke were to report that Jesus was wearing a tweed jacket, then shoot, we’re got a contradiction! Mark says the jacket IS blue, and Luke says the jacket IS tweed! Blue does not equal tweed! And to make things worse, John makes no mention of the jacket at all! Well, I think we can safely conclude that the gospels are just plain silly, I chide you affectionately, my children, for being so unreasonable.
Erhman, like Lutherans and the sola scriptura brigade, need a thorough dose of hermeneutics and tradition, because they sound like the New Atheists in their selective readings, complete disregard of context and tradition. “Hey, I’m 15 and I just discovered Nietzsche, even though I don’t understand him! Ha HA!”
Third, there is nothing uncommon about the association of Catholics with democrats. Whether it is a morally tenable position at the moment is another question, but historically, Catholics have been predominantly democrats because it was a more favorable party to support in a predominantly Protestant country in years past. Whether you can support Obama, well, I’m not putting my dog in that fight. I will just add, since we all know abortion is counter to teaching, that socialism IS NOT charity.